Year 9 English lesson plan · More English resources
Year 9 NAPLAN Reading Review: Evaluating Arguments, Tone, Perspective and Figurative Language
A NAPLAN-style reading review with two original texts: a feature article about light pollution and a short literary extract about a girl leaving her grandmother's island. Students practise evaluating claims, evidence and rebuttals, identifying tone and perspective, and explaining the effect of figurative language, with answer explanations and an exit ticket.
- 60 minutes
- Year 9
- English
- Reading comprehension: evaluating arguments, tone, perspective and figurative language
- 🇦🇺 Australia
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Identify a writer's main claim and evaluate the reasoning and evidence used to support it, including concessions and rebuttals.
- Identify the tone of a passage and explain which word choices create it.
- Describe the perspective and narrative point of view of a text, and infer a character's or writer's attitudes.
- Explain the effect of figurative language, including metaphor, simile and personification, in relation to meaning and mood.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can state a writer's main claim and name the type of evidence used for it.
- I can judge whether evidence is strong or weak, and explain why.
- I can name a tone with a precise word and point to the words that create it.
- I can explain what a piece of figurative language suggests, not just name it.
- I can explain how a setting can reflect a character's feelings.
Curriculum focus: Literacy — Interpreting, analysing, evaluating · Australian Curriculum v9.0
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
This is a review lesson written in the style of NAPLAN. It is not official NAPLAN material and does not use any official test items. Official information about NAPLAN, including example tests, is published by ACARA (the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority) on the national NAPLAN website. NAPLAN is held online, with tests in March, and covers reading, writing, conventions of language and numeracy.
NSW and Victoria
- NSW: Stage 5 (Years 9–10), NSW English K–10 Syllabus.
- Victoria: Level 9, Victorian Curriculum 2.0 English.
Placement can differ by a year between schools, so check your school's scope and sequence.
Key vocabulary
- claim
- The main point a writer wants the reader to accept.
- concession
- Admitting that part of an opposing view is reasonable before answering it.
- rebuttal
- The writer's answer to an opposing view, showing why it is weaker.
- tone
- The writer's attitude, shown through word choice, such as wry, urgent, wistful or bitter.
- perspective
- The viewpoint from which a text or an issue is seen, including the writer's or a character's values and attitudes.
- personification
- Giving human qualities or actions to something that is not human.
- pathetic fallacy
- Using weather or setting to reflect a character's mood.
In the glossary: figurative language, metaphor, mood, personification, perspective, point of view, rebuttal, simile, tone
Materials & preparation
You will need
- Text 1 and Text 2 (in the Preparation notes), printed with numbered paragraphs, one copy per student
- Highlighters in three colours
- Mini whiteboards and markers
- A tone word bank on the board: wry, playful, urgent, measured, wistful, melancholy, bittersweet, hopeful, bitter, sombre
- The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Print Text 1 — 'Give Us Back the Dark' (a feature article): (1) Stand in the middle of a big city on a clear night and look up. If you are lucky, you might count a dozen stars. Drive a few hours away, beyond the last streetlight, and the same sky blazes with thousands of them, the pale smear of the Milky Way stretched from one horizon to the other. The stars have not moved. We have simply drowned them out. (2) Light pollution, the excess artificial light that spills into the night sky, is one of the few environmental problems that could be reduced almost overnight. Unlike plastic in the ocean, light does not linger. Switch off a light, and its pollution vanishes at the speed of, well, light. (3) The costs of an over-lit night are not only about missing the stars. Many animals rely on darkness. Some night-flying insects circle streetlights until they are exhausted. Newly hatched sea turtles find their way to the ocean partly by heading towards the brighter, open horizon over the water; near a brightly lit beachfront, some crawl towards the lights and away from the sea instead. (4) Supporters of bright lighting argue that it makes streets safer, and that argument deserves to be taken seriously. Nobody wants a pitch-black car park at midnight. But safety depends less on how much light we use than on how we use it. A shielded light that points down at the footpath lights the ground where people walk; an unshielded globe throws much of its glow sideways and upwards, where it lights nothing but the sky. (5) My neighbour, a retired electrician, swapped his porch globe for a shielded, motion-sensor light last winter. 'It's on when I need it and off when I don't,' he told me. 'And I can see the stars from my back step again.' (6) None of this requires us to give up the night-time city. It asks only that we light what we need, when we need it, and leave the rest of the sky to the stars.
