Year 8 English lesson plan · More English resources
Writing an Argument Essay with PEEL Paragraphs: Position, Counterargument and Conclusion (with Model Essay)
Students unpack an original model essay arguing for a later school start time, then learn to write a clear position statement, PEEL body paragraphs (Point, Explain, Evidence, Link), a counterargument with a rebuttal and a conclusion that adds nothing new. They plan and draft their own argument essay on a school-life topic.
- 60 minutes
- Year 8
- English
- Argument writing
- 🇳🇿 New Zealand
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Identify the structure of an argument essay: introduction with a position statement, body paragraphs, a counterargument with a rebuttal, and a conclusion.
- Write a body paragraph using the PEEL structure: Point, Explain, Evidence or Example, Link.
- Write a counterargument that fairly states an opposing view and a rebuttal that responds to it.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can write a position statement that clearly says what I think and previews my reasons.
- My body paragraph starts with a topic sentence (Point) and ends by linking back to my position.
- I can support a point with an explanation and a specific example, not just 'everyone knows'.
- I can state an opposing view fairly and then explain why my position is still stronger.
- My conclusion restates my position and reasons without adding a new argument.
Curriculum focus: English — Writing: argument and persuasion · The New Zealand Curriculum
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
The model essay was written for this lesson. Its claims about sleep are kept general on purpose; it contains no statistics. If students want to add evidence, have them use sources you supply in class rather than searching online.
Key vocabulary
- argument essay
- An essay that takes a position on an issue and uses reasons and evidence to convince the reader.
- position statement
- A sentence in the introduction that states exactly what the writer believes and often previews the main reasons.
- topic sentence
- The first sentence of a paragraph, which states the paragraph's main point.
- evidence
- Facts, examples, expert views or experiences that support a point.
- counterargument
- A reason someone might give for the opposite view.
- rebuttal
- The writer's response to a counterargument, explaining why their own position still holds.
- connective
- A word or phrase that links ideas, e.g. furthermore, however, therefore, as a result.
- conclusion
- The final paragraph, which restates the position, sums up the reasons and leaves the reader with a final thought.
In the glossary: conclusion, connective, evidence, paragraph, persuasive text, rebuttal, thesis, topic sentence
Materials & preparation
You will need
- The model essay 'Our School Day Should Start Later' (printed, one per pair, text in Preparation)
- Highlighters in four colours per pair (or four coloured pencils)
- PEEL planning frame (printable): four boxes labelled Point, Explain, Evidence/Example, Link
- Essay planning sheet: Introduction / Body 1 / Body 2 / Counterargument and rebuttal / Conclusion
- Mini whiteboards and markers
- The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Print the model essay. Our School Day Should Start Later. *(Introduction)* Every weekday morning, students drag themselves out of bed, gulp down breakfast and rush out the door before they feel properly awake. By the time the first lesson begins, many are yawning instead of learning. I believe our school should start forty-five minutes later, because students would be better rested, would learn more in their first lessons and would have calmer mornings at home.
- *(Body 1)* The most important reason for a later start is that students would get more sleep. Sleep researchers have found that as children move towards their teenage years, their body clocks shift later, so many do not feel sleepy until later at night. The school bell, however, rings at the same time, so these students are woken while their bodies still need rest. Imagine Kai, who lies awake until after ten o'clock even when he goes to bed at nine. If he has to be up at seven, he loses sleep every school night, and by Friday he is exhausted. A later start would let students like Kai wake when their bodies are ready, which is why our school should change its timetable.
- *(Body 2)* Furthermore, a later start would help students learn more in their first lessons. When people are tired, it is harder to concentrate, to remember new information and to stay patient with a tricky problem. Picture the first lesson on a cold, dark winter morning: heads resting on desks, slow answers and plenty of 'Can you say that again?' Those first minutes are often wasted. If students arrived awake and alert, every lesson of the day could be used well, so a later start would make our school day more productive.
- *(Counterargument and rebuttal)* Some people argue that a later start would cause problems for families, because parents who begin work early need to drop their children off first. This is a fair concern. However, the school could open the library for supervised quiet reading before the official start, so students who arrive early would still have a safe, calm place to go. A later start does not have to mean a later arrival for everyone; it simply means the learning begins when more students are ready for it.
