English glossary Β· Year 3 to Year 12
Debate
What it means
A debate is a formal discussion in which two teams argue for and against a topic. Speakers take turns, following rules about time and order.
Examples
- Topic: 'That homework should be banned.' The affirmative team argues for it and the negative team against it.
- The third negative speaker rebuts the affirmative team's strongest point and sums up the negative case.
For teachers
In a school debate the affirmative team argues for the topic and the negative team argues against it, and each speaker has a role, such as defining the topic, presenting arguments, rebutting and summing up. Teams are often assigned their side, which teaches students to build arguments from evidence rather than personal opinion. In Australian and New Zealand school debating, adjudicators usually judge matter (content), manner (delivery) and method (structure), and debating builds research, listening and teamwork skills.
Common misconception
Students often think a debate is won by speaking loudest or attacking the other team. Debates are judged on the quality of arguments, evidence, rebuttal and structure, and speakers must attack ideas, not people.