- Print Text 2 — 'The Last Ferry' (a literary extract): (1) The ferry shuddered away from the jetty, and the island began to shrink. Ana stood at the rail with her hands in her pockets, watching her grandmother's house become a white matchbox on the hill, then a speck, then nothing at all. (2) All summer the island had been loud with gulls and generators and Gran's radio, which only ever played songs older than Ana's parents. Now the engine's drone swallowed every other sound. Behind her, a family argued cheerfully about sandwiches. Ana did not turn around. (3) She thought of the kitchen that morning: the kettle muttering on the stove, the screen door slapping shut, Gran pressing a jar of fig jam into her hands as if it were treasure. 'For the mainland,' Gran had said, the way other people might say 'for the journey to the moon'. (4) The wind dragged Ana's hair across her face. The sea, which had been a sparkling playground for six weeks, was the colour of a bruise now, heaving and sullen under a low sky. (5) She felt for the jar in her pocket, its lid cold against her fingers. Next summer, she told herself. Next summer was a long way off, but it was there, like the island: out of sight, but not gone.
- Write the tone word bank on the board, and the warm-up sentences (see Sequence).
Lesson sequence
- 1
Diagnostic warm-up
7 minTeacher
- Write on the board: A) 'The new skate park is a triumph: bold, generous and long overdue.' B) 'The new skate park has opened at last, only four years late and twice the promised cost. Bravo.' C) 'Everyone at my bus stop loves the skate park, so the whole town must love it.'
- Ask for whiteboards: 1) Give a precise tone word for A and for B. 2) What is wrong with the reasoning in C?
- Reveal answers: 1) A is enthusiastic or admiring. B is sarcastic: 'Bravo' says the opposite of what the writer means. 2) C generalises from a small, unrepresentative group: a few people at one bus stop cannot speak for a whole town.
- Say: 'Tone lives in word choice, and arguments live or die on their evidence. Today you will evaluate a feature article and analyse a literary extract.' Note which item caused the most errors.
Students
- Answer on whiteboards, using the tone word bank.
- 2
Strategy teaching: evaluating an argument (Text 1)
12 minTeacher
- Read Text 1 aloud while students follow with numbered paragraphs.
- Model finding the claim: say, 'A feature article often opens with a scene before the argument. Paragraph 1 paints the sky. The claim arrives fully in paragraph 6: we should light only what we need, when we need it. Paragraph 2 adds that the problem could be reduced almost overnight.'
- Model evaluating evidence: say, 'Paragraph 3 gives examples about insects and sea turtles. They are specific and relevant, but the writer gives no numbers or sources, so a sceptical reader might want more. Paragraph 5 is an anecdote: one neighbour's experience. It is vivid and relatable, but it cannot prove the change works everywhere.'
- Model concession and rebuttal: say, 'In paragraph 4 the writer says that argument deserves to be taken seriously. That is a concession. It makes the writer seem fair. Then But safety depends less on how much light we use than on how we use it is the rebuttal. Is it convincing? It offers a practical alternative, shielded lights, but it does not prove that shielded lighting is just as safe. A strong answer notices both.'
- Model tone: say, 'At the speed of, well, light is a joke. The pause in well shows the writer enjoying the wordplay. So the tone is wry and conversational, even though the topic is serious.'
Students
- Highlight the claim in one colour, evidence in a second and the concession and rebuttal in a third.
- Rate each piece of evidence as strong, medium or weak, with a reason, and compare with a partner.
- 3
Strategy teaching: tone, perspective and figurative language (Text 2)
11 minTeacher
- Read Text 2 aloud. Ask: 'Who tells the story? Is it I or she?' Say: 'It is third person, but we only see what Ana sees and feels. That is a limited third-person point of view, close to Ana.'
- Model figurative language: say, 'The house becomes a white matchbox. That is a metaphor. A matchbox is tiny and fragile, so it shows how quickly the house, and the summer, are shrinking away from Ana.'
- Model personification: say, 'The kettle muttering and the engine's drone swallowed every other sound. Kettles do not mutter, and drones do not swallow. The kettle makes the kitchen feel warm and alive in Ana's memory; the engine swallowing sound makes the present feel empty.'
- Model setting and mood: say, 'In paragraph 4 the sea changes from a sparkling playground to the colour of a bruise, heaving and sullen. The sea has not changed that much in a morning; Ana has. The setting reflects her mood. That technique is called pathetic fallacy.'
