Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Year 6 English lesson plan · More English resources

Evaluating Online Sources: Who Made It, Why, When and Can I Check It?

Students learn to judge whether a website or online post can be trusted by asking who made it, why, when and what evidence it gives. They practise lateral reading (checking what other sources say), tell advertising from content, and learn why AI-generated text and images need extra checking, using invented websites.

  • 60 minutes
  • Year 6
  • English
  • Evaluating sources and digital literacy
  • 🇦🇺 Australia

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Evaluate an online source by asking who made it, why it was made, when it was published or updated, and what evidence it gives.
  • Use lateral reading to check what other trustworthy sources say about a website and its claims.
  • Tell the difference between advertising and content, and explain why AI-generated text and images need extra checking.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can find who made a website and explain why that matters.
  • I can work out the purpose of a site: to inform, persuade, sell or entertain.
  • I can check when a page was published or updated and decide whether that matters for my topic.
  • I can leave a site and search what other sources say about it and its claims.
  • I can spot ads and sponsored posts, and I know AI tools can make mistakes and invent sources.

Curriculum focus: Literacy · Australian Curriculum v9.0

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

Australian government websites end in .gov.au and many university websites end in .edu.au. A web address can be a helpful clue, but it is never proof that a page is accurate. The eSafety Commissioner's website has further classroom resources on online safety.

NSW and Victoria

  • NSW: Stage 3 (Years 5–6), NSW English K–10 Syllabus.
  • Victoria: Level 6, Victorian Curriculum 2.0 English.

Placement can differ by a year between schools, so check your school's scope and sequence.

Key vocabulary

source
Where information comes from, such as a website, book, video or person.
reliable
Able to be trusted to be accurate.
purpose
The reason a text was made: to inform, persuade, sell or entertain.
evidence
Facts, data or references that support a claim and can be checked.
lateral reading
Leaving a website and opening new tabs to find out what other sources say about it and its claims.
cross-check
To compare information with other independent sources to see if it agrees.
sponsored content
Material paid for by a company, often made to look like a normal article or post.
AI-generated
Made by an artificial intelligence tool rather than written or photographed directly by a person.

In the glossary: evidence, paraphrase, plagiarism, search engine, URL

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • Four website profile cards (see Preparation), one set per group
  • A projector or board to display the WHO-WHY-WHEN-EVIDENCE checklist
  • Optional: devices with internet access and your school's approved search tool, for supervised lateral reading
  • The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. Make the website profile cards (all invented for this lesson; the .example addresses are not real sites). Site 1 — www.superjuice-health.example: headline 'This green juice cures colds in one day!'; no author named; a large 'Buy now — 50% off' button; five-star reviews with first names only; no date; no references. Site 2 — www.coastal-research-centre.example: article 'Why sea turtles are threatened'; written by a named marine scientist with a short biography; published in the past year and updated recently; links to research reports and a government wildlife agency; an 'About us' page explaining it is a non-profit research centre. Site 3 — www.techtalk-daily.example: article 'The best phones you can buy right now'; author named; published more than ten years ago and never updated. Site 4 — www.space-facts-zone.example: article 'Astronauts can see the Great Wall from the Moon'; no author; the page has more ads than text; a comment box full of arguments.
  2. Write the checklist on the board: WHO made it? WHY was it made? WHEN was it published or updated? EVIDENCE: can I check it? CROSS-CHECK: what do other sources say?
  3. If students will search online, check your school's internet use policy and test your search terms first.

Safety

  • Follow your school's internet use policy during any live searching, and use the school's approved search tool and filters.
  • Remind students never to enter personal details on unfamiliar sites, and to tell a teacher if they see something upsetting.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: true or false?

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Read out three claims: 'Goldfish have a three-second memory.' 'Lightning never strikes the same place twice.' 'An octopus has three hearts.' Students vote true or false for each.
    • Reveal: the first two are false and the third is true. Ask: 'Where do false facts like these come from? Why do people believe them?' Say: 'The internet is full of claims. Today you will become a fact detective with a checklist you can use on any site.'

    Students

    • Vote on each claim and suggest why false facts spread.
  2. 2

    Explicit teaching: WHO, WHY, WHEN, EVIDENCE

    12 min

    Teacher

    • WHO: 'Look for an author's name, an About us page and contact details. Is the person or group an expert on this topic? Anonymous sites are harder to trust.'
    • WHY: 'Is the site trying to inform, persuade, sell or entertain? A site that sells a product has a reason to make it sound good.'
    • WHEN: 'Look for a published or updated date. For history, an older page can be fine. For technology, health or science news, old information can be wrong now.'
    • EVIDENCE: 'Does the page explain where its facts come from? Can you check them? Words like "miracle", "secret" and "they don't want you to know" are warning signs.'
    • Model the checklist on Site 1 (superjuice-health.example), thinking aloud: no author, selling juice, no date, no evidence, an exaggerated claim. Conclude: 'Not reliable for a school project.'

