Year 5 English lesson plan · More English resources
NAPLAN Persuasive Writing Review: Planning and Writing a Persuasive Text With a Model Response
A NAPLAN-style persuasive writing review: students unpack an original stimulus prompt about car-free streets, consider their audience, plan an introduction, reasoned body paragraphs, a rebuttal and a conclusion, and study an annotated model response for persuasive devices, cohesion and paragraphing before drafting their own opening. Includes practice tasks with answers.
- 60 minutes
- Year 5
- English
- Persuasive writing: audience, structure, persuasive devices, cohesion and paragraphing
- 🇦🇺 Australia
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Analyse a persuasive prompt to identify the topic, the task and the likely audience.
- Plan a persuasive text with a clear position, three reasons with elaboration, a rebuttal and a conclusion.
- Use persuasive devices such as rhetorical questions, high-modality verbs, emotive and inclusive language, and examples.
- Link ideas with text connectives and topic sentences, and start a new paragraph for each new reason.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can state my opinion clearly in the first paragraph.
- I can write a topic sentence that introduces one reason, then explain and give an example.
- I can use at least three different persuasive devices on purpose.
- I can answer an opposing view in a rebuttal paragraph.
- I can use connectives to link my paragraphs.
Curriculum focus: Literacy — Creating texts · Australian Curriculum v9.0
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
This is a review lesson written in the style of NAPLAN. It is not official NAPLAN material and does not use any official test items. Official information about NAPLAN, including example tests, is published by ACARA (the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority) on the national NAPLAN website. NAPLAN is held online, with tests in March, and covers reading, writing, conventions of language and numeracy. The prompt in this lesson is original. The qualities of writing described here are general features of effective persuasive writing, not the official NAPLAN marking criteria.
NSW and Victoria
- NSW: Stage 3 (Years 5–6) and Stage 4 (Years 7–8), NSW English K–10 Syllabus.
- Victoria: Levels 5–7, Victorian Curriculum 2.0 English.
Placement can differ by a year between schools, so check your school's scope and sequence.
Key vocabulary
- position
- The writer's opinion on the topic, stated clearly, usually in the introduction.
- audience
- The people the writer is trying to convince. Audience affects how formal the language is.
- topic sentence
- The first sentence of a paragraph that tells the reader its main idea.
- modal verb
- A verb that shows how certain or strong something is: might, could, should, must, will.
- rhetorical question
- A question asked for effect, where the writer expects the reader to agree, not to answer.
- rebuttal
- A paragraph that states an opposing view and then explains why it is weaker.
- cohesion
- How well the parts of a text link together, using connectives, pronouns and repeated key words.
In the glossary: audience, cohesion, connective, emotive language, modal verb, persuasive text, rebuttal, rhetorical question, topic sentence
Materials & preparation
You will need
- The stimulus prompt (in the Preparation notes), displayed and printed
- The model response (in the Preparation notes), printed with numbered paragraphs, one copy per student
- Highlighters in three colours
- A blank planning grid: Introduction / Reason 1 / Reason 2 / Reason 3 / Rebuttal / Conclusion
- Lined paper for drafting
- The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Display and print the stimulus prompt — 'Car-free streets': 'Imagine your town council is deciding whether to close one street to cars every weekend so that people can walk, ride, play and meet there. Some people think this is a great idea. Others think it would cause problems. What do you think? Write to convince a reader of your opinion. Before you write: plan your ideas; start with an introduction that states your opinion; write body paragraphs, each with one main reason and examples; finish with a conclusion that sums up your argument. Remember to choose your words carefully, write in paragraphs, and check your spelling and punctuation.'
- Print the model response — 'Give Our Streets Back to People': (1) Picture a Sunday morning where the loudest sound on your street is children laughing instead of engines roaring. I strongly believe that every town should close one street to cars every weekend and turn it into a place for people. A car-free street would make our community healthier, safer and more connected. (2) Firstly, a car-free street would get people moving. Many of us spend our weekdays sitting at desks, in classrooms or in cars. When a street is closed to traffic, families can ride bikes, kick a ball or walk the dog without worrying about cars. If the space is right outside our front doors, being active becomes the easy choice instead of the hard one. (3) Secondly, a car-free street is safer for children. On an ordinary street, parents must call out 'Car!' every few minutes, and games stop again and again. With the cars gone for just two days, young people would finally have a safe place to play close to home. Surely our children deserve that? (4) Most importantly, car-free streets bring neighbours together. Many people live next door to someone for years without learning their name. When the street becomes a meeting place, people stop to chat, share a game of chess or help a toddler learn to ride a scooter. These small moments build a community where people look after one another. (5) Some people argue that closing a street would make it hard for drivers to get around. However, only one street would close, and only on weekends. Drivers could easily use the roads nearby. A short detour is a small price to pay for a happier town. (6) In conclusion, a weekly car-free street would help us move more, keep our children safe and get to know our neighbours. Councils should stop asking 'Why?' and start asking 'Which street first?' Let's give our streets back to people.
