Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Grade 4 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources

4th Grade STAAR Extended Constructed Response Review: Writing an Informational Essay from a Passage

A STAAR-style extended constructed response review: students unpack an essay prompt, read an original passage about city trees, plan a central idea with reasons, use and explain text evidence, and organize an informational essay with an introduction, body paragraphs, transitions and a conclusion. Includes an annotated model essay and a classroom scoring guide.

  • 60 minutes
  • Grade 4
  • English Language Arts
  • Extended constructed response: informational essay
  • 🇺🇸 United States

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Unpack an extended constructed response prompt to identify the task, the topic and the type of writing.
  • Plan and write an informational essay with a clear central idea supported by evidence from a passage.
  • Explain how each piece of evidence supports the central idea, and organize the essay with an introduction, body paragraphs, transitions and a conclusion.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can write a central idea sentence that answers the prompt.
  • I can use at least two pieces of evidence from the passage in my own words.
  • I can explain my evidence with a sentence such as 'This shows that…'.
  • I can organize my essay into an introduction, body paragraphs and a conclusion, linked with transitions.
  • I can check my essay for complete sentences, capital letters, punctuation and spelling.

Curriculum focus: Writing — Composition: Informational Text · State standards (Texas TEKS first)

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

This is a review lesson written in the style of STAAR reading language arts questions. The passages, drafts and questions are original and are not official STAAR material, and the scoring guides are classroom guides, not the official STAAR rubrics. Released STAAR tests and scoring information are published by the Texas Education Agency.

More Texas teacher resources (TEKS and STAAR)

Key vocabulary

prompt
The directions that tell you what to write about and what kind of writing to do.
informational essay
Writing that explains or teaches about a topic using facts and evidence, not opinions.
central idea
The one main point your whole essay explains. It is usually stated in the introduction.
evidence
Facts and details from the passage that support your central idea.
elaboration
Your own sentences that explain how the evidence supports your point.
transition
A word or phrase that links ideas, such as 'First', 'Another way', 'Also' or 'In conclusion'.

In the glossary: evidence, informative text

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • The passage 'Trees in the City' (in the Preparation notes), printed with numbered paragraphs — one copy per student
  • The essay prompt, printed at the top of lined paper
  • A planning organizer: a box for the central idea, two or three boxes for body paragraphs (point, evidence, explanation) and a box for the conclusion
  • Highlighters in two colors
  • The classroom scoring guide and the annotated model essay (in the Preparation notes and Worked examples)

Before the lesson

  1. Print the passage — 'Trees in the City': (1) On a hot summer afternoon, people walking down a city street often look for one thing: shade. But city trees do much more than give people a cool place to stand. (2) Cities are often hotter than the countryside around them. Roads, rooftops and parking lots soak up heat from the sun during the day and give it off again at night. Trees cool things down in two ways. First, their leaves block sunlight before it can reach the ground, so the ground and the air under a tree stay cooler. Second, trees take up water through their roots and let it escape as water vapor from tiny openings in their leaves. Turning liquid water into vapor uses up heat, which cools the leaves and the air around them, a little like the way sweat cools your skin on a hot day. (3) Trees also help when it rains. In a city, much of the ground is covered by roads, rooftops and concrete, so rain cannot soak in. The water rushes into storm drains, and during a heavy storm the drains can fill up faster than they can empty, which can cause flooding. Trees slow the water down. Their leaves and branches catch some of the rain, and their roots make spaces in the soil so that more water can soak into the ground. (4) City trees are homes, too. Birds and squirrels build nests in the branches, and many kinds of insects live on the leaves and bark. A single large tree in a schoolyard can be home to many creatures. (5) Trees can also make a city a more pleasant place to be. Many people find that walking along a shady, leafy street helps them feel calm. (6) Young city trees need help to grow big enough to do all of this. A newly planted tree needs regular watering for its first few years, until its roots grow deep enough to find water on their own. Some cities ask neighbors to adopt a young tree on their street and water it during dry weeks. (7) The next time you stand in the shade of a city tree, look up. That tree is cooling the air, catching rain and sheltering animals, all at the same time.
  2. Print the prompt: 'Read the passage "Trees in the City." Write an informational essay that explains how trees help cities. Use evidence from the passage to support your answer. Remember to: state a clear central idea; organize your writing; develop your ideas with evidence and explanation; use correct spelling, capital letters, punctuation and grammar.'
  3. Copy the classroom scoring guide onto chart paper (label it 'Our classroom guide — not the official STAAR rubric'). Ideas and organization — Strong: a clear central idea that answers the prompt; two or more pieces of relevant evidence from the passage, each explained; an introduction, body paragraphs and a conclusion linked by transitions; no unrelated ideas. Developing: a central idea that is unclear or only partly answers the prompt; evidence that is thin, copied without explanation or partly off-topic; some organization. Beginning: no central idea; little or no evidence from the passage; ideas in a list or out of order. Conventions — Strong: complete sentences and mostly correct capital letters, punctuation, spelling and grammar, so the essay is easy to read. Developing: some errors, but the meaning is clear. Beginning: many errors that make the essay hard to read.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: what is the essay really asking?