- Ask: 'What is the tone at the end?' Draw out: sad but hopeful, or bittersweet, because of 'out of sight, but not gone'.
Students
- Find one simile, one metaphor and one example of personification in Text 2 and write the effect of each.
- 4
Independent practice
22 minTeacher
- Students answer the practice questions. Say: 'For every figurative-language answer, use the frame: the image of ___ suggests ___, which makes the reader feel ___.'
- Work with a small group on the support task, rereading each paragraph aloud and using the tone word bank.
- After 15 minutes, go over questions 4, 5 and 8 with the class, asking students to explain why each wrong option is wrong.
Students
- Answer the practice questions and cite a paragraph for each answer.
- 5
Exit ticket
8 minTeacher
- Display the exit-ticket extract: 'The old fig tree stood guard at the school gate, its branches stretched out like arms to catch the falling rain. Every morning, Mateo walked beneath it and felt, somehow, that he had been counted.'
- Students complete the exit ticket on their own. Sort tickets into: all correct / argument evaluation errors / figurative language errors.
Students
- Read the extract and answer the exit-ticket questions.
Worked examples
Identifying the main claim (multiple choice)
What is the main claim of Text 1? A Cities should switch off all their lights at night. B Light pollution can be reduced by lighting only what we need, when we need it. C Sea turtles are the animals most harmed by artificial light. D Bright lighting is the best way to keep streets safe.
- Look for the sentence the whole article builds towards: paragraph 6, 'light what we need, when we need it'.
- A goes too far: paragraph 6 says 'None of this requires us to give up the night-time city.'
- C is one example from paragraph 3, not the claim, and the text never says 'most harmed'.
- D is the opposing view the writer answers in paragraph 4.
B. Light pollution can be reduced by lighting only what we need, when we need it.
Evaluating a concession and rebuttal
Text 1, paragraph 4: How effectively does the writer respond to the argument that bright lighting makes streets safer?
- Identify the opposing view: bright lighting makes streets safer.
- Identify the concession: 'that argument deserves to be taken seriously. Nobody wants a pitch-black car park at midnight.' This makes the writer seem fair.
- Identify the rebuttal: safety depends on how light is used, and shielded lights pointing down light the footpath without lighting the sky.
- Evaluate: the response is reasonable and practical, but it gives no evidence that shielded lighting is as safe, so a sceptical reader may not be fully convinced.
Fairly effective: the writer concedes the safety concern and offers a practical alternative, but supports it with reasoning rather than evidence.
Explaining a metaphor
Text 2, paragraph 1: Ana watches her grandmother's house 'become a white matchbox on the hill'. Explain the effect.
- Name it: a metaphor (the house is described as a matchbox, without 'like' or 'as').
- What it suggests: a matchbox is tiny and fragile, so the house is shrinking fast as the ferry pulls away.
- Link to mood: the summer and Gran are slipping out of reach, which builds a sense of loss.
The metaphor shows the house shrinking into something tiny and fragile, suggesting that Ana's summer with Gran is slipping away, which creates a sense of loss.
Setting and mood (multiple choice)
Text 2, paragraph 4: The sea changes from 'a sparkling playground' to 'the colour of a bruise… heaving and sullen'. What does this change mainly show? A A dangerous storm is about to hit the ferry. B Ana's mood has changed from happy to sad as she leaves. C Summer is over on the island. D The ferry is in deep water.
- The sea's description changes, but the text gives no sign of danger to the ferry.
- 'Sullen' and 'bruise' are words about hurt and bad moods: human feelings given to the sea.
- The setting mirrors how Ana feels about leaving (pathetic fallacy).
- A over-reads the weather. C and D may be true but do not explain the change in language.
B. Ana's mood has changed from happy to sad as she leaves.
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Reading Review (NAPLAN style)
Read Text 1, 'Give Us Back the Dark', and Text 2, 'The Last Ferry'. For multiple-choice questions, circle the letter of the best answer. For short-answer questions, write full sentences and give a paragraph number.
- 1Text 1 (Multiple choice): What is the writer's main claim? A Cities should switch off all their lights at night. B Light pollution can be reduced by lighting only what we need, when we need it. C Sea turtles are the animals most harmed by artificial light. D Bright lighting is the best way to keep streets safe.
- 2Text 1 (Short answer): In paragraph 2, what reason does the writer give for saying light pollution 'could be reduced almost overnight'?
