Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Year 10 English lesson plan · More English resources

Analysing News Media: How Headlines, Word Choice and Images Position Readers

Students compare two original news reports of the same fictional local event and discover how word choice, headlines, images and captions, and the selection and omission of facts and sources position readers. They check each report against a fact sheet, then write an analytical paragraph and a balanced headline of their own.

  • 60 minutes
  • Year 10
  • English
  • Media literacy
  • 🇳🇿 New Zealand

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Identify how word choice (connotation), headlines, images and captions shape a reader's view of an event.
  • Explain how selecting and omitting facts and sources creates a perspective, even when every sentence is true.
  • Write an analytical paragraph that explains how a news text positions readers, using evidence.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can find at least three loaded words in a news report and explain their connotations.
  • I can name a fact or source that a report leaves out and explain the effect of leaving it out.
  • I can explain how a headline and photo work together to frame a story.
  • I can write a paragraph using a claim, evidence (quotation) and explanation of effect.

Curriculum focus: Reading and viewing — critical analysis · The New Zealand Curriculum

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

Key vocabulary

perspective
The point of view from which a text presents an event or issue.
positioning
How a text leads readers to think or feel a certain way about a subject.
connotation
The feelings and ideas a word suggests beyond its literal meaning, e.g. 'bulldoze' versus 'replace'.
selection and omission
The writer's choice of which facts, quotes and details to include and which to leave out.
framing
Presenting a story through a particular angle, often set up by the headline and opening sentence.
caption
The words under a photo that tell readers what it shows and how to read it.

In the glossary: bias, caption, emotive language, perspective

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • The fact sheet, Report A and Report B (printed below in the worked examples; one copy of each per student)
  • Highlighters in two colours
  • The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. Print the fact sheet separately from the two reports. Keep the fact sheet back until the 'what's missing' phase.
  2. Write the two headlines on the board and cover them until the hook.
  3. Prepare a three-column table on the board: 'Technique', 'Report A', 'Report B'.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: one event, two headlines

    6 min

    Teacher

    • Uncover the two headlines: 'Parking Relief at Last for Millbrook Shoppers' and 'Kids Lose Courts as Council Paves Park for Cars'.
    • Say: 'Both headlines are about the same council decision on the same day. Write down what you think happened, and how each one makes you feel about it.'
    • Take responses. Ask: 'If you only read one of these, what would you think of the council?' Draw out that the same event is framed as a win or a loss.

    Students

    • Predict the event from each headline and describe the feeling each one creates.
  2. 2

    Explicit teaching: tools for positioning readers

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Introduce five techniques and record them in the table: word choice (connotation), headline and lead (the first sentence), selection and omission (facts and sources), quotes and who gets a voice, images and captions.
    • Model connotation: write 'replace', 'remove' and 'bulldoze' in a line. Ask: 'All three could describe the same action. Which sounds most negative? Why?'
    • Model selection: 'A report can contain only true sentences and still be one-sided, because of what it leaves out.'
    • Model images: 'A photo of a smiling baker and a photo of a child behind a locked gate both tell the truth about a moment, but they ask us to feel different things.'
    • Give the paragraph structure for later: Claim (what the text does) → Evidence (a short quotation) → Explain (the effect on the reader).

    Students

    • Record the techniques with an example of each, and rank the three verbs from neutral to most negative.
  3. 3

    Read and annotate the two reports

    15 min

    Teacher

    • Hand out Report A and Report B. Pairs read both aloud, then highlight positive or approving language in one colour and negative or critical language in the other.
    • Students fill in the table: for each technique, write one example from each report.
    • Circulate and prompt: 'Who is quoted in each report? Who isn't? What does the caption ask you to notice? Which numbers are used, and how are they described?'

    Students

    • Read, highlight and complete the comparison table in pairs.
  4. 4

    What's missing? The fact sheet

    10 min

    Teacher

    • Hand out the fact sheet. Say: 'This lists the facts both journalists had. Tick each fact that appears in Report A, and each fact that appears in Report B.'
    • Discuss: 'Which facts did Report A leave out? Why might it leave them out?' (The 5–4 vote, the 640-signature petition, the junior club moving to Eastvale.) 'And Report B?' (The cracked surface, the three hours of bookings a week, the traders' parking problems, the two hours of free parking.)
    • Point out: 'Neither report contains a false statement. Their perspectives come from selection, omission and word choice.'
    • Ask: 'What would a more balanced report include?'