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Write two prompts: (a) 'Explain how trees help cities.' (b) 'Explain why trees are your favorite plant.'
    • Ask: 'Which prompt can you answer using only the passage? Which one asks for your opinion?' Agree that (a) is informational and must be answered with evidence from the passage.
    • Say: 'On the STAAR reading language arts test, an extended constructed response asks you to write an essay about a passage. Your job is to answer the prompt, use evidence from the passage, explain it and organize it. Today we will plan and write one together.'

    Students

    • Tell a partner which prompt needs passage evidence and why.
  2. 2

    Unpack the prompt and read the passage

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Display the prompt. Model the 'circle, underline, box' routine: circle the type of writing ('informational essay'), underline the task ('explains how trees help cities'), box the rule ('Use evidence from the passage').
    • Say: 'So my job is to EXPLAIN, not to give my opinion. Every main point must come from the passage.'
    • Read the passage aloud. After each paragraph, ask: 'Does this paragraph tell a way trees HELP cities?' Students highlight helping ideas in color 1.
    • Stop at paragraph 6. Ask: 'Does this paragraph tell how trees help cities, or how people help trees?' Agree: it is about helping trees, so it is not a main point for this prompt. Students highlight it in color 2 as 'not for my essay'.
    • List the ways trees help on the board: cooling (paragraph 2), stopping floods (paragraph 3), homes for animals (paragraph 4), helping people feel calm (paragraph 5).

    Students

    • Circle, underline and box the prompt.
    • Highlight each way trees help cities and mark paragraph 6 as 'not for my essay'.
  3. 3

    Model: plan the essay and write the introduction

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Say: 'I will choose my three strongest points, the ones with the most evidence: cooling, flooding and animal homes.' Fill in the planning organizer.
    • Model the central idea: 'City trees help cities by keeping them cooler, protecting them from flooding and giving animals a place to live.' Say: 'It answers the prompt AND tells the reader my three points, in the order I will write them.'
    • Show a weak introduction: 'Hi! My essay is about trees. I am going to tell you about them.' Ask: 'What is missing?' (A central idea; it announces instead of explaining.)
    • Write the model introduction (Worked example 1) and point out the hook sentence and the central idea.

    Students

    • Copy the central idea into the planning organizer, or write your own version using different points from the passage.
  4. 4

    Guided practice: one body paragraph together

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Write the body paragraph recipe on the board: Point (topic sentence with a transition) → Evidence (from the passage, in your own words) → Explain ('This shows that…' / 'Because of this…').
    • Build the cooling paragraph together (Worked example 2). Ask: 'Which details from paragraph 2 prove trees cool the city?' Then ask: 'What sentence can we add that explains WHY that matters?'
    • Say: 'Copying a whole paragraph from the passage is not explaining. Use the passage's facts, in your own words, and add your thinking.'

    Students

    • Suggest evidence and an explanation sentence for the cooling paragraph.
  5. 5

    Independent writing

    16 min

    Teacher

    • Students write the rest of the essay: the flooding paragraph, the animal homes paragraph and a conclusion. Students who chose different points follow their own plan.
    • Circulate with the question: 'Show me your evidence. Now show me your explanation.'
    • Support group: give the body paragraph frames and the conclusion frame (see Differentiation). If time is short, students finish one body paragraph and the conclusion, and complete the essay in the next lesson.

    Students

    • Write the body paragraphs and conclusion of the essay.
  6. 6

    Self-check and exit ticket

    7 min

    Teacher

    • Students check their essay against the Strong column of the classroom guide and tick each part they can find: central idea, two pieces of evidence, explanation, transitions, conclusion.
    • Students complete the exit ticket on their own.

    Students

    • Self-check the essay against the classroom guide.
    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Writing the introduction

Write an introduction for the essay 'Explain how trees help cities.'

