Grade 3 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources
Compare and Contrast: Venn Diagrams, Signal Words and Writing a Compare-and-Contrast Paragraph
Students read two original informational texts about penguins and owls, sort the details into a Venn diagram, and learn signal words for similarities (both, also, like) and differences (however, whereas, unlike). After pulling apart a model paragraph, they write their own compare-and-contrast paragraph about bicycles and scooters.
- 60 minutes
- Grade 3
- English Language Arts
- Compare and contrast
- 🇺🇸 United States
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Identify similarities and differences between two texts on the same topic and record them in a Venn diagram.
- Use signal words that show similarities (both, also, like, similarly) and differences (however, whereas, unlike, in contrast).
- Write a compare-and-contrast paragraph with a topic sentence, similarities, differences and a concluding sentence.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can sort details into the Only A, Only B and Both parts of a Venn diagram.
- I can use at least two similarity signal words and two difference signal words.
- My paragraph has a topic sentence that names both things, sentences about how they are the same and different, and a concluding sentence.
Curriculum focus: Reading — Informational Text; Writing · State standards (Texas TEKS first)
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
Compare and contrast as a text structure appears regularly on STAAR reading in Grades 3 and 4.
Key vocabulary
- compare
- Look at how two or more things are the same (and sometimes also how they are different).
- contrast
- Look at how two or more things are different.
- Venn diagram
- Two overlapping circles. Details that belong to only one thing go in its own circle; details that belong to both go in the overlap.
- similarity
- A way that two things are the same.
- difference
- A way that two things are not the same.
- topic sentence
- The first sentence of a paragraph. It tells the reader what the whole paragraph is about.
In the glossary: compare and contrast, difference, paragraph, topic sentence, Venn diagram
Materials & preparation
You will need
- Text A (Penguins) and Text B (Owls) printed side by side, one copy per student (see preparation)
- A blank Venn diagram for each student, and a large one on the board
- The bicycle and scooter fact card (see preparation), one per student or pair
- Highlighters in two colors, or two colored pencils, per student
- The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Print Text A, Penguins: 'Penguins are birds, but they cannot fly. Instead, their wings work like stiff flippers that push them through the water, so they are excellent swimmers. Penguins catch fish, squid and krill in the sea. Thick, tightly packed feathers and a layer of fat keep them warm in cold water. Almost all penguins live in the southern half of the world. Some live on the ice of Antarctica, while others live on rocky coasts and beaches. Penguins lay eggs, and in most kinds of penguin both parents take turns keeping the eggs warm.'
- Print Text B, Owls: 'Owls are birds that can fly almost silently. Their soft feathers have fringed edges that muffle the sound of their wings, so their prey does not hear them coming. Most owls hunt at night, using their large eyes and excellent hearing to find mice, insects and other small animals. Owls often swallow small prey whole. Later, they cough up a pellet of the fur and bones they could not digest. Owls live on every continent except Antarctica, in forests, deserts, grasslands and even cities. Like all birds, owls lay eggs.'
- Print the fact card, Bicycles and Scooters: 'Both have wheels and handlebars. Both are used for getting around, and riders of both should wear a helmet. A bicycle usually has two wheels, pedals, a chain and a seat. The rider sits down and pushes the pedals to turn the back wheel. Bicycles are good for longer trips. A kick scooter has two or three small wheels and a flat deck. The rider stands on the deck and pushes along the ground with one foot. Many scooters fold up small enough to carry.'
- Write the signal word chart on the board. Same: both, also, too, like, similarly, in the same way. Different: however, but, whereas, while, unlike, in contrast, on the other hand.
Lesson sequence
- 1
Hook: same or different?
5 minTeacher
- Hold up a pencil and a pen. Ask: 'How are these the same?' (Both are used for writing; both are long and thin; both fit in a pencil case.) 'How are they different?' (A pencil can be erased; a pen uses ink; a pencil needs sharpening.)
- Say: 'When we say how things are the same, we compare. When we say how they are different, we contrast. Today we'll do this with two texts, then write a paragraph that does both.'