- *(Conclusion)* Starting forty-five minutes later is a small change that could make a big difference. Rested students learn better, mornings at home become calmer, and a supervised early room means no family is left out. It is time for our school to let its students wake up before we ask them to learn.
- Prepare the four-colour highlighting key on the board: yellow = position statement; green = topic sentences (Points); blue = evidence or examples; pink = counterargument and rebuttal.
- Write three essay topics on the board for students to choose from: 'Students should be allowed to use phones at lunchtime', 'Every school should have a four-day week of lessons and one day of clubs', 'Homework should be optional'. Students may argue for or against.
Lesson sequence
- 1
Hook: quick vote and reasons
5 minTeacher
- Say: 'Stand up if you think school should start later. Stay seated if you think it should stay the same.' Count quickly.
- Ask one student from each side: 'Give me your best reason in one sentence.' Write both reasons on the board.
- Say: 'Having an opinion is easy. Convincing someone who disagrees with you is a skill. Today you will learn the structure that makes an argument convincing: position, PEEL paragraphs, a counterargument and a conclusion.'
Students
- Vote by standing or sitting.
- Give a one-sentence reason.
- 2
Deconstruct the model essay
15 minTeacher
- Hand out the model essay, one per pair. Read it aloud while students follow.
- Say: 'An argument essay has a skeleton. Let's find the bones.' Point to the highlighting key.
- Say: 'First, the position statement. Find the one sentence that tells us exactly what the writer believes. Highlight it yellow.' (I believe our school should start forty-five minutes later, because students would be better rested, would learn more in their first lessons and would have calmer mornings at home.)
- Ask: 'What does this sentence do as well as giving the opinion?' (It previews the reasons, like a map of the essay.)
- Say: 'Now highlight the first sentence of each body paragraph in green. These are topic sentences.' Check: 'The most important reason for a later start is that students would get more sleep.' 'Furthermore, a later start would help students learn more in their first lessons.'
- Say: 'Highlight in blue anything that works as evidence or an example.' Discuss: the sleep researchers' finding, the example of Kai, the picture of the winter-morning lesson.
- Say: 'Find the paragraph that admits the other side has a point. Highlight it pink.' Ask: 'Why would a writer include the opposite view? Doesn't that weaken the argument?' Draw out: 'It shows you have thought about it fairly, and it lets you answer the objection before the reader raises it.'
- Ask: 'Does the conclusion introduce any new reasons?' (No. It restates the position, sums up the reasons and ends with a final thought.)
Students
- Follow the reading.
- Highlight the four parts with a partner.
- Explain why the counterargument makes the essay stronger.
- 3
Explicit teaching: PEEL paragraphs
10 minTeacher
- Write P, E, E, L down the side of the board. Say: 'Point: your topic sentence. Explain: why or how this is true. Evidence or example: something specific that proves it. Link: connect back to your position.'
- Label Body 1 together. Point: 'The most important reason for a later start is that students would get more sleep.' Explain: 'Sleep researchers have found … woken while their bodies still need rest.' Evidence or example: 'Imagine Kai … by Friday he is exhausted.' Link: 'A later start would let students like Kai wake when their bodies are ready, which is why our school should change its timetable.'
- Say: 'Watch what happens when we remove the E and E.' Read only: 'The most important reason is students would get more sleep. So we should start later.' Ask: 'Convinced?' (No. It is just an opinion repeated.)
- Show a weak piece of evidence: 'Everyone knows school starts too early.' Ask: 'Why is this weak?' (It is not specific; "everyone" is not true; it gives no reason.) Say: 'Good evidence is specific: an example, an experience, a fact you can check or what an expert says.'
- Teach connectives on the board: to add a reason — Furthermore, In addition, Another reason; to contrast — However, On the other hand; to show a result — Therefore, As a result, This means.
Students
- Label the PEEL parts of Body 1 aloud.
- Explain why the stripped-down paragraph is not convincing.
