Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Reading comprehension

Fact or Opinion Sort

Students sort 16 original statements about octopuses into fact, opinion or both, using clue words and the test 'Could I check this?'. Includes a tricky false fact and a full answer key with reasons.

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Setup

  1. Print one statement sheet per pair.
  2. Draw a three-column table on the board headed Fact, Opinion and Both.
  3. Write the two tests on the board: Fact: Could I check it in a reliable book or by observing? Opinion: Is it what someone thinks or feels? Could someone reasonably disagree?
  4. Write these opinion clue words on the board: best, worst, most, should, cute, creepy, fun, interesting, I think.

How to run the activity

  1. 1Say: 'A fact is something that can be checked and proven. An opinion is what someone thinks or feels, and other people could disagree.'
  2. 2Model two statements from the sheet. Statement 1: 'An octopus has eight arms. Could I check it? Yes, in any animal book. Fact.' Statement 2: 'Octopuses are the most amazing animals in the ocean. Could someone disagree? Yes, a shark fan might! And I can see the clue word most. Opinion.'
  3. 3Pairs color-code statements 3 to 16: one color for fact, one for opinion, and one for statements that contain both. They must agree before coloring.
  4. 4Circulate and listen for reasoning. Prompt: 'How could you check that? Which word tells you it is someone's opinion?'
  5. 5Stop the class at statement 11 ('An octopus has ten arms') if pairs are stuck. Ask: 'Is it true? Can it be checked? So is it a fact-type statement or an opinion?' Draw out that it is a statement of fact that turns out to be false when checked.
  6. 6Go through the answers, with pairs giving reasons. Write a few in the table on the board.
  7. 7Finish: each student writes one fact and one opinion of their own about an animal they like, swaps with a partner, and the partner identifies which is which.

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish between statements of fact and opinions.
  • Identify language that signals an opinion.
  • Understand that a factual statement can be checked, and may turn out to be true or false.

Printable student sheet

Fact or Opinion: Octopuses

Color each statement: one color for FACT, one for OPINION, and one for statements that are BOTH. Ask: Could I check it? Could someone reasonably disagree?

  1. 1An octopus has eight arms.
  2. 2Octopuses are the most amazing animals in the ocean.
  3. 3An octopus has three hearts.
  4. 4An octopus has no bones in its body.
  5. 5Octopuses look creepy.
  6. 6Many octopuses can change the color of their skin in less than a second.
  7. 7It would be fun to keep an octopus as a class pet.
  8. 8Many octopuses can squirt a cloud of ink to escape from predators.
  9. 9Octopus blood is blue.
  10. 10Watching an octopus is more interesting than watching a dolphin.
  11. 11An octopus has ten arms.
  12. 12Octopuses have suckers on their arms.
  13. 13Everyone should learn about octopuses at school.
  14. 14The best color for an octopus is red.
  15. 15Octopuses have eight arms, and they are the cutest creatures in the sea.
  16. 16Scientists have seen octopuses unscrew the lids of jars.
Show answers and teacher guidance
  1. Fact. It can be checked in any reliable animal reference book.
  2. Opinion. 'Most amazing' is a judgment; others might choose a different animal.
  3. Fact. Scientists have confirmed this: two hearts pump blood through the gills and one pumps it around the body.
  4. Fact. Octopuses are invertebrates with soft bodies, which lets them squeeze through small gaps.
  5. Opinion. 'Creepy' is a feeling; many people think octopuses look beautiful.
  6. Fact. This has been observed and filmed by scientists.
  7. Opinion. 'Fun' is a judgment, and others could disagree (it would also be very hard to care for one).
  8. Fact. This can be checked in reference books and has been observed in the wild.
  9. Fact. Octopus blood uses copper to carry oxygen, which makes it blue.
  10. Opinion. 'More interesting' depends on the person.
  11. Statement of fact, but false. It can be checked, and checking shows an octopus has eight arms. Accept 'fact-type statement that is wrong' as the best answer.
  12. Fact. The suckers help them grip, taste and feel.
  13. Opinion. The clue word 'should' tells us it is what someone thinks ought to happen.
  14. Opinion. 'Best' is a judgment; there is no way to prove one color is best.
  15. Both. The first part is a fact that can be checked; 'cutest' is an opinion.
  16. Fact. It describes something that was observed and recorded, so it can be checked.

Variations

  • Stand up, sit down: read each statement aloud; students stand for fact and sit for opinion, then justify.
  • Cut and sort: pairs cut the statements into strips and sort them into three piles.
  • Topic swap: write 10 statements about your current science or history topic for the same routine.

Extension

  • Rewrite three opinions as facts, e.g. 'Octopuses look creepy' becomes 'Octopuses have soft bodies with no bones.'
  • Write a short persuasive paragraph about octopuses using at least two facts to support one opinion.

Additional support

  • Sort only into fact and opinion (leave out 'both' and statement 11).
  • Highlight the opinion clue words on the board in the same color students use for opinion.

Extension challenge

  • Students explain why statement 16 is a fact even though it is about what scientists saw, and decide what makes a source of facts reliable.

Teacher notes

  • All factual statements have been checked. Octopuses really do have three hearts and blue, copper-based blood, and have been observed unscrewing jar lids in aquariums.
  • Statement 11 is deliberately false. It is a good chance to teach that 'fact' means 'can be checked', and checking is how we find out whether a claim is true.
  • Some students will argue 'Octopuses are clever' is a fact. That statement is not on the sheet, but it is a good discussion: scientists measure problem-solving, so a precise version can be a fact.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More reading comprehension