Students
- Suggest similarities and differences between a pencil and a pen.
- 2
Explicit teaching: the Venn diagram and signal words
8 minTeacher
- Draw two overlapping circles on the board, labeled Pencil and Pen. Say: 'Things that are true only for the pencil go in its circle. Things true only for the pen go in its circle. Things true for both go in the middle, where the circles overlap.' Fill it in using the hook ideas.
- Point to the signal word chart. Say: 'Writers use special words to show they're comparing. Both, also and like tell the reader a similarity is coming. However, whereas and unlike tell the reader a difference is coming.'
- Model two sentences: 'Both pencils and pens are used for writing.' 'A pencil can be erased, whereas a pen usually cannot.' Ask: 'Which sentence shows a similarity? Which word told you?' (The first; both.)
Students
- Help fill the pencil and pen Venn diagram and identify signal words in the model sentences.
- 3
Reading two texts and building a Venn diagram
15 minTeacher
- Read Text A aloud while students follow, then Text B. Say: 'As we read the second time, highlight facts about penguins in one color and facts about owls in the other.'
- Model the first detail: 'Penguins are birds. Owls are birds too. So birds goes in the middle, in Both.' Write it in the overlap.
- Pairs complete their Venn diagrams. After 8 minutes, take answers and fill in the class diagram. Both: birds, have feathers, lay eggs, eat other animals. Penguins only: cannot fly, wings work as flippers, excellent swimmers, eat fish, squid and krill, fat and thick feathers keep them warm, almost all live in the southern half of the world, some live in Antarctica. Owls only: can fly almost silently, fringed feathers muffle sound, most hunt at night, eat mice and insects, swallow small prey whole and cough up pellets, live on every continent except Antarctica.
- Ask: 'Where does lives in Antarctica go?' (Penguins only. Text B says owls live on every continent except Antarctica.) Say: 'Good readers check both texts before deciding a detail goes in the middle.'
- Ask: 'Do both birds eat other animals?' (Yes: penguins eat fish, squid and krill; owls eat mice and insects.) Say: 'So eat other animals goes in Both, but what they eat goes in each circle. A big idea can be the same even when the details are different.'
Students
- Highlight details in each text and sort them into a Venn diagram with a partner.
- 4
Pulling apart a model paragraph
10 minTeacher
- Display the model paragraph: 'Penguins and owls are both birds, but they live very different lives. Like all birds, both have feathers and lay eggs, and both hunt other animals for food. However, penguins cannot fly, whereas owls fly so quietly that their prey cannot hear them. Penguins use their flipper-like wings to swim and catch fish, squid and krill in the sea. In contrast, most owls hunt mice and insects on land at night. Where they live is different too: almost all penguins live in the southern half of the world, including Antarctica, while owls live on every continent except Antarctica. These two birds show how differently animals in the same group can live.'
- Say: 'Let's find the parts.' Underline the topic sentence. Ask: 'What does it tell us?' (Both things being compared, and that they are the same in one way but different in others.)
- Ask students to find the similarity sentence (sentence 2) and the difference sentences (sentences 3 to 6). Circle every signal word together: both, but, Like, both, both, However, whereas, In contrast, while.
- Point to the last sentence. Say: 'The concluding sentence sums up the big idea without repeating every detail.' Write the frame on the board: Topic sentence → How they are the same → How they are different → Concluding sentence.
Students
- Identify the topic sentence, similarity sentence, difference sentences, signal words and concluding sentence.
- 5
Writing: a compare-and-contrast paragraph
15 minTeacher
- Hand out the Bicycles and Scooters fact card. Say: 'First, sort the facts into a quick Venn diagram. Then write your paragraph using the frame. Use at least two similarity words and two difference words from the chart.'
- Give the topic sentence starter for anyone who needs it: 'Bicycles and scooters are both ways to get around, but they work in different ways.'
- Work with a small group on the additional support task while others write independently. Ask as you circulate: 'Which signal word shows the reader this is a difference?'
