English glossary · Year 6 to Year 11
Discussion
Also called: discussion text, balanced argument
What it means
A discussion is a text that looks at an issue from more than one side. It gives arguments for and against, then reaches a balanced conclusion or recommendation.
Examples
- 'Should school uniforms be compulsory?' with paragraphs giving points for and against.
- 'On the other hand, some people argue that homework takes away time for sport and family.'
For teachers
Discussions differ from one-sided persuasive texts because they present several viewpoints fairly. A typical structure is a statement of the issue, arguments for with evidence, arguments against with evidence, and a conclusion that weighs both sides and may make a recommendation. Language features include modal verbs, contrasting connectives (however, on the other hand) and an objective, third-person tone. Planning in a two-column 'for and against' table helps students keep the sides balanced.
Common misconception
Students often treat a discussion as a persuasive text and argue only one side. A discussion must present both sides fairly, and the writer's view belongs only in the conclusion, supported by weighing the evidence.