Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Year 5 Classroom Wellbeing lesson plan · More Classroom Wellbeing resources

Friendship and Resolving Conflict: I-Statements and a Four-Step Routine

Students explore the qualities of a good friend and learn that disagreements between friends are normal. They practise turning blaming 'you' statements into I-statements, learn the four-step COOL routine for working through a conflict, and role-play original, everyday scenarios. They also learn the difference between a conflict and bullying, and when to get help from an adult.

  • 60 minutes
  • Year 5
  • Classroom Wellbeing
  • Friendship and conflict resolution
  • 🇳🇿 New Zealand

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Describe the qualities of a good friend and explain why disagreements happen even in strong friendships.
  • Use I-statements to say how you feel and what you need without blaming.
  • Apply a simple four-step routine to work through a conflict, and recognise when a problem needs an adult's help.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can name at least three qualities of a good friend.
  • I can turn a blaming 'you' statement into an I-statement.
  • I can use the COOL steps to work through a disagreement in a role-play.
  • I can explain the difference between a conflict and bullying.
  • I can name a trusted adult I could go to for help.

Curriculum focus: Health and Physical Education — Relationships with other people · The New Zealand Curriculum

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

If a student discloses harm, follow your school's child protection policy and the guidance of your designated child protection person.

Key vocabulary

conflict
A disagreement or clash between people who want or think different things.
I-statement
A way of speaking that says how you feel and what you need, starting with 'I', without blaming the other person.
compromise
An agreement where each person gives a little so that both are reasonably happy.
empathy
Trying to understand how someone else feels.
bullying
When someone deliberately and repeatedly hurts or upsets another person who finds it hard to make it stop.
trusted adult
A grown-up you feel safe with who can help, such as a teacher, parent, carer or school staff member.

In the glossary: bullying, conflict resolution, emotion, empathy, I-statement, trusted adult

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • Chart paper for a class 'Recipe for a Good Friend'
  • A COOL routine poster (see preparation)
  • Role-play scenario cards (in the sequence below), one set per group
  • Sticky notes
  • The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. Make the COOL poster. C — Calm down: take three slow breaths or take a short break. O — Own your feelings: use an I-statement. O — Open your ears: listen to the other person and say back what you heard. L — Look for a fair solution: suggest ideas together and choose one you can both accept.
  2. Print and cut the scenario cards. All scenarios are invented and mild. Do not use real events from your class.
  3. Plan how you will respond if a student discloses harm (see safety). Know who your school's child protection contact is.
  4. Set or revisit class agreements for discussion: we listen, we use made-up names, we don't share private stories about others.

Safety

  • Use only the invented scenarios. Do not ask students to role-play or describe real events involving classmates.
  • Remind students not to use real classmates' names or private information during discussions.
  • If a student discloses harm, abuse, neglect or ongoing bullying: stay calm, listen, thank them for telling you, do not promise to keep it a secret, do not question them in detail or investigate, and follow your school's child protection procedures straight away (including any mandatory reporting requirements).
  • Watch for students who become distressed and offer a quiet space and a follow-up conversation in private.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: a recipe for a good friend

    7 min

    Teacher

    • Say: 'If you were writing a recipe for a good friend, what ingredients would you need?' Give an example: 'One cup of kindness.'
    • Students write ingredients on sticky notes and add them to a large bowl drawn on chart paper. Read them out and group similar ones.

    Students

    • Write qualities of a good friend on sticky notes and add them to the class recipe.
  2. 2

    Qualities of a friend

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Draw out key qualities: kind, trustworthy, a good listener, fair, honest, respectful, includes others, says sorry and forgives.
    • Ask: 'Can a good friend ever disagree with you?' Say: 'Yes. Good friends are still different people. They might want different things or see things differently. Disagreements are normal. What matters is how we handle them.'
    • Ask: 'Which of these qualities help when friends disagree?' (Listening, fairness, saying sorry, respect.)

    Students

    • Discuss which qualities matter most and which help during a disagreement.
  3. 3

    Conflict or bullying?

    6 min

    Teacher

    • Say: 'A conflict is a disagreement between people. It can happen once, both people usually have a say, and it can often be sorted out by talking.'
    • Say: 'Bullying is different. It is when someone deliberately hurts or upsets another person again and again, and the person finds it hard to make it stop. Bullying is never okay, and it is not something you should sort out on your own. Always tell a trusted adult.'
    • Read two short examples and ask students to decide which is which. 'Two friends both want to be captain for one game.' (Conflict.) 'Every day for weeks, someone hides the same student's bag and laughs when they can't find it.' (Bullying: deliberate and repeated. Tell an adult.)