Students
- Sort the bicycle and scooter facts into a Venn diagram, then write a compare-and-contrast paragraph.
- 6
Share and exit ticket
7 minTeacher
- Ask two or three volunteers to read their paragraphs. The class listens for signal words and puts a hand up each time they hear one.
- Students complete the exit ticket. Sort into secure / nearly / not yet to plan the next lesson.
Students
- Listen for signal words, then complete the exit ticket on their own.
Worked examples
Sorting details into a Venn diagram
Sort these details for penguins and owls: lay eggs; can fly; live in Antarctica; have feathers; most hunt at night; excellent swimmers.
- Check each detail against both texts.
- Lay eggs: both texts say so. Both.
- Can fly: only owls. Penguins cannot fly. Owls only.
- Live in Antarctica: some penguins do; owls live everywhere except Antarctica. Penguins only.
- Have feathers: penguins have thick, tightly packed feathers; owls have soft, fringed feathers. Both.
- Most hunt at night: only Text B says this. Owls only.
- Excellent swimmers: only Text A says this. Penguins only.
Both: lay eggs, have feathers. Penguins only: live in Antarctica, excellent swimmers. Owls only: can fly, most hunt at night.
Turning a Venn diagram into sentences
Write one similarity sentence and one difference sentence about bicycles and scooters.
- Pick a detail from the overlap: both have wheels and handlebars.
- Start with a similarity signal word: 'Both bicycles and scooters have wheels and handlebars.'
- Pick one detail from each circle that match up: a bicycle rider sits and pedals; a scooter rider stands and pushes with one foot.
- Join them with a difference signal word: 'A bicycle rider sits and pushes the pedals, whereas a scooter rider stands on the deck and pushes along the ground with one foot.'
Similarity: 'Both bicycles and scooters have wheels and handlebars.' Difference: 'A bicycle rider sits and pushes the pedals, whereas a scooter rider stands and pushes along the ground with one foot.'
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Compare and Contrast Practice
Use Text A (Penguins), Text B (Owls) and the Bicycles and Scooters fact card to answer the questions. Write in full sentences unless the question says otherwise.
- 1Write P (penguins only), O (owls only) or B (both): a) have feathers b) cough up pellets c) wings work like flippers d) lay eggs e) live on every continent except Antarctica.
- 2Name two ways penguins and owls are the same, according to the texts.
- 3Name two ways penguins and owls are different.
- 4Circle the signal word and say whether it shows a similarity or a difference: 'Penguins catch food in the sea. In contrast, owls catch food on land.'
- 5Choose the best signal word to complete the sentence: 'Penguins lay eggs. Owls ___ lay eggs.' (also / however / whereas)
- 6Choose the best signal word: 'A bicycle has pedals, ___ a kick scooter does not.' (both / whereas / similarly)
- 7Zara put 'eat fish' in the middle of her Venn diagram. Is she right? Explain using the texts.
- 8Write a topic sentence for a paragraph comparing bicycles and scooters.
- 9Write one sentence about how bicycles and scooters are the same. Use a similarity signal word.
- 10Write one sentence about how bicycles and scooters are different. Use a difference signal word.
- 11Write a full compare-and-contrast paragraph (5 to 7 sentences) about bicycles and scooters.
Show answersHide answers
- a) B b) O c) P d) B e) O
- Any two of: both are birds; both have feathers; both lay eggs; both eat other animals.
- Any two of: penguins cannot fly but owls can; penguins swim but owls hunt on land; penguins eat fish, squid and krill but owls eat mice and insects; most owls hunt at night; almost all penguins live in the southern half of the world, while owls live on every continent except Antarctica.
- In contrast. It shows a difference.
- also
- whereas
- No. Text A says penguins eat fish, but Text B says owls eat mice, insects and other small animals. 'Eat fish' belongs in the penguins circle. 'Eat other animals' could go in the middle.
- Answers will vary. It must name both things and hint at similarities and differences, e.g. 'Bicycles and scooters are both ways to get around, but they work in different ways.'
