Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Year 4 Science lesson plan · More Science resources

What Plants Need to Grow: Planning and Setting Up a Fair Test

Students review what plants need (light, water, air, nutrients and space) and plan a fair test of one need using seedlings. They identify the variable they will change, the one they will measure and the ones they will keep the same, make predictions, set up the test and record first measurements. The test then runs for one to two weeks.

  • 60 minutes
  • Year 4
  • Science
  • Plant needs and fair testing
  • 🇳🇿 New Zealand

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Describe the things most plants need to grow and stay healthy: light, water, air, nutrients, space and a suitable temperature.
  • Plan a fair test by naming the variable to change, the variable to measure and the variables to keep the same.
  • Make a prediction, set up the test and record first observations and measurements in a results table.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can list at least four things plants need.
  • I can explain that in a fair test we change only one thing.
  • I can name what we change, what we measure and what we keep the same in our test.
  • I can write a prediction with a reason.
  • I can measure a seedling and record the result in a table.

Curriculum focus: Science — Living World; Nature of Science · The New Zealand Curriculum

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

Potting mix can contain harmful bacteria. Follow the bag's safety instructions: the teacher opens and dampens the mix, students wear gloves, and everyone washes hands afterwards.

Key vocabulary

fair test
An investigation where only one thing is changed and everything else is kept the same, so we know what caused any difference.
variable
Anything in an investigation that can change or be changed.
independent variable
The one thing we choose to change (for example, how much light the plants get).
dependent variable
The thing we measure or observe to see what happens (for example, plant height or leaf colour).
controlled variables
The things we keep the same so the test is fair (for example, type of plant, soil, cup size and amount of water).
prediction
What you think will happen, and why, before you test it.
seedling
A very young plant that has just grown from a seed.
nutrients
Substances plants take in from the soil through their roots, which help them grow.

In the glossary: conclusion, data, fair test, leaf, prediction, root, seed, stem, variable, variable, variable

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • At least 6 seedlings per group, all the same kind and about the same size (for example bean, pea or wheat seedlings sown about 10 days earlier)
  • Identical small pots or cups with drainage holes, and saucers or trays underneath
  • Potting mix (potting soil), gloves, and a dust mask for the teacher if the bag recommends one
  • A measuring cylinder or measuring jug marked in millilitres
  • Rulers marked in millimetres
  • A dark cupboard or a large cardboard box for the light test
  • Labels or masking tape and markers
  • The planning and results sheet (practice sheet) and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. About 10 days before the lesson, sow seeds in identical pots so that each group has at least 6 seedlings with their first leaves. Sow extra in case some do not grow. Most seeds sprout without light, so seedlings can be started anywhere warm, then moved to a bright spot once they come up.
  2. Use untreated seeds. Some seed packets are coated with chemicals, so check the label.
  3. Decide which test each group will run: Test A (light: bright spot vs dark cupboard) or Test B (water: a measured amount every second school day vs no water). Each test needs at least 3 plants in each condition.
  4. Find a bright spot out of strong, direct afternoon sun, and a dark cupboard or box that keeps out light but lets some air in.
  5. Check student allergies, and wear gloves and open potting mix bags away from faces, following the bag's instructions.

Safety

  • Potting mix and soil can contain harmful bacteria. The teacher opens bags and dampens the mix away from students' faces, students wear gloves, and everyone washes hands with soap and water afterwards.
  • Use untreated seeds. Never eat seeds or any part of the experiment plants.
  • Check for allergies to plants, soil or gloves (for example latex) and provide alternatives.
  • Wipe up spilled water straight away so no one slips.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: the two mystery plants

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Describe two plants that started the same: 'One is short, green and sturdy. The other is tall, thin, pale yellow and floppy.' Ask: 'Which plant is healthier? What might have happened to the other one?'
    • Say: 'Scientists don't just guess. They test their ideas. Today we are going to plan and set up a fair test to find out what plants need.'

    Students

    • Suggest reasons why two plants might grow differently.
  2. 2

    What do plants need?

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Ask pairs to list everything they think a plant needs to grow. Collect ideas on the board.
    • Build the list: light, water, air, nutrients (from the soil), space to grow and a suitable temperature (not too hot or too cold).
    • Say: 'Plants make their own food inside their leaves. To do that they need light, water and a gas from the air called carbon dioxide. The soil does not give them food; it gives them water and nutrients, and holds them in place.'

    Students

    • List and discuss what plants need.
  3. 3

    Explicit teaching: what makes a test fair?