- Draw the planning grid on the board.
- Write the warm-up sentences on the board (see Sequence).
Lesson sequence
- 1
Diagnostic warm-up
6 minTeacher
- Write three sentences: A) 'Maybe homework is kind of not great sometimes.' B) 'Homework must be limited because students need time to rest, play and spend time with family.' C) 'Homework is bad.'
- Ask: 'Which sentence is the most persuasive? Why? What is wrong with the other two?'
- Draw out: B states a clear position with a strong modal verb (must) and gives reasons. A is weak and unsure (maybe, kind of, sometimes). C is clear but gives no reason and uses a vague word (bad).
- Say: 'Today you will learn to write like sentence B for a whole piece.' Note which students chose A or C.
Students
- Choose the most persuasive sentence on whiteboards and give one reason.
- 2
Unpacking the prompt and the audience
7 minTeacher
- Display the stimulus prompt. Say: 'First, I find the topic: closing a street to cars on weekends. Then the task: convince a reader of my opinion. I must choose a side. I can agree or disagree; both can be convincing if I give strong reasons.'
- Ask: 'Who might read this? Who makes the decision?' Agree on the town council and the people in the town. Say: 'They are adults who care about their town, so my language should be polite and fairly formal, with no slang.'
- Model a 2-minute brainstorm in a T-chart: For (exercise, safety for children, meeting neighbours, less noise) and Against (traffic detours, deliveries, noise from crowds). Say: 'I choose the side with the strongest three reasons. I also note the best argument against my side, so I can answer it.'
Students
- Complete a T-chart of reasons for and against with a partner.
- Choose a side and circle their three strongest reasons.
- 3
Analysing the model response
12 minTeacher
- Read the model response aloud while students follow.
- Structure: say, 'Paragraph 1 hooks the reader, states the position (I strongly believe…) and previews three reasons: healthier, safer, more connected. Paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 each take one of those reasons in the same order. Paragraph 5 is the rebuttal. Paragraph 6 sums up and ends with a call to action.'
- Persuasive devices: have students highlight in one colour as you name them: the hook that paints a picture (paragraph 1); high-modality verbs (should in paragraphs 1 and 6, must in paragraph 3); inclusive language (us, our, Let's); a rhetorical question ('Surely our children deserve that?'); emotive language (laughing, roaring, happier); the rule of three (move more, keep our children safe, get to know our neighbours); everyday examples (kick a ball, walk the dog, a game of chess).
- Cohesion: highlight in a second colour: Firstly, Secondly, Most importantly, However, In conclusion. Say: 'These connectives guide the reader. Most importantly tells the reader this is the strongest reason, so I save it for last.' Point out that the conclusion repeats the three reasons in new words.
- Paragraphing: say, 'Each paragraph has one main idea. The topic sentence comes first, then explanation, then an example or a strong final sentence. A new reason means a new paragraph.'
- Say: 'Notice what the writer did not do: no made-up statistics. Examples from everyday life are honest and convincing.'
Students
- Highlight devices in one colour and connectives in another.
- Label the job of each paragraph in the margin: introduction, reason 1, reason 2, reason 3, rebuttal, conclusion.
- 4
Sentence-level practice
8 minTeacher
- Students complete practice questions 1 to 6 with a partner.
- Take quick answers for questions 2 and 4. Say: 'Changing one word, from could to must, changes how strong your argument sounds.'
Students
- Complete practice questions 1 to 6 with a partner.
- 5
Planning and drafting
20 minTeacher
- Students fill in the planning grid for their own side (5 minutes). Say: 'Write notes, not sentences. One reason per box. Add one example for each reason.'
- Students then draft their introduction and first body paragraph (15 minutes). Say: 'Your introduction needs a hook, your position and a preview of your reasons. Your body paragraph needs a topic sentence, an explanation and an example.'
- Students who choose the opposite side to the model (keeping streets open) can use practice question 8 as a starting point.
- Confer with individual students. Ask: 'Where is your position?' 'Which device did you choose and why?' 'Which connective links this paragraph to the last one?'
Students
- Complete the planning grid.
- Draft the introduction and first body paragraph.