- Answers will vary, e.g. 'Both bicycles and scooters have wheels and handlebars.' or 'Like bicycle riders, scooter riders should wear a helmet.'
- Answers will vary, e.g. 'A bicycle has a seat, whereas a scooter rider stands on a flat deck.' or 'Unlike bicycles, many scooters fold up small enough to carry.'
- Answers will vary. Check for: a topic sentence naming both; at least one similarity with a signal word (both, also, like); at least two differences with signal words (whereas, however, unlike, in contrast); facts taken accurately from the fact card; and a concluding sentence.
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Give a Venn diagram with some details already written in, and cards for the rest to sort.
- Provide a paragraph frame: 'Bicycles and scooters are both ___. Both have ___. However, a bicycle ___, whereas a scooter ___. Unlike a bicycle, a scooter ___. Overall, ___.'
- Let students write three sentences (topic, one similarity, one difference) instead of a full paragraph.
Core task
- Complete practice questions 1 to 11, including the full paragraph.
Extension challenge
- Write the paragraph in two different ways: first all the similarities then all the differences, and then going point by point (seat, wheels, how you move). Explain which is easier to read.
- Add a third text of your own choice to the penguin and owl comparison using a three-circle Venn diagram.
- Rewrite the model paragraph using different signal words without changing the meaning.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Check Venn diagrams: are details in the overlap true for both texts?
- Use practice question 7 to check whether students compare big ideas (eat other animals) and details (eat fish) correctly.
- Mark paragraphs against the success criteria: topic sentence, similarity, differences, signal words, concluding sentence.
- Sort exit tickets into secure / nearly / not yet to plan the next lesson.
Exit ticket
- Write two signal words that show a similarity and two that show a difference.
- In a Venn diagram, where do you write a detail that is true for both things?
- Write one sentence that contrasts penguins and owls.
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- Similarity: any two of both, also, too, like, similarly, in the same way. Difference: any two of however, but, whereas, while, unlike, in contrast, on the other hand.
- In the middle, where the two circles overlap.
- Answers will vary, e.g. 'Penguins cannot fly, whereas owls can fly almost silently.' Check for a correct fact and a difference signal word.
Common misconceptions
- Compare only means find differences. Compare usually means looking at similarities (and often differences too); contrast means looking at differences.
- If one text doesn't mention something, it is a difference. Text B doesn't mention feathers keeping owls warm, but that doesn't mean owls' feathers don't. Only use what the texts actually say, and check both texts.
- Listing facts is a compare-and-contrast paragraph. The paragraph must link the two things with signal words, not describe one and then the other with no connection.
- Both details must match exactly to go in the middle. A big idea can be shared (both eat other animals) even when the details differ (fish versus mice).
Extension
- Compare two characters from a class novel or picture book using a Venn diagram, then write a paragraph.
- Cross-curriculum link: compare two places, two materials or two animals your class is studying, using the same paragraph frame.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
Interactive games
More lesson plans
Digraphs sh, ch and th: Hearing, Reading and Writing Words Like ship, chop and thin
A teacher-led phonics lesson for beginning readers: two letters, one sound. Students hear sh, ch and th at the start and end of words, learn an action for each sound, read and build short words such as ship, chop, thin and fish, sort words by digraph and write words from dictation. All practice is show-and-say, so it works before students can read independently.
High-Frequency Words: Sounding Out the Regular Parts and Learning the Tricky Parts by Heart
Students learn common high-frequency words, such as the and said, with a heart word routine: say the word, tap its sounds, match each sound to its letters and mark the tricky part with a heart. Regular words are sounded out, never guessed. Quick, active games build fast, accurate reading and spelling of the words.
Phonological Awareness: Hearing Rhyme and Clapping Syllables
A playful listening lesson for beginning readers. Students learn that rhyming words sound the same at the end (cat, hat), judge whether word pairs rhyme, make their own rhymes, then clap, stamp and use the chin-drop trick to count the syllables in names and everyday words. No reading or writing needed.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.