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Tell a story: 'Sam wanted to know if light helps plants grow. Sam put a bean plant on the windowsill and watered it every day. Sam put a tomato plant in the cupboard and forgot to water it. The windowsill plant grew better. Sam said light helps plants grow.' Ask: 'Is that a fair test? Why not?'
    • Draw out the problems: different kinds of plants, different amounts of water. Say: 'Sam changed three things, so we cannot tell which one made the difference. In a fair test we change only one thing.'
    • Introduce the three kinds of variable using a table on the board. Change (independent variable): the one thing we change. Measure (dependent variable): what we measure or observe. Keep the same (controlled variables): everything else.
    • Say: 'We also test more than one plant in each group. If one plant was weak to start with, it won't spoil our results. More plants makes our results more reliable.'
    • Quick check: students tell a partner what Sam should change, measure and keep the same to make the test fair.

    Students

    • Spot what makes Sam's test unfair and suggest how to fix it.
  4. 4

    Planning and predicting

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Allocate Test A (light) or Test B (water) to each group. Groups fill in the planning section of the sheet: question, what we change, what we measure, what we keep the same.
    • Ask each group to write a prediction using 'I think ___ because ___'.
    • Check every plan before groups set up. Ask: 'How will you make sure the water is the same for every plant?' (Measure it with the measuring cylinder.)

    Students

    • Complete the planning section and write a prediction with a reason.
  5. 5

    Setting up the test

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Give out gloves. Groups label each pot with their group name, the condition (for example 'Light 1', 'Dark 1') and today's date.
    • Test A: water all 6 plants with the same measured amount. Put 3 in the bright spot and 3 in the dark cupboard or box. Test B: put all 6 in the same bright spot. Mark 3 'water' and 3 'no water'.
    • Agree the watering routine for Test B and write it on the sheet, for example 20 millilitres for each 'water' plant every second school day. Test A plants all get the same routine.
    • Remind students: 'Do not move, touch or water the plants except at the agreed times. That would change a variable.'

    Students

    • Label, water and place the plants according to the plan.
  6. 6

    First observations and measurements

    10 min

    Teacher

    • Model measuring: 'Put the ruler on the soil next to the stem, with zero at the soil. Read the height at the top of the tallest leaf, in millimetres.'
    • Students record Day 0 in the results table: height, leaf colour (green, pale green, yellow) and number of leaves for each plant.
    • Explain the next steps: 'We will measure and observe again on Day 3, Day 7 and Day 10. Then we will compare the results and see if our predictions were right.'
    • Students take off gloves and wash hands with soap and water.

    Students

    • Measure and record the height, leaf colour and number of leaves for each plant, then wash hands.
  7. 7

    Exit ticket

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Students complete the exit ticket. Collect planning sheets and store them with the plants.

    Students

    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Naming the variables

Mia wants to find out if plants grow taller when they get more water. What should she change, measure and keep the same?

  1. What is she testing? The amount of water. That is what she changes.
  2. How will she know if it made a difference? She will measure plant height.
  3. What else could affect height? Type of plant, size of pot, soil, light, temperature. Keep all of these the same.

Change: the amount of water. Measure: plant height. Keep the same: type and size of plant, pot, soil, light, temperature and how often she waters.

Writing a prediction

Write a prediction for Test A (bright spot vs dark cupboard).

  1. Use the frame 'I think ___ because ___'.
  2. Say what you think will happen to the plants in each condition.
  3. Give a reason based on what you know about plants.

Example: 'I think the plants in the bright spot will stay green and healthy, and the plants in the dark will turn pale and weak, because plants need light to make their food.'

Reading results

After 10 days, the plants in the dark are taller (average 85 mm) than the plants in the light (average 70 mm), but they are pale yellow, thin and floppy. Did the dark help them grow better?

  1. Height is only one measurement. Look at the other observations too: colour and strength.
  2. The plants in the light are green and sturdy. The plants in the dark are pale, thin and weak.
  3. Plants in the dark use up their stored food stretching up to find light. Without light they cannot make new food, and they stay pale.

No. The plants in the dark grew taller but were unhealthy. The plants in the light were healthier, which shows plants need light.

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Fair Test Planning and Results Sheet

Answer questions 1 to 8 today. Fill in the results table (question 9) on each measuring day. Answer questions 10 to 12 today or at the end of the test, as your teacher directs.

