Year 4 English lesson plan · More English resources
Persuasive Writing: Should Our School Have a Class Pet?
Students unpack a model persuasive text, learn the structure (opinion, three reasons with evidence, conclusion) and persuasive language features, then plan and write their own persuasive piece on whether the school should have a class pet.
- 60 minutes
- Year 4
- English
- Persuasive writing
- 🇳🇿 New Zealand
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Identify the structure of a persuasive text: opinion, reasons with evidence, conclusion.
- Use persuasive language features: strong modal verbs, emotive words, rhetorical questions and linking words.
- Plan and write a persuasive text with a clear opinion and three supported reasons.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can state my opinion clearly in my introduction.
- I can give three reasons and back each one up with an example or evidence.
- I can use at least three persuasive language features.
- I can finish with a conclusion that restates my opinion.
Curriculum focus: Writing · The New Zealand Curriculum
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
Key vocabulary
- persuade
- To try to make someone agree with you or do something.
- opinion
- What you think or believe about something. Others might disagree.
- reason
- Why you think something.
- evidence
- Facts, examples or experiences that back up a reason.
- modal verb
- A word that shows how strongly we mean something, e.g. must, should, could, might.
- rhetorical question
- A question asked to make the reader think, not to get an answer, e.g. 'Who wouldn't want a happier classroom?'
- conclusion
- The final paragraph that sums up the reasons and repeats the opinion.
In the glossary: conclusion, emotive language, evidence, modal verb, persuasive text, rhetorical question
Materials & preparation
You will need
- The model persuasive text (Worked example 1), displayed and printed one per pair
- Highlighters in three colours
- Persuasive planning sheet (opinion box, three reason boxes each with an evidence line, conclusion box)
- A 'persuasive language toolkit' chart: modal verbs, emotive words, rhetorical questions, linking words
- Writing books or lined paper
- The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Print the model text (one per pair) and the planning sheet (one per student).
- Draw the four-box 'persuasive hamburger' on the board: top bun = opinion, three fillings = reasons and evidence, bottom bun = conclusion.
- Prepare the persuasive language toolkit chart.
- Check your school's policy on class pets so you can answer questions honestly; this lesson is a writing task, not a real decision.
Lesson sequence
- 1
Hook: agree or disagree line
6 minTeacher
- Mark one side of the room 'Strongly agree' and the other 'Strongly disagree'.
- Read statements and have students move to show their opinion: 'Lunchtime should be longer.' 'Homework should be banned.' 'Our school should have a class pet.'
- After the last statement, ask one student from each side: 'Why are you standing there? Convince someone to move.'
- Say: 'When you tried to make someone move, you were persuading. Today you'll learn to do that in writing, where the reader can't hear your voice.'
Students
- Move to show their opinion.
- Give a reason for their position.
- 2
Deconstruct the model text
12 minTeacher
- Display the model text (Worked example 1) and read it aloud.
- Ask: 'What does the writer want us to think? Where do they tell us?' Highlight the opinion in yellow.
- Ask: 'How many reasons do they give?' Highlight each reason in green. Then: 'How do they prove each reason?' Highlight evidence in blue.
- Point out the conclusion: 'The writer reminds us of the reasons and says the opinion again, even more strongly.'
- Go through the toolkit chart, finding an example of each feature in the model: 'should', 'must' (modal verbs); 'calm, happy' (emotive words); 'Who wouldn't…?' (rhetorical question); 'Firstly, In addition, Finally, For these reasons' (linking words).
Students
- In pairs, highlight their own copy as the teacher models.
- Find and point to examples of each persuasive feature.
- 3
Shared planning
10 minTeacher
- Say: 'Now we'll plan the OTHER side together: our school should NOT have a class pet.' (This stops students copying the model.)
- Take suggestions for reasons (weekends and holidays, allergies, cost, the animal's wellbeing) and choose the three strongest. Ask: 'Which reason would convince a principal most?'
- For each reason, ask: 'What example or evidence could we give?' Record on the hamburger plan.
- Model turning one plan box into a paragraph (see Worked example 2).
- Tell students they may now choose either side for their own writing.