- 3Text 1 (Short answer): Explain the effect of the sentence 'We have simply drowned them out' in paragraph 1.
- 4Text 1 (Multiple choice): Which word best describes the tone of 'its pollution vanishes at the speed of, well, light'? A wry B furious C fearful D technical
- 5Text 1 (Multiple choice): Which statement best evaluates the evidence in paragraph 5? A It is a personal anecdote that makes the idea relatable but cannot prove the change works for everyone. B It is scientific data that proves shielded lights are safer. C It is irrelevant to the argument. D It is the opposing view that the writer rejects.
- 6Text 1 (Short answer): Identify the concession and the rebuttal in paragraph 4, and evaluate how convincing the rebuttal is.
- 7Text 1 (Multiple choice): Which best describes the writer's perspective? A All night-time lighting should be banned. B Unnecessary light should be reduced, while useful lighting is kept. C The writer has no opinion on the issue. D Safety matters more than seeing the stars.
- 8Text 2 (Multiple choice): From whose point of view is the extract told? A first person, by Ana B third person, closely following Ana's thoughts and feelings C Gran's point of view D a narrator who knows every character's thoughts equally
- 9Text 2 (Short answer): Find one example of personification in paragraph 2 or 3, and explain its effect.
- 10Text 2 (Short answer): In paragraph 2, Ana 'did not turn around' when the family behind her argued cheerfully. What can you infer about how she feels?
- 11Text 2 (Short answer): Gran says 'For the mainland' 'the way other people might say for the journey to the moon'. What does this suggest about Gran's perspective?
- 12Text 2 (Multiple choice): What does the simile 'as if it were treasure' (paragraph 3) suggest? A The jam is very expensive. B Gran gives the jam with great care because it is precious to her. C Ana does not like fig jam. D The jar is buried in the garden.
- 13Text 2 (Multiple choice): Which word best describes the tone of the final paragraph? A bitter B bittersweet C terrified D triumphant
- 14Both texts (Short answer): Both writers describe the natural world. Explain how each uses it for a different purpose.
Show answersHide answers
- B. The article builds to paragraph 6: 'light what we need, when we need it'. A is contradicted by 'None of this requires us to give up the night-time city.' C is one example and 'most harmed' is not stated. D is the opposing view answered in paragraph 4.
- Unlike plastic in the ocean, light does not linger: once a light is switched off, its pollution disappears immediately.
- It is a metaphor: city light overwhelms starlight the way a loud noise drowns out a quiet one. 'We' makes people responsible, and 'simply' suggests the problem is our doing, not the stars', which sets up the argument that we can fix it.
- A. The writer makes a pun on 'light', and the pause in 'well' shows amusement, so the tone is wry and conversational. B and C do not fit a joke. D is wrong because the phrase is casual, not scientific.
- A. One neighbour's experience is vivid and shows the change is practical, but it is a single case. B: there is no data. C: it directly supports the idea of lighting only what we need. D: the neighbour agrees with the writer.
- Concession: the safety argument 'deserves to be taken seriously' and 'Nobody wants a pitch-black car park at midnight.' Rebuttal: safety depends on how light is used, so shielded lights pointing down can light footpaths without lighting the sky. Evaluation: it is reasonable and practical, which makes the writer seem fair, but no evidence is given that shielded lighting is as safe, so it relies on reasoning alone.
- B. Paragraph 6: 'None of this requires us to give up the night-time city… light what we need, when we need it.' A goes too far. C is wrong: the article argues a position throughout. D is the opposing view.
- B. The narrator uses 'she' and 'Ana', but we only see what Ana sees, remembers and feels. A would use 'I'. C: Gran appears only in Ana's memory. D: we never learn what the family or Gran are thinking.
- Sample answers: 'the engine's drone swallowed every other sound' makes the noise feel all-consuming and the present feel empty and lonely; 'the kettle muttering on the stove' makes Gran's kitchen feel warm, homely and alive in Ana's memory.
- She is sad and does not want to share in their cheerful mood; she wants to keep looking at the island and hold on to the summer for as long as possible.
- Gran sees the mainland as a distant, almost foreign place, far from her island life. The comparison is gently humorous and shows how much she cares, sending Ana off with something precious from home.
- B. Gran 'pressing' the jar into Ana's hands like treasure shows the gift has deep personal value. A takes the comparison literally. C and D are not supported by the text.
- B. 'Next summer was a long way off' is sad, but 'out of sight, but not gone' is hopeful, so the tone mixes sadness and hope. A is too harsh: Ana is not angry. C and D do not match her quiet reflection.