- 6
Exit ticket
7 minTeacher
- Students swap drafts with a partner, who highlights the position and one persuasive device and suggests one stronger word.
- Students complete the exit ticket on their own. Use it to plan the next writing session, where students finish the piece.
Students
- Give a partner one specific suggestion.
- Complete the exit ticket.
Worked examples
Unpacking the prompt
Read the 'Car-free streets' prompt. What is the topic, what is the task, and who is the audience?
- Topic: whether a town should close one street to cars every weekend.
- Task: choose a side and convince the reader of that opinion.
- Audience: the town council and people who live in the town, who are adults, so the tone should be polite and fairly formal.
Topic: weekend car-free streets. Task: persuade. Audience: council members and residents.
Building a strong introduction
Write an introduction that hooks the reader, states a position and previews three reasons.
- Hook: paint a picture the reader can imagine: 'Picture a Sunday morning where the loudest sound on your street is children laughing instead of engines roaring.'
- Position, stated firmly: 'I strongly believe that every town should close one street to cars every weekend…'
- Preview the three reasons, in the order the body paragraphs will follow: 'healthier, safer and more connected'.
Paragraph 1 of the model response.
Building a body paragraph
Turn the note 'safer for kids' into a full persuasive paragraph.
- Topic sentence with a connective: 'Secondly, a car-free street is safer for children.'
- Explain the problem now: 'On an ordinary street, parents must call out 'Car!' every few minutes, and games stop again and again.'
- Explain the benefit: 'With the cars gone for just two days, young people would finally have a safe place to play close to home.'
- Finish with a device: a rhetorical question, 'Surely our children deserve that?'
Paragraph 3 of the model response.
Writing a rebuttal
Answer the opposing view: 'Closing a street would make it hard for drivers to get around.'
- State the opposing view fairly: 'Some people argue that…'
- Turn with a contrast connective: 'However,…'
- Give a reason the view is weaker: only one street, only on weekends, nearby roads are available.
- Finish by restating your side: 'A short detour is a small price to pay for a happier town.'
Paragraph 5 of the model response.
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Persuasive Writing Practice (NAPLAN style)
Use the 'Car-free streets' prompt and the model response. For multiple-choice questions, circle the letter of the best answer. For writing tasks, write in full sentences. Sample answers are given; other well-reasoned answers are also correct.
- 1(Multiple choice) Which sentence is the best opening for a persuasive text on this topic? A 'In this text I will write about streets.' B 'Every town should give one street back to its people every weekend.' C 'Some people like cars and some people do not.' D 'Streets are made of asphalt.'
- 2(Short answer) Rewrite this sentence with a stronger modal verb: 'Maybe councils could think about closing a street.'
- 3(Multiple choice) Which persuasive device is used in 'Surely our children deserve that?' A a fact B a rhetorical question C a simile D a statistic
- 4(Short answer) Rewrite this sentence using inclusive language: 'You should support this idea.'
- 5(Multiple choice) Which connective best starts a rebuttal paragraph? A Firstly B In conclusion C However D For example
- 6(Short answer) Replace the vague word 'good' with more precise, persuasive language: 'Car-free streets are good for towns.'
- 7(Short answer) This paragraph has two main ideas. Where should the second paragraph begin? 'Car-free streets help people exercise. Families can ride bikes and walk together. Car-free streets also help local shops. People walking past are more likely to stop and buy something.'
- 8(Short answer) Write a topic sentence for a paragraph that argues AGAINST car-free streets, about deliveries.
- 9(Multiple choice) The writer is addressing the town council. Which sentence has the most suitable tone? A 'Closing the street is a total no-brainer, guys.' B 'I respectfully urge the council to trial a car-free street this summer.' C 'Anyone who disagrees is silly.' D 'Whatever, just do it.'
- 10(Short answer) Write a rebuttal sentence to answer this objection: 'Shops on the street would lose customers.'
Show answersHide answers
- B. It states a clear position and makes the reader want to know why. A announces the topic without an opinion. C sits on the fence. D is a fact that is not related to the argument.
- Sample answer: 'Councils must close one street every weekend.' (Must or should replaces maybe and could, which sound unsure.)
- B. The writer does not expect an answer; the question makes the reader agree. A and D are wrong because no fact or number is given. C is wrong because nothing is compared using like or as.
- Sample answer: 'We should all support this idea for our town.' (We, us and our include the reader on the writer's side.)
- C. However signals a contrast with the opposing view. A starts the first reason. B starts the conclusion. D introduces an example inside a paragraph.