    Students

    • Record the checklist.
    • Help the teacher find the warning signs on Site 1.
  3. 3

    Lateral reading: leave the site

    10 min

    Teacher

    • Say: 'Fact checkers do something surprising. Instead of reading a site from top to bottom, they open a new tab and search for what others say about the site and its claims. This is called lateral reading, because you read sideways across many tabs.'
    • Model with Site 4. Say: 'I would search the claim "can you see the Great Wall from the Moon". When I check trusted sources, such as a national space agency or an encyclopedia, they agree it cannot be seen from the Moon with the naked eye.' If devices are available, demonstrate a supervised search.
    • Say: 'If you can't find any trusted source that agrees with a surprising claim, don't use it. One source is never enough for an important fact.'

    Students

    • Suggest search words for checking a claim.
    • Discuss what makes a cross-checking source trustworthy.
  4. 4

    Ads, sponsored posts and AI

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Explain that many sites earn money from ads. Some ads are clearly boxed; others are labelled 'Sponsored', 'Promoted' or 'Partner content' and look like ordinary articles. Ask: 'Why would a company want its ad to look like an article?'
    • Explain AI-generated content: 'AI chatbots can write text that sounds confident and correct but is wrong. They can even invent quotes, statistics and book titles that do not exist. AI tools can also make realistic fake photos and videos.'
    • Say: 'Treat AI answers as a starting point, not a source. Check every important fact and every reference in a reliable source before you use it.'

    Students

    • Share examples of ads they have seen that looked like normal posts.
    • Suggest ways to check an AI answer.
  5. 5

    Group investigation: website profile cards

    15 min

    Teacher

    • Give each group the four website profile cards. Groups apply the checklist to Sites 2, 3 and 4 and rate each as 'reliable', 'use with care' or 'not reliable', with reasons.
    • Prompt: 'Site 3 has a named author. Does that make it reliable for choosing a phone today?' 'Site 2 links to other sources. What would you check next?'
    • Students then start the practice sheet individually.

    Students

    • Rate each site with the checklist and give reasons.
    • Begin the practice sheet.
  6. 6

    Share and compare

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Each group reports one rating. Expected: Site 2 reliable (expert author, recent, evidence, non-profit, can be cross-checked); Site 3 use with care (out of date for this topic); Site 4 not reliable (no author, false claim).
    • Stress that even reliable sites can make mistakes, which is why we cross-check.

    Students

    • Report and justify ratings.
  7. 7

    Exit ticket

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Students complete the exit ticket. Finish any remaining practice questions for homework or the next lesson.

    Students

    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Applying the checklist

Evaluate Site 1: www.superjuice-health.example, headline 'This green juice cures colds in one day!'

  1. WHO: no author or About us page, so we cannot tell if anyone with health expertise wrote it.
  2. WHY: a large 'Buy now' button shows the purpose is to sell, so the site benefits if we believe the claim.
  3. WHEN: no date.
  4. EVIDENCE: no references; the five-star reviews cannot be checked and could be made up.
  5. CROSS-CHECK: health agencies explain that there is no cure for the common cold; most colds get better on their own within a week or two.

Not reliable. The site has no author, aims to sell, gives no date or evidence, and its claim is not supported by trustworthy health sources.

When the date matters

Site 3 is a well-written article about the best phones to buy, by a named author, published more than ten years ago. Can you use it for a report on today's best phones?

  1. WHO: a named author, which is a good sign.
  2. WHEN: more than ten years old and never updated.
  3. Topic: technology changes quickly, so a phone list from that long ago is out of date.

Use with care, and not for today's best phones. It might be useful for a report on how phones have changed.

Checking an AI answer

A chatbot says, 'According to the book Ocean Giants by Dr Mara Kell (2019), blue whales sleep for 12 hours a day.' What should you do before using this fact?

  1. Search a library catalogue or trusted search tool for the book and the author. Chatbots sometimes invent books and experts.
  2. Search for the fact itself in reliable sources, such as a museum, university or government wildlife site.
  3. If you cannot find the book or the fact in a reliable source, do not use it.

Do not use it until you can find both the book and the fact in reliable sources. (The book and author here are invented for this example, so they cannot be found.)