    Students

    • Check each report against the fact sheet and discuss the effect of what was left out.
  5. 5

    Independent practice

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Students complete the practice sheet, including writing one analytical paragraph and one balanced headline.
    • Work with a small group on the additional support task, using the paragraph frame.

    Students

    • Answer the practice questions and write an analytical paragraph.
  6. 6

    Exit ticket

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Students complete the exit ticket individually. Sort into secure / nearly / not yet to plan the next lesson on analysing a full media text.

    Students

    • Answer the exit ticket on their own.

Worked examples

The fact sheet (what both journalists knew)

Read the facts about the Millbrook Park decision.

  1. On Tuesday, Millbrook Council voted 5–4 to turn two tennis courts at Millbrook Park into a 40-space car park.
  2. The project will cost $180,000. Work is expected to begin in March.
  3. The courts were built in 1978 and their surface is cracked. Council booking records show the courts are used for an average of 3 hours a week.
  4. Main Street shop owners say customers struggle to find parking on weekends. The car park will offer 2 hours of free parking.
  5. A petition against the plan was signed by 640 people.
  6. The Millbrook junior tennis club (35 members) will move to the Eastvale courts, 4 km away.

Use this sheet to check what each report includes and leaves out.

Report A

Headline: Parking Relief at Last for Millbrook Shoppers. Photo: a smiling baker standing outside her shop. Caption: 'Main Street baker Rosa Nguyen is looking forward to busier Saturdays.'

  1. Weekend shoppers in Millbrook will soon find it easier to park after the council approved a new 40-space car park at Millbrook Park on Tuesday.
  2. The $180,000 project will replace two cracked, rarely used tennis courts, which council figures show are booked for an average of just three hours a week.
  3. 'Customers tell me every Saturday they've circled the block three times and given up,' said Main Street baker Rosa Nguyen, who has run her shop for 15 years. 'This will bring life back to our street.'
  4. The car park will offer two hours of free parking. Work is expected to begin in March.

Perspective: the decision is a sensible improvement that helps shoppers and local business.

Report B

Headline: Kids Lose Courts as Council Paves Park for Cars. Photo: a child holding a racquet behind a locked gate. Caption: 'Locked out: junior players face a 4 km trip to keep playing.'

  1. Millbrook's junior tennis players will be forced out of their home courts after a divided council voted 5–4 on Tuesday to bulldoze two tennis courts at Millbrook Park to make way for a car park.
  2. More than 600 residents signed a petition against the plan.
  3. 'Thirty-five kids learned to play here. Now they'll have to travel 4 km to Eastvale, and plenty of families can't manage that,' said junior coach Daniel Okafor.
  4. The council will spend $180,000 of ratepayers' money on the project.

Perspective: the decision is an unfair loss for children and the community, pushed through against public opinion.

Model analytical paragraph

Explain how Report B uses word choice to position readers against the council's decision.

  1. Claim: Report B uses emotive verbs to present the council's decision as aggressive and uncaring.
  2. Evidence: The council voted to 'bulldoze' the courts, and the junior players will be 'forced out' of their 'home courts'.
  3. Explain: 'Bulldoze' suggests destruction rather than planned change, while 'forced out' and 'home' frame the children as victims losing something that belongs to them. Readers are led to sympathise with the players and see the council as heavy-handed, even though the report never directly says the decision is wrong.

Report B uses emotive verbs to present the decision as aggressive: the council will 'bulldoze' the courts and players will be 'forced out' of their 'home courts'. These words suggest destruction and loss, positioning readers to sympathise with the children and see the council as heavy-handed, without the report ever stating an opinion directly.

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Positioning Readers: Practice

Use Report A, Report B and the fact sheet. Quote short phrases as evidence. Question 8 is a full paragraph.