    Students

    • Decide whether each example is a conflict or bullying, and explain why.
  4. 4

    Explicit teaching: I-statements

    9 min

    Teacher

    • Write: 'You always ruin everything!' Ask: 'How would you feel if someone said this to you? Would you want to sort things out?'
    • Say: 'Blaming statements usually make the other person defensive. An I-statement says how I feel and what I need.' Write the frame: I feel ___ when ___ because ___. I would like ___.
    • Model: 'I feel frustrated when the game rules change halfway through, because it's hard to know how to win. I would like us to agree on the rules before we start.'
    • Students practise in pairs on whiteboards, turning these into I-statements: 'You never let me have a turn!' 'You broke my pencil case!' 'You're so bossy!'
    • Share some answers. Check each one names a feeling, describes the action (not the person) and asks for something reasonable.

    Students

    • Turn blaming 'you' statements into I-statements using the frame.
  5. 5

    The COOL routine

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Introduce the COOL poster and go through each step.
    • Model with a volunteer using a scenario: you both want the same library book. Calm down: take three slow breaths. Own your feelings: 'I feel disappointed because I've been waiting to read the next book in the series.' Open your ears: listen to the volunteer, then say, 'So you need it for your project this week?' Look for a fair solution: brainstorm (take turns, read it together, one borrows now and the other reserves it next) and agree on one.
    • Say: 'If you've tried COOL and it isn't working, or anyone is unsafe, or someone is being hurt, stop and get a trusted adult. That is a smart choice, not dobbing or tattling.'

    Students

    • Watch the model and identify each COOL step.
  6. 6

    Role-plays

    14 min

    Teacher

    • In groups of three (two actors and one observer), students choose a scenario card. The observer ticks off each COOL step on the practice sheet. Swap roles for each scenario.
    • Scenario 1: Mika and Jules both want to choose the game at lunch. Mika wants to play basketball; Jules wants to play tag.
    • Scenario 2: Pria lent her new coloured pencils to Ollie. They came back with two broken leads.
    • Scenario 3: In a group project, Tao feels he is doing most of the work while Sam keeps chatting.
    • Scenario 4: Remy made a joke about Lani's drawing. Remy thought it was funny, but Lani felt embarrassed.
    • Scenario 5: Ellie sat with someone new at lunch, and her usual friend Noor felt left out.
    • Circulate and coach. Prompt: 'What's your I-statement? What did you hear them say? What solutions could work for both of you?'
    • Bring the class together and ask two groups to show a role-play. Discuss: 'Which step was hardest? Which solution was fair to both people?'

    Students

    • Role-play scenarios using the COOL steps, taking turns as actor and observer.
  7. 7

    Practice sheet and exit ticket

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Students complete the remaining practice questions and the exit ticket.
    • Close by reminding everyone who the trusted adults at school are, and that they can talk to you privately at any time.

    Students

    • Complete the practice sheet and exit ticket.

Worked examples

Writing an I-statement

Turn this into an I-statement: 'You never listen to my ideas!'

  1. Name the feeling: frustrated or ignored.
  2. Describe what happened (the action, not the person): when my ideas are skipped in our group.
  3. Say why: because I'd like to help.
  4. Ask for what you need: I would like us to hear everyone's idea before we choose.

'I feel frustrated when my ideas get skipped, because I want to help the group. I would like us to listen to everyone's idea before we choose.'

Using COOL

Mika wants to play basketball at lunch and Jules wants to play tag. Show how they could use COOL.

  1. Calm down: both take three slow breaths.
  2. Own your feelings: Mika says, 'I feel left out of tag because I'm not a fast runner. I would like to play basketball.'
  3. Open your ears: Jules says, 'So you'd prefer a game that's not about running?' Then Jules shares: 'I feel cooped up after sitting all morning, so I want to run around.'
  4. Look for a fair solution: they suggest ideas (take turns choosing, play each game for half of lunch, find a game with some running that suits both) and agree on one.

Example: they play tag for the first half of lunch and basketball for the second half, and agree to swap the order tomorrow.

Conflict or bullying?

Leo and Ari argued about who won a race, then didn't talk for the rest of lunch. The next day they were playing together again. Is this conflict or bullying?

  1. Did it happen once or again and again? Once.
  2. Was one person deliberately hurting the other who couldn't make it stop? No, they disagreed with each other.
  3. Did they sort it out? Yes.

Conflict. It was a one-off disagreement between friends who both had a say and worked it out.

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Friendship and Conflict Practice

Answer each question. For role-plays, use the observer checklist in question 8.