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Fact Detective: Evaluating Online Sources

Use the WHO, WHY, WHEN, EVIDENCE and CROSS-CHECK checklist. The websites below are invented for this activity.

  1. 1List the four questions in our checklist before you cross-check.
  2. 2Why does it matter who made a website?
  3. 3Name the four main purposes a website might have.
  4. 4A site selling running shoes says its shoes are 'the best in the world'. Why should you be careful?
  5. 5Give one topic where an old page could still be useful, and one where it probably would not be.
  6. 6What is lateral reading?
  7. 7www.animal-wonders.example says that 'bats are blind'. Describe how you would cross-check this.
  8. 8A post is labelled 'Sponsored'. What does this mean?
  9. 9List three warning signs that a site might not be reliable.
  10. 10Why should you check facts from an AI chatbot before using them?
  11. 11A dramatic photo of a shark swimming on a flooded city street is shared thousands of times. What should you do before believing it?
  12. 12Challenge: www.river-health-project.example has a named scientist as the author, a recent date and links to government water-quality reports. Is that enough to trust every fact on it? Explain.
Show answers
  1. Who made it? Why was it made? When was it published or updated? What evidence does it give?
  2. It tells us whether the author has expertise on the topic and whether they might be biased. Anonymous sites are harder to trust.
  3. To inform, persuade, sell or entertain.
  4. The site's purpose is to sell, so it benefits from making its shoes sound good. The claim is an opinion with no evidence.
  5. Sample: still useful — the history of ancient Rome; probably not useful — the latest technology, health advice or current events.
  6. Leaving the site and opening new tabs to search what other trustworthy sources say about the site and its claims.
  7. Search the claim in trusted sources such as a museum, university, zoo or wildlife agency. They show the claim is false: bats can see, and many also use echolocation.
  8. A company paid for it. It is a form of advertising, even if it looks like an ordinary article or post.
  9. Any three of: no author; no date; no evidence or references; exaggerated claims ('miracle', 'secret'); mainly selling something; lots of ads; spelling errors; reviews that cannot be checked.
  10. AI chatbots can produce answers that sound correct but are wrong, and can invent quotes, statistics and sources that do not exist.
  11. Check whether trusted news organisations or fact-checking sites have reported it; search for where the image first appeared. It could be edited, AI-generated or from a different event.
  12. It is a good sign, but not a guarantee. Even reliable sources make mistakes, so you should still cross-check important facts with at least one other independent source.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Provide a checklist card with tick boxes and simple prompts: 'Is there a name?' 'Is it trying to sell?' 'Is there a date?' 'Does it say where facts come from?'
  • Work with Sites 1 and 4 only, which have clear warning signs, before moving to the trickier Site 3.
  • Pair students so one reads the card and the other ticks the checklist.

Core task

  • Rate all four website profile cards with reasons and complete practice questions 1 to 11.

Extension challenge

  • Design your own invented website profile card (using a .example address) that looks reliable but has one hidden problem. Swap with a partner to find it.
  • With supervision, use lateral reading to check a claim from a current classroom topic and record which sources you used and why you trusted them.
  • Write a short guide for younger students explaining how to check whether a photo is real.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Listen during the group investigation for reasons that use the checklist, not just 'it looks good'.
  • Check practice questions 6, 7 and 12 for understanding of lateral reading and cross-checking.
  • Use question 10 and the exit ticket to check understanding of AI-generated content.

Exit ticket

  1. What does lateral reading mean?
  2. Give two reasons a website might not be reliable.
  3. True or false: if an AI chatbot gives a reference, the book or article must exist. Explain.
Show exit ticket answers
  1. Leaving a website to check what other trustworthy sources say about it and its claims.
  2. Any two of: no author; no date or out of date; no evidence; exaggerated claims; it is trying to sell something; it is full of ads.
  3. False. AI chatbots can invent references, so you must find the source yourself before using it.

Common misconceptions

  • If it is on the first page of search results, it must be true. Search results are ranked by many factors, and some top results are ads. Position is not proof of accuracy.
  • A professional-looking site is reliable. Anyone can make a polished website. Check who made it and what evidence it gives.
  • A web address ending in a government or education suffix is always right. These are good clues, but pages can still be out of date or misread. Cross-check important facts.
  • AI tools look facts up, so they are always correct. AI chatbots generate likely-sounding text and can produce errors and invented sources.
  • If lots of people share it, it must be true. False claims and edited images often spread faster than corrections.

Extension

  • Create a class display of the checklist with an example of each warning sign.
  • Before the next research task, require students to record the WHO, WHY and WHEN for each source they use.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.