Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Careers for educators

Student mentoring skills for teachers and tutors

Build practical mentoring skills: goal-setting with students, feedback that helps, supporting motivation and holding growth-oriented conversations.

3 min read

Mentoring is the part of teaching that sits beside the content: helping a student decide what they're aiming for, notice their own progress and keep going when it's hard. Classroom teachers do it in conversations at the edge of a lesson. Tutors often do it more directly, because they work with fewer students over a longer stretch. Either way, mentoring is a skill you can practise and improve.

Start with the relationship

Students take advice from people they trust. Before you set goals or give feedback, make sure the student knows you're on their side.

  • Ask about their interests, and remember the answers.
  • Listen more than you talk in early conversations.
  • Be reliable: do what you said you'd do, and follow up.
  • Keep confidences appropriately, while being clear that you must pass on any safety concern.

Goal-setting that students own

Goals work best when students help write them and can see progress. A useful structure is to agree one main goal at a time, break it into small steps, and decide together how you'll both know it's happening.

  1. Ask, don't tell. 'What would you like to be able to do by the end of term that you can't do yet?'
  2. Make it specific. 'Get better at writing' becomes 'Write a paragraph with a clear topic sentence and two pieces of evidence.'
  3. Focus on actions within their control. 'Practise for ten minutes after dinner on three nights' is something a student can do, whereas a particular mark depends on many factors.
  4. Plan for obstacles. 'What might get in the way? What will you do if that happens?'
  5. Review regularly. Revisit the goal briefly each week or session and adjust it if needed.

Feedback that helps

Feedback is most useful when the student can act on it straight away. A simple pattern is: what's working, one thing to improve, and how to do it.

  • Be specific about the work: 'Your second paragraph explains the cause clearly' rather than 'Good job'.
  • Limit improvements to one or two at a time so they feel achievable.
  • Give students time to use the feedback in the same session, if possible.
  • Ask the student to say the feedback back in their own words.
  • Praise effective strategies and effort rather than labelling the student as 'smart' or 'naturally good at it'.

Supporting motivation

Motivation is rarely fixed. It tends to grow when students feel some control over what they're doing, when they experience success, and when they feel connected to the people around them.

  • Choice. Offer small choices: which problem to try first, which topic to write about, how to show their thinking.
  • Competence. Pitch tasks so students can succeed with effort. Too easy is boring; too hard is discouraging.
  • Connection. Show genuine interest in their progress, and link learning to things they care about.
  • Visible progress. Keep examples of earlier work so students can compare and see how far they've come.

Growth-oriented conversations

When a student is frustrated or says 'I'm just bad at this', the way you respond can shift how they see their own learning. The aim is not to pretend everything is easy, but to show that difficulty is a normal part of improving.

  • Acknowledge the feeling first: 'This is a tricky one. It's normal to feel stuck.'
  • Add 'yet': 'You can't do this yet. Let's look at what you can already do.'
  • Point to evidence of past growth: 'Remember when long division felt like this?'
  • Ask about strategy: 'What have you tried? What else could you try?'
  • Invite reflection at the end: 'What helped you today? What will you do next time you get stuck?'

Working with families

When appropriate, share students' goals and progress with families so they can reinforce the same messages at home. Keep the student at the centre: where possible, let them explain their own goals and progress, and frame updates around effort, strategies and next steps.

Know the limits of mentoring

Mentoring supports learning and wellbeing, but it isn't counselling. If a student shares something that worries you about their safety or mental health, follow your school's or employer's procedures and refer them to the appropriate staff or services. Look after yourself too: mentoring is rewarding, and it can also be emotionally demanding.

Practising the skill

Choose one technique from this article and use it deliberately for two weeks, such as student-written goals or the 'what's working, one improvement, how' feedback pattern. Note what changes. Mentoring improves with practice and reflection, just like any other part of teaching.