Students
- Suggest reasons and evidence.
- Choose their own side and start filling in their planning sheet.
- 4
Independent writing
22 minTeacher
- Students finish their plan (5 minutes) and then write their persuasive text.
- Set the expectation: introduction with opinion, three reason paragraphs with evidence, conclusion.
- Conference with individuals: 'Read me your strongest reason. How could you make it even more convincing?'
- At the halfway point, pause the class and ask everyone to check they have used at least one modal verb and one linking word.
- Support group: work with students using the paragraph frames (see Differentiation).
Students
- Plan, then write their persuasive text.
- Tick off persuasive features on the toolkit chart as they use them.
- 5
Share and exit ticket
10 minTeacher
- Pairs swap writing and give 'two stars and a wish': two persuasive features that worked and one suggestion.
- Invite two students (one from each side) to read their conclusions aloud. Ask the class: 'Which conclusion persuaded you more, and why?'
- Students complete the exit ticket individually.
Students
- Give and receive peer feedback.
- Complete the exit ticket.
Worked examples
Model persuasive text and how it was built
Every Classroom Needs a Pet. I strongly believe our school should have a class pet. A pet would teach us responsibility, help us learn about living things and make our classroom a calmer place. Firstly, a class pet would teach students to be responsible. Every day, someone would have to feed it, give it fresh water and clean its home. For example, a roster could give every student a turn, so everyone learns how to care for another living thing. In addition, a pet would help us learn. We could observe how it eats, sleeps and grows, and record what we notice. This is real learning that you cannot get from a book. Finally, a pet would make our classroom calmer and happier. Many people feel relaxed when they watch fish swim or stroke a soft guinea pig. Who wouldn't want a happier classroom? For these reasons, our school must get a class pet. It would make us more responsible, help us learn and bring calm to every day.
- Introduction: the first sentence states the opinion ('I strongly believe…'). The second sentence previews all three reasons, so the reader knows what is coming.
- Reason 1 paragraph: starts with a linking word (Firstly) and the reason in one clear sentence, then gives evidence (what students would do every day) and an example (a roster).
- Reason 2 paragraph: 'In addition' links it to the first reason; the evidence is what students could observe and record.
- Reason 3 paragraph: 'Finally' signals the last reason; a rhetorical question ('Who wouldn't want…?') makes the reader agree in their head.
- Conclusion: 'For these reasons' sums up; the modal verb changes from 'should' to the stronger 'must', and the three reasons are repeated in a shorter form.
- Language choices: emotive words (calmer, happier, soft, relaxed), modal verbs (should, must, would), linking words (Firstly, In addition, Finally, For these reasons).
Structure: opinion → reason 1 + evidence → reason 2 + evidence → reason 3 + evidence → conclusion. Persuasive features: modal verbs, emotive words, a rhetorical question, linking words.
Turning a plan into a paragraph (opposing side)
Plan box: Reason — 'Nobody to look after it in the holidays.' Evidence — 'School is closed for weeks at a time; a pet needs care every single day.'
- Start with a linking word and turn the reason into a strong statement: 'Firstly, a class pet would have nobody to care for it during the holidays.'
- Add the evidence: 'Our school is closed for weeks at a time, but an animal needs food, water and attention every single day.'
- Add an example or a 'what if': 'If a family forgot to feed it, or went away, the pet could become sick.'
- Finish with a punchy sentence that links back to the opinion and uses a modal verb or emotive language: 'It would be unfair to bring an animal into a place where it could be left alone.'
Firstly, a class pet would have nobody to care for it during the holidays. Our school is closed for weeks at a time, but an animal needs food, water and attention every single day. If a family forgot to feed it, or went away, the pet could become sick. It would be unfair to bring an animal into a place where it could be left alone.
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Persuasive Writing Practice
Answer questions 1–7 before you write. Question 8 is your own persuasive paragraph.
- 1Which sentence is an opinion? (a) Guinea pigs eat hay. (b) Guinea pigs are the best class pets.
- 2Put these modal verbs in order from weakest to strongest: must, might, should.
- 3Rewrite to make it more persuasive: 'It would be good to have a pet.'
