Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Classroom icebreakers

Would You Rather: Classroom Edition

Students walk to one side of the room or the other to answer light-hearted would-you-rather questions, then chat with someone who made the same choice. Fifteen low-stakes prompts with follow-up questions get a new class moving and talking.

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Setup

  1. Stick the A sign on one wall and the B sign on the opposite wall.
  2. Push chairs in and clear a walkway down the middle of the room, or run the game outside or in the hall.
  3. Choose 6 to 8 prompts from the printable. Start with the sillier ones (1, 2 and 9 work well).
  4. Write the three rules on the board: 1. Walk, don't run. 2. Every choice is a good choice. 3. You can always say 'pass' when asked to explain.

Safety

  • Insist on walking only, and keep the walkway clear of bags and chairs.
  • Limit the group moving at once if your room is small: half the class moves while the other half signals from their seats, then swap.

How to run the activity

  1. 1Gather students in the middle of the room. Say: 'I will read a would-you-rather question. If you choose the first option, walk to side A. If you choose the second, walk to side B. There are no wrong answers, and you don't have to explain unless you want to.'
  2. 2Run a practice round: 'Would you rather be a cat or a dog for a day? Cats to A, dogs to B. Go!' Wait until everyone has arrived, then praise the calm walking.
  3. 3Read the first real prompt twice. Give 5 seconds of thinking time, then say 'Move!'
  4. 4When everyone is on a side, say: 'Turn to one person next to you. Tell them your first name and one reason for your choice.' Allow 30 seconds.
  5. 5Ask one volunteer from each side to share a reason with the class. Then read the follow-up question from the printable and take one or two answers.
  6. 6Say: 'Anyone who has changed their mind may switch sides now.' Ask a switcher (if they are willing) what convinced them.
  7. 7Return everyone to the middle and repeat with the next prompt. Encourage students to pair with a different person each round.
  8. 8After 6 to 8 rounds, finish with: 'Put your hand up if you found someone who agreed with you on something surprising.' Take two answers, then return to seats.

Learning outcomes

  • Make a choice independently and give a simple reason for it.
  • Learn classmates' names and start short conversations with different people.
  • Show respect for choices that differ from their own.

Printable student sheet

Would You Rather: Classroom Edition

Choose an option and walk to side A or side B. Be ready to share your first name and one reason with the person next to you.

  1. 1Would you rather have a pet dinosaur the size of a cat (A) or a pet cat the size of a dinosaur (B)?
  2. 2Would you rather only be able to whisper (A) or only be able to shout (B) for a whole day?
  3. 3Would you rather live in a treehouse (A) or in a bubble under the sea (B)?
  4. 4Would you rather be a famous author (A) or a famous inventor (B)?
  5. 5Would you rather ride a dragon (A) or a giant eagle (B)?
  6. 6Would you rather sing everything you say (A) or dance everywhere you go (B) for a day?
  7. 7Would you rather have a magic pencil that makes drawings real (A) or a magic bag that can hold anything (B)?
  8. 8Would you rather visit the past (A) or the future (B)?
  9. 9Would you rather be the size of an ant (A) or the size of a giant (B) for one day?
  10. 10Would you rather have a pet penguin (A) or a pet sloth (B)?
  11. 11Would you rather have a day with no gravity (A) or a day with no night (B)?
  12. 12Would you rather be able to breathe underwater (A) or run as fast as a cheetah (B)?
  13. 13Would you rather write with your other hand for a day (A) or hop everywhere for a day (B)?
  14. 14Would you rather have lessons on a moving train (A) or in a treetop classroom (B)?
  15. 15Would you rather be the funniest person in the world (A) or the best puzzle solver in the world (B)?
Show answers and teacher guidance
  1. Follow-up: 'Where would your pet sleep, and what would it be good at?'
  2. Follow-up: 'Which one would make a normal school day harder? Why?'
  3. Follow-up: 'What is one thing you would need to bring with you?'
  4. Follow-up: 'What would your first book or invention be?'
  5. Follow-up: 'Where would you fly first?'
  6. Follow-up: 'How would your classmates react?'
  7. Follow-up: 'What is the first thing you would draw or pack?'
  8. Follow-up: 'Which time would you visit, and what would you want to see?'
  9. Follow-up: 'What would be the biggest problem? What would be the best part?'
  10. Follow-up: 'What would you name it?'
  11. Follow-up: 'What would you do first?'
  12. Follow-up: 'How could you use your skill to help someone?'
  13. Follow-up: 'Which would make you more tired, and why?'
  14. Follow-up: 'What would be the best lesson to have there?'
  15. Follow-up: 'How would your skill help your friends?'

Variations

  • Seated version: students hold up one finger for A or two fingers for B, then turn to a neighbour to explain.
  • Undecided zone: add a middle area for students who truly cannot choose; they must say what would help them decide.
  • Topic version: after a unit, use content prompts such as 'Would you rather be a plant or an animal for a day?' to review vocabulary.
  • Student prompts: in later weeks, students write prompts on scrap paper; you choose kind, classroom-friendly ones to read out.

Extension

  • Students write their own would-you-rather prompt where both options are equally tempting, and explain why it is hard to choose.
  • Count the students on each side for three prompts and record the results as a tally or simple bar graph.

Additional support

  • Show a quick sketch or picture for each option on the board for students who are still learning English or are early readers.
  • Let students move with a buddy for the first two rounds.

Extension challenge

  • Students must give a reason that considers someone else (e.g. 'It would help my team because…') rather than personal preference.

Teacher notes

  • This is a getting-to-know-you activity, so keep it fast and light. For a deeper reasoning version with debate frames, use the separate 'Would You Rather… and Why?' activity.
  • The prompts deliberately avoid family, home, money, food, appearance and anything a student might not have or might feel embarrassed about.
  • Never ask a student to explain their choice if they say 'pass'. Moving to a side is enough participation.
  • Inclusion: if any student cannot move easily, use the seated version for the whole class rather than singling anyone out.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More classroom icebreakers