  1. 1Report A describes the courts as 'cracked, rarely used'. What effect do these words have on how readers see the loss of the courts?
  2. 2Report B uses 'bulldoze' where Report A uses 'replace'. Explain the difference in connotation.
  3. 3List two facts from the fact sheet that Report A leaves out, and explain why leaving them out supports its perspective.
  4. 4List two facts from the fact sheet that Report B leaves out, and explain the effect.
  5. 5The fact sheet says 640 people signed the petition. Report B says 'more than 600 residents'. Is this accurate? Why might the writer choose this wording?
  6. 6Who is quoted in each report? What does this choice of sources do?
  7. 7Explain how the photo and caption in Report B work together with the headline.
  8. 8Write an analytical paragraph (claim, evidence, explain) on how Report A positions readers to support the decision.
  9. 9Write a balanced headline for the story (no more than 10 words).
Show answers
  1. They make the courts sound worthless and neglected, so losing them seems like no loss at all. Readers are positioned to accept the decision as sensible.
  2. 'Replace' is neutral and suggests swapping one thing for something useful. 'Bulldoze' suggests force and destruction, making the council seem aggressive and the loss feel violent.
  3. Any two: the 5–4 vote; the 640-signature petition; the 35-member junior club moving 4 km to Eastvale. Leaving them out hides the disagreement and the people who lose out, so the decision appears popular and costless.
  4. Any two: the cracked surface; the average of 3 hours of bookings a week; traders' parking problems; the 2 hours of free parking; the March start. Leaving them out hides the reasons for the decision and its benefits, so it appears unjustified.
  5. It is accurate (640 is more than 600). Rounding to 'more than 600' sounds large and memorable, and calling them 'residents' makes the opposition sound like the local community as a whole, although the fact sheet doesn't say whether every signer lives in Millbrook.
  6. Report A quotes only a Main Street baker, who supports the car park; Report B quotes only a junior coach, who opposes it. Each report gives a voice to one side only, so readers hear one perspective as if it were the main one.
  7. The headline 'Kids Lose Courts' sets up children as the losers; the photo of a child behind a locked gate shows that loss visually; the caption 'Locked out' repeats the idea of exclusion. Together they create sympathy before readers reach the facts.
  8. Sample: Report A positions readers to see the car park as a welcome fix for a real problem. Its headline promises 'Parking Relief at Last', framing the decision as an answer to long frustration, and it quotes a baker of 15 years who says customers have 'circled the block three times and given up'. The only voice is a long-standing local business owner, which makes the benefit seem personal and trustworthy, while the description of the courts as 'cracked, rarely used' suggests nothing of value is lost. Omitting the 5–4 vote and the petition hides any disagreement.
  9. Sample: 'Council Votes 5–4 to Turn Tennis Courts into Car Park'. A balanced headline states what happened, avoids loaded words, and doesn't frame either side as winners or losers.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Pre-highlight five loaded words in each report and ask students to explain only their connotations.
  • Give a paragraph frame: 'Report ___ uses ___ to make readers feel ___. For example, ___. This suggests ___.'
  • Use a fact sheet checklist with tick boxes for Report A and Report B.

Core task

  • Complete all practice questions, including the analytical paragraph and balanced headline.

Extension challenge

  • Rewrite Report B as a balanced report of about 120 words that includes both perspectives, then explain three changes you made.
  • Write a third report from the junior tennis club's newsletter and explain how its purpose and audience shape its perspective.
  • Discuss: is a completely neutral news report possible? Use evidence from both reports.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Check the comparison table: are the examples matched to the right technique?
  • Use practice questions 3 and 4 to check understanding of selection and omission.
  • Assess the analytical paragraph for a clear claim, an embedded quotation and an explanation of effect on readers.
  • Sort exit tickets into secure / nearly / not yet.

Exit ticket

  1. Explain how a news report can position readers even if every sentence in it is true.
  2. Choose one word from either report, state its connotation, and explain its effect on readers.
Show exit ticket answers
  1. Through selection and omission (choosing which facts and sources to include), word choice with strong connotations, the headline and lead, and images and captions. These shape what readers notice and feel without any false statements.
  2. Sample: 'forced out' (Report B) suggests the children are victims of an unfair decision made against their will, positioning readers to sympathise with them and oppose the council.

Common misconceptions

  • Bias means lying. Students often think a biased report contains false information. Show that both reports are factually accurate and that perspective comes from selection, omission and language.
  • Listing techniques without effects. 'The writer uses emotive language' is not analysis. Always ask: 'Which words? What do they make the reader think or feel?'
  • Images are neutral evidence. Photos are chosen, cropped and captioned. Ask: 'What else could the photographer have shown?'

Extension

  • Headline swap: students rewrite a neutral headline from a class newsletter to favour one side, then to favour the other, and explain the words they changed.
  • Image framing: students describe two different photos that could illustrate the same school event to create opposite impressions.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.