Year 8 Science lesson plan · More Science resources
Separating Mixtures: Filtration, Evaporation, Decanting, Sieving and Magnetic Separation
Students learn that each separation technique works because the substances in a mixture differ in a property such as particle size, solubility, density or magnetism. After teacher demonstrations of sieving, magnetic separation and decanting, they recover sand and salt from a sand–salt–water mixture using filtration and flame-free evaporation.
- 60 minutes
- Year 8
- Science
- Mixtures and separation techniques
- 🇳🇿 New Zealand
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Distinguish between pure substances and mixtures, and use the terms solute, solvent, solution, soluble and insoluble correctly.
- Explain which property each separation technique relies on: sieving (particle size), magnetic separation (magnetism), decanting (settling of a denser solid), filtration (insoluble particles too large to pass through filter paper) and evaporation (a dissolved solid left behind when the liquid evaporates).
- Plan the order of techniques needed to separate a mixture of several substances.
- Carry out filtration and flame-free evaporation safely to recover sand and salt from a sand–salt–water mixture.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can say whether a material is a pure substance or a mixture and explain why.
- I can name the property that each of the five separation techniques uses.
- I can explain why filtration removes sand from water but cannot remove dissolved salt.
- I can list, in order, the steps to separate sand, salt, gravel and steel paperclips.
- I can follow the safety steps and use the words residue and filtrate to describe my results.
Curriculum focus: Science — Material World · The New Zealand Curriculum
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
Key vocabulary
- pure substance
- A material made of only one kind of particle, such as pure water or table salt.
- mixture
- Two or more substances mixed together but not chemically joined, so each keeps its own properties.
- soluble / insoluble
- A soluble substance dissolves in a liquid (salt in water). An insoluble substance does not (sand in water).
- solute, solvent and solution
- The solute is the substance that dissolves (salt), the solvent is the liquid it dissolves in (water), and the solution is the mixture they form (salt water).
- sieving
- Separating solid pieces of different sizes by shaking them through a mesh. Small pieces fall through; large pieces stay behind.
- magnetic separation
- Using a magnet to pull out magnetic materials such as iron, steel, nickel or cobalt from non-magnetic ones.
- decanting
- Letting a solid settle to the bottom of a liquid, then gently pouring the liquid off the top.
- filtration
- Pouring a mixture through filter paper. Insoluble solid particles are too large to pass through the tiny holes; the liquid and anything dissolved in it pass through.
- residue
- The solid left behind on the filter paper after filtration.
- filtrate
- The liquid that passes through the filter paper.
- evaporation
- A liquid changing into a gas at its surface. When the water in a solution evaporates, the dissolved solid is left behind.
In the glossary: dissolve, evaporation, magnet, mixture, solution
Materials & preparation
You will need
- Per group of three: two clear plastic cups (about 250 mL), a plastic funnel, a filter paper circle, a teaspoon, a stirring rod or plastic spoon, a 50 mL measuring cylinder, a shallow dark-coloured saucer or petri dish, paper towel and safety glasses
- Washed play sand (about 2 level teaspoons per group) and fine table salt (1 level teaspoon, about 5 g, per group)
- Room-temperature water, plus a jug of warm tap water (not from a kettle) if there is no sunny windowsill
- Teacher demonstration: a kitchen sieve, a mixture of gravel and sand, a mixture of sand and small steel paperclips, a strong magnet in a zip-lock bag, and a clear jar of muddy water (soil and water) shaken in the morning and left to settle
- A 'mystery tub' for the hook: sand, salt, a handful of gravel and a few steel paperclips mixed together in a clear container
- A saucer of salt water evaporated on a windowsill over the previous few days, showing salt crystals
- Optional: digital scales reading to 0.1 g
- Practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Three or four days before the lesson, dissolve 1 teaspoon of salt in 50 mL of water, pour about 20 mL into a shallow dark saucer and leave it on a sunny windowsill. On the day, it shows white salt crystals for students to see.
- On the morning of the lesson, shake the jar of soil and water and leave it to settle so that it is ready for decanting.