  1. 1List three qualities of a good friend.
  2. 2Is it normal for friends to disagree sometimes? Explain.
  3. 3Finish the I-statement frame: I feel ___ when ___ because ___. I would like ___.
  4. 4Rewrite as an I-statement: 'You took my seat!'
  5. 5Rewrite as an I-statement: 'You're so bossy!'
  6. 6What do the letters in COOL stand for?
  7. 7Why is it helpful to calm down before trying to solve a problem?
  8. 8Observer checklist: in the role-play you watched, tick each step you saw: Calm down / Own your feelings / Open your ears / Look for a fair solution. What was the solution?
  9. 9Pria lent her coloured pencils to Ollie, and two came back broken. Write one fair solution.
  10. 10Conflict or bullying? Two friends argue about whose turn it is on the swing, then work it out.
  11. 11Conflict or bullying? For weeks, a group keeps leaving out the same student on purpose and laughing about it.
  12. 12Name two times when you should get a trusted adult's help instead of sorting a problem out yourselves.
Show answers
  1. Any three of: kind, trustworthy, honest, a good listener, fair, respectful, includes others, says sorry, forgives, supportive.
  2. Yes. Friends are different people with different ideas and wants. What matters is how they handle disagreements.
  3. Answers will vary. Check for a feeling word, an action (not a personal attack), a reason and a reasonable request.
  4. Example: 'I feel annoyed when someone sits in my seat while I'm away, because I wasn't finished. I would like to have my seat back, please.'
  5. Example: 'I feel left out when decisions are made without me, because I have ideas too. I would like us to take turns choosing.'
  6. Calm down; Own your feelings (use an I-statement); Open your ears (listen and say back what you heard); Look for a fair solution.
  7. When we are very upset, it is harder to think clearly and listen, and we might say something hurtful.
  8. Answers will vary. Check that the solution is fair to both people and respectful.
  9. Examples: Ollie says sorry and replaces or sharpens them; they agree Ollie will be more careful next time; Ollie offers to share his own pencils.
  10. Conflict. It is a one-off disagreement that they sorted out.
  11. Bullying. It is deliberate and repeated, and the student cannot make it stop. Tell a trusted adult.
  12. Any two of: someone is being hurt or is unsafe; it is bullying; you have tried to sort it out and it hasn't worked; someone is very upset; someone is breaking an important rule.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Give an I-statement card with sentence starters and a feelings word bank (frustrated, disappointed, left out, annoyed, worried, embarrassed).
  • Let students act as the observer first so they see the COOL steps before trying them.
  • Use Scenario 1 or 2, which have clear, practical solutions.

Core task

  • Complete practice questions 1 to 11 and take part in at least two role-plays.

Extension challenge

  • Write an original mild scenario and two different fair solutions, and explain which you think is best and why.
  • Explain how empathy helps in the 'Open your ears' step.
  • Create a comic strip showing two characters using COOL to solve a problem.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Check whiteboard I-statements: do they name a feeling, describe an action and make a reasonable request?
  • Observe role-plays: can students use each COOL step and reach a fair solution?
  • Use practice questions 10 to 12 to check understanding of conflict, bullying and when to get help.
  • Exit tickets show whether students can write an I-statement and name a trusted adult.

Exit ticket

  1. Write an I-statement for this situation: a friend keeps interrupting you when you are telling a story.
  2. What is one difference between a conflict and bullying?
  3. Name one trusted adult at school you could go to for help.
Show exit ticket answers
  1. Example: 'I feel frustrated when I get interrupted, because I lose my place. I would like to finish my story first, then hear yours.'
  2. Any one of: bullying is deliberate and repeated, a conflict is often a one-off; in bullying the person can't make it stop, in a conflict both people have a say; bullying always needs an adult's help.
  3. Any appropriate adult, such as a class teacher, principal, school counselling staff or another staff member.

Common misconceptions

  • Good friends never argue. Disagreements are normal in healthy friendships. What matters is solving them respectfully.
  • Every conflict is bullying. A one-off disagreement is a conflict. Bullying is deliberate, repeated and involves someone who finds it hard to make it stop.
  • Telling an adult is dobbing or tattling. Getting help when someone is hurt, unsafe or being bullied is the right thing to do.
  • An I-statement means you always get your way. An I-statement shares your feelings and needs; you still need to listen and find a fair solution.
  • Saying sorry fixes everything immediately. An apology helps, but repairing a friendship can take time and actions as well as words.

Extension

  • Make a class COOL corner with the poster, feelings word bank and a calm-down space.
  • Over the next week, students note (privately) a time they used an I-statement and how it went.
  • Read a picture book or short story about friendship and identify where characters could have used COOL.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.