  1. 1List four things most plants need to grow.
  2. 2What does 'fair test' mean?
  3. 3Our question: Does ___ affect how well a seedling grows? (Fill in for your test.)
  4. 4What will we change? (independent variable)
  5. 5What will we measure or observe? (dependent variable)
  6. 6List three things we will keep the same. (controlled variables)
  7. 7Why do we use 3 plants for each condition instead of 1?
  8. 8My prediction: I think ___ because ___.
  9. 9Results table: for each plant, record height (mm), leaf colour and number of leaves on Day 0, Day 3, Day 7 and Day 10.
  10. 10Kai's results after 10 days: plants with no water are 32 mm, 30 mm and 35 mm tall and drooping. Plants with water are 58 mm, 61 mm and 60 mm tall and upright. What can Kai conclude?
  11. 11Why would it be unfair to put the 'water' plants by a sunny window and the 'no water' plants in a shady corner?
  12. 12Challenge: Plan a fair test to find out if plants grow better in potting mix or sand. What would you change, measure and keep the same?
Show answers
  1. Any four of: light, water, air, nutrients, space, a suitable temperature.
  2. A test where only one thing is changed and everything else is kept the same.
  3. Test A: Does light affect how well a seedling grows? Test B: Does water affect how well a seedling grows?
  4. Test A: whether the plant gets light or is kept in the dark. Test B: whether the plant gets water or no water.
  5. Plant height in millimetres, leaf colour and number of leaves.
  6. Any three of: type of plant, size of seedling at the start, pot size, amount and type of soil, temperature, amount of water (Test A) or amount of light (Test B), how often we check.
  7. If one plant is weak or damaged, it won't spoil the results. Using more plants makes the results more reliable.
  8. Answers will vary. Check for a clear prediction and a reason linked to plant needs.
  9. Day 0 heights should be similar for all plants. Check that units (mm) are included and observations are recorded for every plant.
  10. Plants grow better with water. The watered plants grew taller and stayed upright; the plants with no water grew less and drooped.
  11. Two things would be changing (water and light), so you couldn't tell which one caused any difference.
  12. Change: the type of soil (potting mix or sand). Measure: plant height, leaf colour, number of leaves. Keep the same: type and size of plant, pot size, amount of water, light, temperature, how often you check.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Give a planning sheet with the three variable boxes labelled with pictures: a hand turning a dial (change), a ruler (measure), a lock (keep the same).
  • Provide a word bank for controlled variables: plant type, pot size, soil, water, light, temperature.
  • Give a prediction frame with choices to circle: 'I think the plants in the ___ will grow better / worse because plants need ___.'

Core task

  • Complete questions 1 to 9 today and over the test period.

Extension challenge

  • Answer the challenge question and explain how you would make the test fair.
  • Calculate the average height for each condition on each measuring day and draw a line graph.
  • Explain why the plants in the dark might grow taller but still be less healthy.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Check planning sheets: can each student correctly name the variable changed, the variable measured and at least three controlled variables?
  • Listen to the Sam discussion: can students explain why the test was unfair?
  • Observe measuring: do students start at zero at the soil and record in millimetres?
  • Use practice questions 10 and 11 to check understanding of conclusions and fairness.

Exit ticket

  1. In our test, what is the one thing we are changing?
  2. Name two things we must keep the same to make our test fair.
  3. Why do we only change one thing in a fair test?
Show exit ticket answers
  1. Test A: light (bright spot or dark). Test B: water (water or no water).
  2. Any two of: type of plant, pot size, soil, amount of water (Test A), amount of light (Test B), temperature.
  3. So we know that any difference in the results was caused by that one thing.

Common misconceptions

  • Plants get their food from the soil. Plants make their own food (a type of sugar) in their leaves, using light, water and carbon dioxide from the air. Soil supplies water and nutrients and holds the plant up.
  • Taller always means healthier. Plants kept in the dark often grow tall and thin as they stretch towards light, but they are pale and weak.
  • Seeds need light to sprout. Most seeds sprout in the dark using food stored inside the seed. Light becomes important once the first leaves appear, which is why this test uses seedlings, not seeds.
  • More water is always better. Too much water can rot the roots. Plants need the right amount.
  • One plant is enough. Using several plants for each condition makes results more reliable.

Extension

  • After the test, write a short science report: question, prediction, method, results, conclusion and what you would do differently next time.
  • Test a new variable, such as temperature (a warm room vs a cool room) or space (one seedling per pot vs five).
  • Observe a celery stick or white flower stem standing in coloured water to see how water moves up a plant.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.