- Set out one tray per group with the equipment listed. Put the salt and sand in small labelled cups so students do not handle the stock containers.
- Choose a sunny, undisturbed windowsill (or a bench away from traffic) for the evaporating dishes, and prepare a label for each group's dish using a group number or team name, not student names.
- Read your school's science risk assessment for the practical. There is no heating in this lesson: no Bunsen burners, candles, hot plates or kettles.
Safety
- No flames or heating equipment in this lesson: no Bunsen burners, candles, hot plates or kettles. Evaporation happens on a sunny windowsill, or with the saucer resting on a cup of warm tap water.
- Wear safety glasses throughout. Salt or sand in an eye stings: rinse with running water and tell the teacher straight away.
- Never taste anything in a science lab, even salt.
- Pour sand gently and close to the cup so it does not make dust.
- Wipe up spills of water or sand immediately: wet floors and sand on hard floors are slippery.
- Use plastic cups and funnels where possible. Report any breakages to the teacher; do not pick up broken glass.
- Keep the magnet in its zip-lock bag and away from phones, laptops and bank cards.
- Wash hands at the end of the practical.
Lesson sequence
- 1
Hook: the mystery tub
5 minTeacher
- Hold up the mystery tub. Say: 'This morning I knocked four containers off the prep-room shelf and they all landed in this tub: sand, salt, gravel and steel paperclips. I need all four back, separately. Picking them out with tweezers would take all week. What could we do instead?'
- Give pairs one minute to suggest ideas, then take three or four. For each idea ask: 'What is different about the thing you are removing that lets your idea work?'
- Say: 'By the end of the lesson you'll be able to write a plan that gets all four back, and you'll have done the hardest part yourselves: getting the salt out of the sand.'
Students
- Suggest separation ideas in pairs and name the difference each idea relies on.
- 2
Explicit teaching: mixtures, dissolving and the five techniques
12 minTeacher
- Say: 'A pure substance contains only one kind of particle, like pure water or table salt. A mixture contains two or more substances that are not chemically joined, so each one keeps its own properties. Sea water, soil and air are all mixtures.'
- Say: 'Because each substance keeps its own properties, we can separate a mixture if we find a property that is different: the size of the pieces, whether they dissolve, whether they sink and settle, or whether a magnet attracts them.'
- Stir a teaspoon of salt into a cup of water in front of the class. Say: 'Where did the salt go? It hasn't vanished. It has dissolved: it has broken up into particles far too small to see, spread through the water. The salt is the solute, the water is the solvent, and together they make a solution.'
- Draw a three-column table on the board: Technique | Property used | Example. Fill it in with the class: sieving — size of pieces — gravel from sand; magnetic separation — magnetic or not — steel paperclips from sand; decanting — a denser solid settles to the bottom — pouring water off settled mud; filtration — insoluble pieces too big to pass through the filter paper — sand from water; evaporation — a dissolved solid stays behind when the liquid evaporates — salt from salt water.
- Say: 'Only some metals are magnetic: iron, nickel, cobalt and most steels. Aluminium cans and copper wire are not attracted to a magnet.'
- Check for understanding: 'Thumbs up or down: can filtration get the salt out of salt water?' (Down.) Ask a student to explain: 'The dissolved salt particles are so small they pass straight through the holes in the filter paper with the water.'
Students
- Copy and complete the technique table.
- Answer the thumbs up or down check and explain the answer.
- 3
Teacher demonstrations: sieving, magnetic separation and decanting
8 minTeacher
- Sieving: shake the gravel and sand mixture through the kitchen sieve over a tray. Ask: 'Which property did the sieve use?' (Size: the sand grains are smaller than the holes; the gravel is larger.)
- Magnetic separation: hold the magnet, still inside its zip-lock bag, over the sand and paperclip mixture. Ask: 'Why do you think I left the magnet in the bag?' (So the paperclips can be pulled off easily: when I take the magnet out of the bag over a dish, they drop off.) Show this.