- 4
Explicit teaching: counterargument and rebuttal
8 minTeacher
- Write the frame: 'Some people argue that ___ because ___. This is a fair point. However, ___, so ___.'
- Model one live for the topic 'Homework should be optional': 'Some people argue that homework should be compulsory because practice helps students remember what they learnt. This is a fair point. However, students who need practice can still choose to do it, and those who are already confident can spend the time reading, playing sport or helping at home, so making homework optional respects how different students learn best.'
- Say: 'Notice the rebuttal does not insult the other side. It agrees the concern is real, then gives a solution or a stronger reason.'
- Students write one counterargument and rebuttal on whiteboards for 'Students should be allowed to use phones at lunchtime'. Share two or three and give feedback.
Students
- Write a counterargument and rebuttal on whiteboards using the frame.
- Listen to feedback on shared examples.
- 5
Plan and draft
17 minTeacher
- Say: 'Choose one topic from the board and decide which side you will argue. You don't have to pick the side you really agree with; arguing the other side is great practice.'
- Say: 'Spend five minutes filling in the planning sheet: your position statement, two reasons, an example for each, and one counterargument with a rebuttal.'
- Then say: 'Now write your introduction and your first PEEL paragraph in full. Tick off P, E, E and L in the margin as you go.'
- Conference with individual students. Ask: 'Which sentence is your Point? Where is your example? How does your last sentence link back to your position?'
Students
- Choose a topic and side.
- Complete the planning sheet.
- Draft the introduction and first PEEL paragraph, ticking each part.
- 6
Exit ticket
5 minTeacher
- Students complete the exit ticket. Collect drafts to give written feedback before the next lesson, where students write the rest of the essay.
Students
- Complete the exit ticket independently.
Worked examples
Writing a position statement
Turn this opinion into a position statement: 'I reckon uniforms are kind of bad.'
- Decide the exact claim: what should happen?
- Use confident language: avoid 'I reckon' and 'kind of'.
- Preview two or three reasons.
Our school should stop requiring uniforms, because students would be more comfortable, families would save money and students could express who they are.
Building a PEEL paragraph
Write a PEEL paragraph for the position 'Homework should be optional', using the reason 'students need time to rest'.
- Point: One important reason homework should be optional is that students need time to rest after a full school day.
- Explain: After six hours of concentrating, the brain needs a break to recharge, just as muscles need rest after sport.
- Evidence/Example: For example, Zara has netball practice two nights a week and helps cook dinner on the others. When she also has homework, she often goes to bed late and arrives at school tired.
- Link: Making homework optional would let students like Zara rest when they need to, which is why it should not be compulsory.
The four sentences together form one complete PEEL paragraph.
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Argument Essay Practice
Use the model essay 'Our School Day Should Start Later' and what you learnt about PEEL to answer each question.
- 1Copy the position statement from the model essay.
- 2In Body 1 of the model essay, which sentence is the Link?
- 3Which is the strongest topic sentence for an essay arguing for a longer lunch break? A: 'Lunch is a meal.' B: 'A longer lunch break would give students more time to be active, which helps them focus in the afternoon.' C: 'I think lunch is good.'
- 4Why is 'Everyone knows homework is pointless' weak evidence? Rewrite it as a stronger example.
- 5Fill in each gap with However or Therefore: 'Phones can distract students in class. ___, they are useful for contacting family after school. ___, phones should be allowed at school but kept in bags during lessons.'
- 6Write a counterargument and rebuttal for the position 'School uniforms should be compulsory'.
- 7Name one thing a conclusion should do and one thing it should NOT do.
- 8Put these sentences in PEEL order: (a) For instance, Priya's class planted a vegetable garden and used the produce in a shared lunch. (b) This is why every school should have a garden. (c) School gardens teach students where food comes from. (d) When students grow food themselves, they see each step from seed to plate.
Show answersHide answers
- I believe our school should start forty-five minutes later, because students would be better rested, would learn more in their first lessons and would have calmer mornings at home.
- A later start would let students like Kai wake when their bodies are ready, which is why our school should change its timetable.
- B. It states a clear point that supports the position and hints at the explanation. A is a fact that doesn't argue anything; C is vague.