- Sample answer: Text 1 describes the starry sky, insects and sea turtles to persuade readers that light pollution matters and should be reduced. Text 2 describes the sea and the island to reveal Ana's feelings, using the setting to mirror her sadness at leaving.
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Read both texts aloud together and pre-teach excess, shielded, sullen and jetty.
- Give a claim–evidence–evaluation organiser for Text 1 with paragraph numbers already filled in.
- Give the figurative-language frame: 'The image of ___ suggests ___, which makes the reader feel ___.'
- Keep the tone word bank on the desk, with a short definition for each word.
Core task
- Answer all practice questions with a paragraph number for each.
Extension challenge
- Write a paragraph from the point of view of a shop owner who thinks bright shopfront lights are necessary, answering the writer's rebuttal.
- Rewrite paragraph 4 of Text 2 so the setting reflects a hopeful mood, then explain the word choices you changed.
- Suggest two pieces of evidence the writer of Text 1 could add to strengthen the article, and explain why each would help.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Use the warm-up to see whether tone or argument evaluation needs the most time.
- Check practice questions 1 and 7 for identifying the claim and perspective, and questions 5 and 6 for evaluations that weigh strengths and weaknesses rather than simply agreeing.
- Check practice questions 3, 9 and 12 for explanations of effect, not just naming a device.
- Check practice questions 4, 8 and 13 for precise tone words and correct point of view.
- Sort exit tickets to form reteaching groups.
Exit ticket
- Read the extract: 'The old fig tree stood guard at the school gate, its branches stretched out like arms to catch the falling rain. Every morning, Mateo walked beneath it and felt, somehow, that he had been counted.' Find one simile and one example of personification.
- How does the extract make Mateo seem to feel? Explain how the figurative language helps.
- A writer claims: 'Everyone I asked at the bus stop agreed the timetable should change, so the whole town wants it.' Explain one weakness in this argument.
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- Simile: 'its branches stretched out like arms'. Personification: the tree 'stood guard' (it also seems to count Mateo).
- Safe and that he belongs. A tree that 'stood guard' and seems to count him is like a protective person who notices him each day, so the reader feels he is looked after.
- It generalises from a small group that may not represent the town: only people at one bus stop were asked, and the writer does not say how many. It cannot support a claim about 'the whole town'.
Common misconceptions
- Agreeing instead of evaluating. 'Evaluate' means weighing strengths and weaknesses of the reasoning or evidence, not saying whether you agree.
- Naming devices without effect. 'It is personification' earns little on its own. Explain what the image suggests and how it shapes mood or meaning.
- Vague tone words. 'Happy' or 'sad' are too broad. Use precise words such as wry, wistful or bittersweet, and point to the words that create the tone.
- Third person means all-knowing. A third-person narrator can still stay close to one character, as in Text 2.
- Treating anecdotes as proof. A single story can make an idea relatable, but it cannot prove a general claim.
Extension
- Evidence ladder: give groups six teacher-written pieces of evidence for one claim (an anecdote, an expert quote, a statistic, a generalisation, an example, an opinion) and have them rank the evidence from strongest to weakest, justifying each placement.
- Tone shift: students rewrite a neutral teacher-written paragraph in three tones (wry, urgent, wistful) and swap for a partner to identify each tone.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
More lesson plans
Digraphs sh, ch and th: Hearing, Reading and Writing Words Like ship, chop and thin
A teacher-led phonics lesson for beginning readers: two letters, one sound. Students hear sh, ch and th at the start and end of words, learn an action for each sound, read and build short words such as ship, chop, thin and fish, sort words by digraph and write words from dictation. All practice is show-and-say, so it works before students can read independently.
High-Frequency Words: Sounding Out the Regular Parts and Learning the Tricky Parts by Heart
Students learn common high-frequency words, such as the and said, with a heart word routine: say the word, tap its sounds, match each sound to its letters and mark the tricky part with a heart. Regular words are sounded out, never guessed. Quick, active games build fast, accurate reading and spelling of the words.
Phonological Awareness: Hearing Rhyme and Clapping Syllables
A playful listening lesson for beginning readers. Students learn that rhyming words sound the same at the end (cat, hat), judge whether word pairs rhyme, make their own rhymes, then clap, stamp and use the chin-drop trick to count the syllables in names and everyday words. No reading or writing needed.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.