- Decanting: show the jar of muddy water, with soil settled at the bottom. Slowly pour the water into an empty jar, stopping when the soil starts to move. Ask: 'Is the water I poured off perfectly clean?' (No, it is still a little cloudy: very fine particles have not settled.) Say: 'Decanting is quick, but not perfect. We could filter this water next to remove more of the soil.'
Students
- Observe each demonstration and record the technique, the property used and one limitation in their table.
- 4
Safety briefing and planning
5 minTeacher
- Say: 'We are not using Bunsen burners, candles or any flame today. Boiling salt water on a flame can make it spit hot liquid. Instead, the sun and warm air will evaporate our water slowly over the next few days. Our dishes go on the sunny windowsill, or sit on top of a cup of warm tap water to speed things up.'
- Read the safety rules aloud (see Safety): safety glasses on, nothing tasted, spills wiped straight away, sand poured gently, hands washed at the end.
- Ask groups to write the order of steps to get sand and salt back from their mixture before they touch any equipment. Take answers and agree on: add water and stir to dissolve the salt; filter to catch the sand; leave the filtrate to evaporate to get the salt; dry the sand.
Students
- Write the method in four steps and check it with the teacher before starting.
- 5
Investigation: separating sand and salt
18 minTeacher
- Give the instructions one step at a time, and display them on the board: (1) Put 1 level teaspoon of salt and 2 level teaspoons of sand into a cup and look closely at the mixture. (2) Measure 50 mL of water and add it. Stir for one minute, until you can no longer see salt grains. (3) Fold the filter paper in half, then in half again, and open it into a cone with one layer on one side and three on the other. Sit it in the funnel over the clean cup. (4) Pour the mixture slowly into the filter paper, never letting the liquid rise above the top of the paper. (5) Pour about 20 mL of the filtrate into your labelled saucer and carry it carefully to the windowsill. (6) Open the filter paper flat on a paper towel so the sand can dry.
- Circulate and ask: 'What is the residue? What is the filtrate? Why is the filtrate clear if there is salt in it?' (The salt is dissolved and its particles are too small to see.)
- If there is no sunny windowsill, show groups how to sit their saucer on top of a cup of warm tap water. Say: 'The warm water heats the saucer gently, so its water evaporates faster. No kettle water: tap-warm is all we need.'
- Bring out the saucer you prepared earlier. Say: 'This is what your saucer will look like in a few days. The water has evaporated into the air, and the salt has been left behind as crystals.'
- Five minutes before the end, call 'Equipment down': filter paper and damp sand on the paper towel in the drying area, cups rinsed, benches wiped, hands washed.
Students
- Follow the six steps in their group, sharing the roles of measurer, pourer and recorder.
- Record observations of the mixture, the residue and the filtrate, and draw a labelled diagram of the filtration set-up.
- Pack up, wipe benches and wash hands.
- 6
Results and discussion
7 minTeacher
- Ask: 'Where is the salt right now?' (Dissolved in the filtrate, in the saucer on the windowsill.) 'How do we know it is there, without tasting it?' (The saucer evaporated earlier shows salt crystals. We never taste anything in a science lab.)
- Ask: 'Our sand is still damp, and that water had salt in it. So is our sand perfectly clean?' (No, a little salt is left in it.) 'How could we make it cleaner?' (Pour a little clean water through the sand on the filter paper to rinse it.)
- Return to the mystery tub. Ask groups to write the full plan to recover all four substances. Agree on: sieve out the gravel; pull out the paperclips with the magnet in its bag; add water and stir to dissolve the salt; filter to collect the sand; evaporate the filtrate to collect the salt; dry the sand.
- Ask: 'Why do we use the magnet before we add water?' (Dry paperclips are easier to remove cleanly, and steel can rust if it sits in salt water.)
Students
- Discuss in groups and write the four-substance separation plan.
- 7
Exit ticket
5 minTeacher
- Students complete the exit ticket on their own. Sort into secure / nearly / not yet to plan the next lesson, when groups collect their salt crystals and observe them with a hand lens.
Students
- Answer the exit ticket on their own.