  1. Hook the reader with a sentence connected to the topic, without asking the reader about themselves: 'Trees are more than a nice place to sit in the shade.'
  2. Give one sentence of background: 'In a city, trees work hard every day.'
  3. End with the central idea, which answers the prompt and names the points in order.

Annotated introduction: [hook] Trees are more than a nice place to sit in the shade. [background] In a city, trees work hard every day. [central idea that answers the prompt and previews three points] City trees help cities by keeping them cooler, protecting them from flooding and giving animals a place to live.

Writing a body paragraph with evidence and explanation

Write the body paragraph about how trees keep cities cooler.

  1. Point: begin with a transition and the first point: 'One important way trees help cities is by keeping them cooler.'
  2. Evidence 1 (paragraph 2, in my own words): roads, rooftops and parking lots soak up heat, but tree leaves block sunlight before it reaches the ground.
  3. Evidence 2 (paragraph 2): trees let water escape from their leaves as vapor, and this cools the air around them.
  4. Explain: 'This shows that a street lined with trees can be cooler and more comfortable than a street with none.'

Annotated body paragraph: [transition + point] One important way trees help cities is by keeping them cooler. [evidence, paraphrased] According to the passage, roads, rooftops and parking lots soak up heat from the sun, but tree leaves block the sunlight before it can reach the ground. [evidence] Trees also let water escape from their leaves as vapor, which cools the air around them. [explanation] This shows that a street lined with trees can be cooler and more comfortable than a street with none.

The complete model essay

Read the whole model essay and find each part of the classroom guide.

  1. Paragraph 1: introduction from Worked example 1.
  2. Paragraph 2: cooling paragraph from Worked example 2.
  3. Paragraph 3: 'Trees also protect cities from flooding. The passage explains that rain cannot soak into roads and concrete, so it rushes into storm drains that can fill up during a heavy storm. Tree leaves and branches catch some of the rain, and their roots help water soak into the soil. Because of this, less water rushes into the drains at once, so the streets are less likely to flood.'
  4. Paragraph 4: 'In addition, trees give city animals a place to live. Birds and squirrels build nests in the branches, and many insects live on the leaves and bark. Without trees, these animals would have far fewer places to live in a city.'
  5. Paragraph 5: 'Trees cool the air, catch rain and shelter animals, all at the same time. That is why every tree planted along a city street helps make the city a better place to live.'

Annotations: the central idea is in paragraph 1 and every body paragraph supports it; each body paragraph starts with a transition ('One important way', 'also', 'In addition'); every piece of evidence comes from the passage (paragraphs 2, 3 and 4) and is put in the writer's own words; each body paragraph ends with an explanation ('This shows that…', 'Because of this…', 'Without trees…'); the conclusion restates the central idea in new words without adding new evidence; the essay leaves out paragraph 6 because it is about helping trees, not how trees help cities. On the classroom guide this essay is Strong for both ideas and organization and conventions.

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Extended Constructed Response Review

Use the passage 'Trees in the City' and the prompt 'Write an informational essay that explains how trees help cities.' Give a paragraph number for any evidence you use.