- 4Write a rhetorical question to persuade people that a class pet would be fun.
- 5Give one piece of evidence for this reason: 'A class pet would help us learn.'
- 6Circle the linking words: 'Firstly, pets are fun. In addition, they teach responsibility. Finally, they keep us calm.'
- 7What two jobs does a conclusion do?
- 8Write one full reason paragraph for your side: a linking word, the reason, evidence or an example, and a final punchy sentence.
Show answersHide answers
- (b) Guinea pigs are the best class pets.
- might, should, must
- Example: 'Having a class pet would be a fantastic experience for every student.' (Accept any version with a stronger modal verb or emotive language.)
- Example: 'Who wouldn't love to start each morning with a furry friend?' (Accept any question that expects the reader to agree.)
- Example: 'We could measure how much it grows each week and record it in a chart.' (Accept any specific example linked to learning.)
- Firstly; In addition; Finally
- It sums up (restates) the reasons and repeats the opinion, often more strongly.
- Accept any paragraph with all four parts, e.g. 'In addition, a class pet would help us learn about animals. We could watch how it eats and sleeps and write down what we notice. Learning from a real animal is far more exciting than reading about one.'
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Write two reasons instead of three, using paragraph frames: 'Firstly, ___. For example, ___.' and 'In conclusion, ___ because ___.'
- Give a word bank of emotive words and modal verbs.
- Allow students to say each paragraph aloud to a partner before writing it.
Core task
- Write a full persuasive text with an introduction, three reasons with evidence and a conclusion.
- Use at least three persuasive language features.
Extension challenge
- Add a counter-argument paragraph: 'Some people say ___. However, ___.'
- Rewrite the introduction for two different audiences (the principal and a younger class) and explain how the language changes.
- Order the three reasons from strongest to weakest and justify the order.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Use the success criteria as a checklist when reading drafts: opinion, three reasons, evidence for each, conclusion, three persuasive features.
- Listen during shared planning: can students tell the difference between a reason and evidence?
- Use exit tickets to identify who needs more teaching on evidence versus reasons.
Exit ticket
- What goes in the introduction of a persuasive text?
- What is the difference between a reason and evidence?
- Write one sentence that uses a strong modal verb.
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- A clear statement of the writer's opinion (and often a preview of the reasons).
- A reason says why you think something; evidence is a fact or example that proves the reason.
- Example: 'Our school must have a class pet.' (Accept any sentence using must, should or another strong modal verb.)
Common misconceptions
- A list of reasons is enough. Students often write three reasons with no support. Ask 'How do you know?' or 'Can you give an example?' after every reason.
- The conclusion introduces a new reason. Explain that the conclusion sums up; new ideas belong in the body.
- Shouting persuades. Capital letters and many exclamation marks don't make writing more convincing. Model choosing powerful words instead.
- Opinion and fact are the same. Practise sorting statements into fact and opinion before writing.
Extension
- Hold a short class debate using students' paragraphs as speeches.
- Write a persuasive letter to the school newsletter on a different issue chosen by the class.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
Printable worksheets
Interactive games
More lesson plans
Digraphs sh, ch and th: Hearing, Reading and Writing Words Like ship, chop and thin
A teacher-led phonics lesson for beginning readers: two letters, one sound. Students hear sh, ch and th at the start and end of words, learn an action for each sound, read and build short words such as ship, chop, thin and fish, sort words by digraph and write words from dictation. All practice is show-and-say, so it works before students can read independently.
High-Frequency Words: Sounding Out the Regular Parts and Learning the Tricky Parts by Heart
Students learn common high-frequency words, such as the and said, with a heart word routine: say the word, tap its sounds, match each sound to its letters and mark the tricky part with a heart. Regular words are sounded out, never guessed. Quick, active games build fast, accurate reading and spelling of the words.
Letter Sounds and Blending CVC Words: Phonics for New Entrants
A fully teacher-led phonics lesson: students listen for the first sound in spoken words, link sounds to letters, then blend three sounds into simple consonant-vowel-consonant words such as sat, map and sun. Movement, robot talk and 'show and say' answers mean every task works for students who are just beginning to read.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.