Worked examples
Planning a multi-step separation
A mixture contains sand, salt, gravel and small steel paperclips. Plan how to recover all four substances separately.
- Look for the property that makes each substance different: gravel has large pieces; steel is magnetic; salt dissolves in water; sand does not dissolve.
- Sieve the dry mixture: the gravel stays in the sieve.
- Hold a magnet (in a zip-lock bag) over what passed through the sieve: the paperclips are attracted to it. This is done while the mixture is dry.
- Add water to the sand and salt and stir: the salt dissolves; the sand does not.
- Filter: the sand is the residue on the filter paper; the salt water is the filtrate.
- Leave the filtrate in a shallow dish in a warm, sunny place: the water evaporates and the salt is left behind. Dry the sand on paper towel.
Sieve (gravel), magnet (paperclips), dissolve and filter (sand), evaporate the filtrate (salt).
Calculating the percentage of salt recovered
A group dissolved 5.0 g of salt with sand in water, filtered the mixture and evaporated all of the filtrate. They collected 4.6 g of salt. What percentage of the salt did they recover, and where might the rest have gone?
- Percentage recovered = mass recovered ÷ starting mass × 100.
- 4.6 ÷ 5.0 = 0.92.
- 0.92 × 100 = 92%.
- The missing 0.4 g of salt was most likely still dissolved in the water soaked into the damp sand and filter paper, or left on the cup, stirring rod or dish.
92% of the salt was recovered. The other 0.4 g stayed in the damp sand and filter paper or on the equipment.
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Separating Mixtures Practice
Answer each question. Name the property being used whenever you choose a separation technique.
- 1Sort these into pure substances and mixtures: sea water, oxygen gas, soil, table sugar, air.
- 2Which technique would you use to separate small stones from sand, and which property does it use?
- 3Tama drops a box of steel drawing pins into a sandpit. How could he get them back quickly? Explain why this works.
- 4After rain, a bucket contains muddy water. The mud settles to the bottom overnight. Name the technique for removing the water, and give one limitation.
- 5Explain why filtration can separate sand from water but cannot separate salt from salt water.
- 6In the sand and salt investigation, name the residue and the filtrate.
- 7Name the solute, the solvent and the solution when salt is dissolved in water.
- 8Two identical saucers of salt water are left to evaporate: one on a sunny windowsill and one in a dark cupboard. Which will leave salt crystals first? Explain.
- 9Kai says the salt 'disappeared' when he stirred it into the water. How could you show him the salt is still there, without tasting it?
- 10Mei's group started with 5.0 g of salt and recovered 4.0 g after evaporating all their filtrate. What percentage did they recover?
- 11A mixture contains iron filings, salt and sand. Write the steps, in order, to recover all three.
- 12Why is it important to remove the iron filings before adding water in the previous question?
Show answersHide answers
- Pure substances: oxygen gas, table sugar. Mixtures: sea water, soil, air.
- Sieving. It uses the difference in the size of the pieces: the sand grains fall through the mesh and the stones stay behind.
- Use a magnet (ideally inside a plastic bag). Steel is magnetic and sand is not, so only the pins are attracted to the magnet.
- Decanting: carefully pouring the water off the settled mud. Limitation: some very fine particles stay mixed in the water, so it is still a little cloudy, and some water is left behind with the mud.
- Sand is insoluble, so its grains stay as solid pieces that are too large to pass through the tiny holes in the filter paper. Salt is soluble: when it dissolves, its particles are so small that they pass through the filter paper with the water.
- The residue is the sand left on the filter paper. The filtrate is the salt water (salt solution) that passed through.
- Solute: salt. Solvent: water. Solution: salt water.
- The saucer on the sunny windowsill. It receives more heat energy, so the water particles move faster and more of them escape from the surface into the air each minute.
- Leave some of the solution in a shallow dish to evaporate: the water leaves and white salt crystals are left behind. (You could also show that the mass of the solution equals the mass of the water plus the mass of the salt.) We never taste anything in a science lab.
- 4.0 ÷ 5.0 = 0.8, and 0.8 × 100 = 80%.