  1. 1Which sentence would be the best central idea for the essay? A Trees are green and have lots of leaves. B City trees help by cooling the air, preventing floods and giving animals homes. C In this essay, I am going to tell you about trees. D Young trees need water for their first few years.
  2. 2Which detail should NOT be used as evidence in this essay? A Tree leaves block sunlight before it reaches the ground. B Tree roots help rainwater soak into the soil. C A newly planted tree needs regular watering for its first few years. D Birds and squirrels build nests in the branches.
  3. 3Paraphrase this evidence in one sentence of your own words: 'The water rushes into storm drains, and during a heavy storm the drains can fill up faster than they can empty, which can cause flooding.'
  4. 4Evidence: 'Birds and squirrels build nests in the branches, and many kinds of insects live on the leaves and bark' (paragraph 4). Write one sentence of elaboration that explains how this evidence supports the idea that trees help cities.
  5. 5Write a topic sentence, with a transition, for a body paragraph about how trees protect cities from flooding.
  6. 6This introduction is weak: 'Hi! My essay is about trees. Trees are cool.' Name two problems and rewrite it.
  7. 7Write a conclusion of two sentences for the essay. Do not add new evidence.
  8. 8Extended constructed response: Write an informational essay that explains how trees help cities. Use evidence from the passage to support your answer.
Show answers
  1. B. It answers the prompt (how trees help cities) and previews three points that the passage supports. A is true but does not explain how trees help cities. C announces the topic but gives no central idea. D is a detail from paragraph 6 about helping trees, not how trees help cities.
  2. C. It is about how people help trees, not how trees help cities, so it does not support the central idea. A supports cooling (paragraph 2), B supports flood protection (paragraph 3) and D supports animal homes (paragraph 4).
  3. Sample paraphrase: 'In a big storm, so much rain pours into the drains that they cannot keep up, and the streets can flood' (paragraph 3). Accept any accurate version that keeps the meaning and does not copy the sentence word for word.
  4. Sample: 'This shows that trees give animals safe places to live in a city, where there are many buildings and roads but few natural homes.' Accept any sentence that connects the evidence to how trees help cities, not one that just repeats the evidence.
  5. Sample: 'Another way trees help cities is by protecting them from flooding.' Accept any sentence that includes a transition (for example 'Another way', 'Also', 'In addition', 'Second') and states the flooding point.
  6. Problems: it talks to the reader instead of starting the essay; it announces the topic instead of stating a central idea; 'cool' is vague and is an opinion; it does not answer the prompt. Sample rewrite: 'Trees do more than make a street look nice. City trees help cities by keeping them cooler, protecting them from floods and giving animals a place to live.'
  7. Sample: 'Trees keep cities cooler, slow down floodwater and give animals homes. Every tree planted along a city street helps the whole neighborhood.' Accept any conclusion that restates the central idea in new words and adds no new evidence.
  8. See the complete model essay in Worked example 3. A Strong essay on the classroom guide has: a central idea that answers the prompt; at least two body paragraphs, each with relevant evidence from paragraphs 2–5 put in the writer's own words and explained; transitions; a conclusion; and mostly correct conventions. Students may choose 'trees help people feel calm' (paragraph 5) as a point, but it has less evidence than the other three. An essay that uses paragraph 6 as a main point has drifted off the prompt.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Give a partly completed planning organizer with the central idea and the three points already written.
  • Body paragraph frame: '[Transition] way trees help cities is by ___. The passage says that ___. This shows that ___.'
  • Conclusion frame: 'Trees help cities by ___, ___ and ___. That is why ___.'
  • Let students write two body paragraphs instead of three.

Core task

  • Plan and write a complete essay with an introduction, at least two body paragraphs and a conclusion.

Extension challenge

  • Add a second piece of evidence to each body paragraph and explain how the two pieces work together.
  • Write a hook that uses a vivid detail from the passage instead of a general statement.
  • Write a different central idea for the same prompt (for example, using cooling, flooding and helping people feel calm), and explain which plan has stronger evidence.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Use the classroom scoring guide to sort essays into Strong, Developing and Beginning for ideas and organization, and separately for conventions.
  • Look for the most common gap: evidence that is copied or listed with no explanation. Plan a mini-lesson on elaboration for that group.
  • Check whether students stayed on the prompt or drifted into paragraph 6 or personal opinions.

Exit ticket

  1. Prompt: 'Explain how a community garden helps a neighborhood.' Write a central idea sentence for this essay.
  2. What is the difference between evidence and elaboration?
  3. Name two things a strong conclusion does.
Show exit ticket answers
  1. Sample: 'A community garden helps a neighborhood by giving families fresh food and by bringing neighbors together.' Accept any sentence that answers the prompt and names at least one way it helps.
  2. Evidence is a fact or detail from the passage. Elaboration is the writer's own explanation of how that evidence supports the point.
  3. Any two of: restates the central idea in new words; sums up the main points; ends with a final thought; does not add new evidence.

Common misconceptions

  • An informational essay can include my opinions. It explains a topic using evidence from the passage. Words such as 'I think trees are awesome' do not belong.
  • Every true detail from the passage belongs in the essay. Only use details that answer the prompt. Paragraph 6 is true but is about helping trees.
  • Copying sentences from the passage is using evidence. Evidence should be put in your own words (or briefly quoted) and then explained.
  • The introduction should say 'In this essay I will…'. A strong introduction states the central idea instead of announcing the topic.
  • A conclusion is where you add your best new fact. A conclusion restates and wraps up; new evidence belongs in a body paragraph.

Extension

  • Essay swap: students swap essays and highlight their partner's central idea, evidence and explanation in three colors, then give one 'glow' and one 'grow'.
  • Use the same planning organizer with the next class informational text.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.