- Sample answer: 'Car-free streets make towns healthier, safer and friendlier.' (Precise, positive words tell the reader exactly why.)
- The new paragraph should begin at 'Car-free streets also help local shops.' The first two sentences are about exercise; the last two are about shops. A strong writer would also add a connective, such as 'In addition, car-free streets help local shops.'
- Sample answer: 'Firstly, closing a street would make it difficult for delivery drivers and tradespeople to reach the homes and businesses that need them.'
- B. It is polite, formal and makes a clear request. A uses slang. C insults people who disagree, which weakens the argument. D is rude and gives no reason.
- Sample answer: 'Some people worry that shops would lose customers. However, people who walk instead of drive are more likely to stop, look in windows and buy something, so the shops could become even busier.'
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Provide a planning grid with sentence starters: 'I strongly believe…', 'Firstly,…', 'Secondly,…', 'Most importantly,…', 'Some people argue… However,…', 'In conclusion,…'.
- Provide a word bank of high-modality verbs and emotive words (must, should, essential, vital, safe, healthy, peaceful).
- Allow students to plan with two reasons instead of three.
Core task
- Plan all six paragraphs and draft the introduction and first body paragraph, using at least three persuasive devices.
Extension challenge
- Write the rebuttal paragraph first, answering the strongest argument against your side.
- Rewrite the model introduction for a different audience, such as younger students, and explain what you changed and why.
- Use a range of sentence types (a short sentence for impact, a complex sentence with 'although' or 'because').
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Use the warm-up to identify students who write weak, unsure positions.
- Check practice questions 2, 4 and 6 for word choice, and 5 and 7 for cohesion and paragraphing.
- Check drafts for: a clear position, one reason per paragraph, topic sentences, at least three persuasive devices, connectives, and correct spelling and punctuation.
- Use the exit ticket to plan conferences in the next writing session.
Exit ticket
- Name two things a strong persuasive introduction should include.
- Rewrite this sentence to make it more persuasive: 'Car-free streets are nice.'
- Write a connective you could use to start a rebuttal paragraph, and one to start a conclusion.
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- Any two of: a hook that grabs the reader; a clear statement of the writer's position; a preview of the main reasons.
- Sample answer: 'Car-free streets are essential for healthy, safe and friendly communities.' (Any rewrite with a precise or emotive word and a clear reason is correct.)
- Rebuttal: However, / On the other hand, / Although some people believe… Conclusion: In conclusion, / To sum up, / Clearly,
Common misconceptions
- Sitting on the fence. Students give both sides equal weight and never state a position. A persuasive text takes one side and answers the other.
- More reasons are always better. Five weak reasons in one paragraph are less convincing than three developed reasons, each in its own paragraph.
- Making up statistics. Invented numbers ('99% of people agree') are not convincing and are not honest. Use everyday examples and reasoning.
- Insulting the other side. Calling people silly weakens an argument. A fair rebuttal is more convincing.
- Using connectives without changing the idea. Starting every paragraph with 'Also' does not create cohesion. Choose connectives that show order, importance or contrast.
- A conclusion that adds new reasons. The conclusion should sum up the argument, not start a new one.
Extension
- Debate warm-up: give a new topic (for example, 'Every school should have a class pet') and have pairs argue each side for one minute, then swap.
- Device detective: students highlight persuasive devices in a teacher-written advertisement or letter and rate how convincing each one is.
- Timed write: in a later session, students write a full persuasive text to a new prompt within a set time, then self-check against the success criteria.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
Printable worksheets
Interactive games
More lesson plans
Digraphs sh, ch and th: Hearing, Reading and Writing Words Like ship, chop and thin
A teacher-led phonics lesson for beginning readers: two letters, one sound. Students hear sh, ch and th at the start and end of words, learn an action for each sound, read and build short words such as ship, chop, thin and fish, sort words by digraph and write words from dictation. All practice is show-and-say, so it works before students can read independently.
High-Frequency Words: Sounding Out the Regular Parts and Learning the Tricky Parts by Heart
Students learn common high-frequency words, such as the and said, with a heart word routine: say the word, tap its sounds, match each sound to its letters and mark the tricky part with a heart. Regular words are sounded out, never guessed. Quick, active games build fast, accurate reading and spelling of the words.
Phonological Awareness: Hearing Rhyme and Clapping Syllables
A playful listening lesson for beginning readers. Students learn that rhyming words sound the same at the end (cat, hat), judge whether word pairs rhyme, make their own rhymes, then clap, stamp and use the chin-drop trick to count the syllables in names and everyday words. No reading or writing needed.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.