- 1. Use a magnet (in a bag) on the dry mixture to remove the iron filings. 2. Add water and stir to dissolve the salt. 3. Filter: the sand is the residue. 4. Evaporate the filtrate to recover the salt. 5. Dry the sand.
- Dry filings are much easier to separate cleanly with a magnet, and iron left in salt water can begin to rust, changing it into a different substance.
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Provide the technique table partly filled in, with a word bank (size, dissolves, settles, magnetic).
- Give a picture-sequence card for the investigation steps, and assign each student one clear role in the group.
- For the four-substance plan, give the steps on cut-up strips for students to put in order.
Core task
- Complete the technique table, carry out the investigation, and answer practice questions 1 to 10.
Extension challenge
- Answer questions 11 and 12, then plan how to separate a mixture of sand, sawdust and salt. (Add water: the sawdust floats and can be skimmed off; filter to collect the sand; evaporate the filtrate for the salt.)
- Explain why salt-making ponds by the sea are wide and shallow rather than narrow and deep. (A larger surface area means more water evaporates each day.)
- Research how a water treatment plant uses settling and filtration to clean drinking water, and draw a flow diagram.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Check each group's written method before they start: are the steps in a workable order?
- Observe the practical: do students fold and fill the filter paper correctly and use the words residue and filtrate?
- Use practice questions 5 and 9 to check understanding of dissolving beyond naming techniques.
- Sort exit tickets into secure / nearly / not yet.
Exit ticket
- Which property of sand lets filtration separate it from water?
- Name a technique that gets salt back from salt water and explain how it works.
- Give one reason we evaporated the water on a sunny windowsill rather than heating it over a flame.
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- Sand is insoluble: its grains do not dissolve and are too large to pass through the holes in the filter paper.
- Evaporation: the water turns into water vapour and leaves, and the dissolved salt is left behind as crystals.
- It is safer: there is no flame or hot equipment, and salt water heated strongly can spit hot liquid. (Slow evaporation also tends to form larger crystals.)
Common misconceptions
- Dissolved means disappeared. The salt is still there, in particles too small to see. Evaporating the water shows it again, and the mass of the solution includes the mass of the salt.
- Dissolving is the same as melting. Melting needs heat and involves one substance changing from solid to liquid. Dissolving involves a solute spreading through a solvent, and happens at room temperature.
- Filter paper can catch anything. Filtration only removes insoluble solid pieces; dissolved substances pass through with the liquid.
- Evaporation destroys the water. The water changes into water vapour and goes into the air. It is still water.
- All metals are magnetic. Only some are, mainly iron, nickel, cobalt and most steels. Aluminium, copper and gold are not.
Extension
- In the next lesson, examine the salt crystals with a hand lens and compare crystal sizes from the windowsill dish and the warm-water dish (slower evaporation usually gives larger crystals).
- Separate the coloured dyes in a water-based felt-tip pen line using paper chromatography (a strip of filter paper standing in a little water), as a preview of another separation technique.
More lesson plans
Living and Non-living Things: a School Grounds Hunt and Picture Card Sort
Students explore the school grounds to find living and non-living things, then sort picture cards and explain their thinking: living things grow, need food and water, and can make new living things like themselves. They finish by naming what plants and animals need to stay alive. Includes outdoor safety steps.
My Five Senses: Seeing, Hearing, Smelling, Tasting and Touching
Students name the five senses and the body parts we use for each, then explore safely at four stations: looking, listening, smelling and touching. They sort pictures by the sense they would use and learn that we often use more than one sense at a time. Tasting is talked about, not done, and clear rules keep everyone safe.
Animal Life Cycles: Butterfly, Frog and Chicken, with Metamorphosis and Direct Development
Students learn that every animal has a life cycle, then follow three: a butterfly (egg, caterpillar, chrysalis, adult), a frog (eggs, tadpole, froglet, adult) and a chicken (egg, chick, adult). They compare animals that change body shape completely through metamorphosis with animals whose young look like small adults, and sequence and compare the cycles.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.