- It is not specific and 'everyone' is an exaggeration, so it proves nothing. Stronger (accept any specific example), e.g. 'Last term, Liam spent forty minutes on a worksheet of questions he could already answer, time he could have spent reading a book he chose.'
- 'Phones can distract students in class. However, they are useful for contacting family after school. Therefore, phones should be allowed at school but kept in bags during lessons.' (However shows a contrast; Therefore shows a result or conclusion.)
- Model answer: 'Some people argue that uniforms stop students expressing their individuality. This is a fair point. However, students can still show who they are through their ideas, their hobbies and their work, and a uniform means nobody is judged on how expensive their clothes are, so uniforms should stay compulsory.' (Accept any answer that fairly states an opposing view and responds to it.)
- Should: restate the position, sum up the main reasons or end with a final thought. Should NOT: introduce a new argument or new evidence.
- c (Point), d (Explain), a (Evidence/Example), b (Link).
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Provide sentence starters for each PEEL part: 'One reason … is that …', 'This is because …', 'For example, …', 'This shows that …'.
- Allow students to plan orally with a partner before writing, and to draft one PEEL paragraph instead of the introduction and a paragraph.
- Give the model essay with the parts already colour-coded for reference.
Core task
- Plan the whole essay and draft the introduction and first PEEL paragraph.
Extension challenge
- Write a second counterargument and rebuttal for your essay, choosing the strongest objection you can think of.
- Rewrite the model essay's conclusion to end with a question or a vivid image, and explain which ending is more persuasive.
- Argue the opposite side of your own topic in a single PEEL paragraph.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Check highlighting during the deconstruction for accurate identification of position, topic sentences, evidence and counterargument.
- Check whiteboard counterarguments for a fair statement of the opposing view and a genuine response.
- Read draft PEEL paragraphs against the success criteria: clear Point, Explanation, specific Evidence and a Link to the position.
- Sort exit tickets into secure / nearly / not yet.
Exit ticket
- What do the letters in PEEL stand for?
- Why does a strong argument essay include a counterargument?
- Write a position statement for 'Homework should be optional' (for or against).
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- Point, Explain, Evidence (or Example), Link.
- It shows the writer has considered other views fairly and lets them answer an objection before the reader raises it, which makes the argument more convincing.
- Any clear statement with reasons, e.g. 'Homework should be optional, because students need time to rest, families have busy evenings and students learn best when they choose to practise.'
Common misconceptions
- More reasons are always better. Two or three well-developed PEEL paragraphs are more convincing than six one-line reasons.
- Including the other side weakens my argument. A fair counterargument with a rebuttal makes the writer more believable.
- Evidence must be a statistic. Specific examples, experiences and expert views are evidence too. Invented statistics are not acceptable.
- The conclusion is the place for my best new point. A conclusion sums up; new arguments belong in the body.
- Strong language means shouting. Confident, reasoned language ('Our school should …') persuades better than exaggeration or insults.
Extension
- In the next lesson students complete the full essay, then peer-review with a PEEL checklist.
- Hold a short structured debate on the chosen topics, using the essays as speaking notes.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
More lesson plans
Digraphs sh, ch and th: Hearing, Reading and Writing Words Like ship, chop and thin
A teacher-led phonics lesson for beginning readers: two letters, one sound. Students hear sh, ch and th at the start and end of words, learn an action for each sound, read and build short words such as ship, chop, thin and fish, sort words by digraph and write words from dictation. All practice is show-and-say, so it works before students can read independently.
High-Frequency Words: Sounding Out the Regular Parts and Learning the Tricky Parts by Heart
Students learn common high-frequency words, such as the and said, with a heart word routine: say the word, tap its sounds, match each sound to its letters and mark the tricky part with a heart. Regular words are sounded out, never guessed. Quick, active games build fast, accurate reading and spelling of the words.
Letter Sounds and Blending CVC Words: Phonics for New Entrants
A fully teacher-led phonics lesson: students listen for the first sound in spoken words, link sounds to letters, then blend three sounds into simple consonant-vowel-consonant words such as sat, map and sun. Movement, robot talk and 'show and say' answers mean every task works for students who are just beginning to read.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.