Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Classroom icebreakers

Two Truths and a Fib: Fact Detectives

A classroom-safe twist on the classic icebreaker: instead of sharing personal facts, teams play detective with sets of three surprising science and general-knowledge statements and must find the fib, giving a reason. Includes eight printable fact sets with explanations.

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Setup

  1. Arrange the class in groups of three or four and give each group a whiteboard or an A/B/C card set.
  2. Have the fact sets ready to show one at a time (cover the rest of the sheet if projecting).
  3. Draw a simple scoreboard on the board with a column per group.

How to run the activity

  1. 1Say: 'Each round I will show three statements. Two are true and one is a fib. Your team is a detective agency: find the fib and be ready to explain your reasoning.'
  2. 2Show Set 1. Give teams 60 seconds to discuss quietly and agree.
  3. 3On 'Reveal!', every team holds up A, B or C at the same time.
  4. 4Ask one team that chose the fib correctly and one that chose differently to share their reasoning. Praise good reasoning even when the answer was wrong.
  5. 5Reveal the fib and read the explanation. Award 1 point for the correct fib and 1 bonus point for a clear 'because' statement.
  6. 6Repeat for 5–8 sets, depending on time.
  7. 7Finish with the icebreaker round: each team writes its own 'two truths and a fib' about a topic (animals, space, sport, food), not about themselves, for another team to solve next lesson.

Learning outcomes

  • Use prior knowledge and reasoning to evaluate whether a statement is true.
  • Justify a choice with a 'because' statement.
  • Collaborate and reach agreement within a team.

Printable student sheet

Fact Detectives: Find the Fib

In each set, two statements are true and one is a fib. Circle the fib and write one reason why you chose it.

  1. 1Set 1: A) An octopus has three hearts. B) A group of owls can be called a parliament. C) Spiders are insects.
  2. 2Set 2: A) The Sun is a star. B) Sound travels faster than light. C) At sea level, water boils at 100 °C.
  3. 3Set 3: A) Bats are mammals. B) Botanists classify a tomato as a fruit. C) Penguins can fly.
  4. 4Set 4: A) The Pacific is the largest ocean on Earth. B) A hexagon has six sides. C) Mount Everest is in Africa.
  5. 5Set 5: A) Babies are born with more bones than adults have. B) The heart is a muscle. C) Blood travels around the body only once a day.
  6. 6Set 6: A) Spiders can make silk. B) Bees make honey from nectar. C) Frogs are reptiles.
  7. 7Set 7: A) There are 60 minutes in an hour. B) A leap year has 366 days. C) A decade is 100 years.
  8. 8Set 8: A) The Moon makes its own light. B) Earth orbits the Sun. C) Ice floats on water.
Show answers and teacher guidance
  1. C is the fib. Spiders are arachnids: they have eight legs and two main body parts. Insects have six legs and three body parts.
  2. B is the fib. Light is much faster than sound, which is why you see lightning before you hear thunder.
  3. C is the fib. Penguins are birds that cannot fly; their wings work like flippers for swimming.
  4. C is the fib. Mount Everest is in Asia, in the Himalayas, on the border of Nepal and China.
  5. C is the fib. Blood circulates around the body continuously, roughly once every minute when resting. (A is true: some bones fuse together as children grow.)
  6. C is the fib. Frogs are amphibians: they usually start life in water and have moist skin.
  7. C is the fib. A decade is 10 years; a century is 100 years.
  8. A is the fib. The Moon reflects light from the Sun; it does not make its own.

Variations

  • Personal-but-safe version: students write two truths and a fib about safe topics only, using stems such as 'My favourite book is…', 'I can…', 'I once made…'. Students choose what to share; nothing about family, home or appearance.
  • Topic review: write fact sets from your current unit to turn the game into revision.
  • Stand up, sit down: with no whiteboards, students stand for the statement they think is the fib as you read A, B and C.

Extension

  • Teams must also correct the fib, turning it into a true statement.
  • Students research (using class books) a surprising true fact to stump the class.

Additional support

  • Read every statement aloud and explain any tricky words (e.g. 'mammal', 'orbit').
  • Start with Sets 3, 6 and 7, which use the most familiar knowledge.

Extension challenge

  • Ask teams to rank how confident they are (1–3) and explain what extra information would change their mind.

Teacher notes

  • This version keeps the fun of the classic game but removes the pressure to reveal personal information, which can be uncomfortable in a new class.
  • Some 'truths' are surprising on purpose. Model curiosity: 'That sounds made up, but it's true! How could we check?'
  • A group of owls is often called a 'parliament'; this is a traditional collective noun, so accept that students may not have heard it.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More classroom icebreakers