Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Grade 5 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources

Making Inferences: Reading Between the Lines

Students learn to combine clues in a text with what they already know to work out things the author doesn't say directly, using the 'It says… I know… So…' frame with an original short story about a rainy Saturday morning.

  • 45 minutes
  • Grade 5
  • English Language Arts
  • Reading comprehension — inference
  • 🇺🇸 United States

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Explain what an inference is and how it differs from information the text states directly.
  • Make inferences by combining clues in the text with background knowledge.
  • Support inferences with evidence using the 'It says… I know… So…' frame.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can find clues in the text that hint at something the author doesn't say.
  • I can link a clue to something I already know.
  • I can write an inference using 'It says… I know… So…'.
  • I can tell the difference between an inference with evidence and a wild guess.

Curriculum focus: Comprehension skills · State standards (Texas TEKS first)

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

More Texas teacher resources (TEKS and STAAR)

Key vocabulary

infer
To work something out using clues and what you already know.
inference
A conclusion you reach by reading between the lines.
clue
A detail in the text that hints at something.
evidence
Words from the text that support your idea.
background knowledge
What you already know from your own life, reading and learning.
literal
Information stated directly in the text.

In the glossary: evidence, inference, reading comprehension

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • The passage 'Saturday Morning' (in the worked examples), displayed and printed one per student
  • A mystery bag with three or four objects (e.g. a towel, goggles, sunscreen bottle)
  • A three-column 'It says… / I know… / So…' chart on the board and on the practice sheet
  • Highlighters
  • The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. Print the passage and practice sheet (one per student).
  2. Pack the mystery bag with everyday objects that point to one activity (e.g. a towel, goggles and a sunscreen bottle → going swimming).
  3. Draw the three-column chart on the board.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: the mystery bag

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Pull objects out one at a time. Ask: 'Where do you think the owner of this bag is going? What makes you think that?'
    • Record a student's reasoning in the chart: It says (I see) goggles, towel, sunscreen. I know people take these swimming. So the owner is going swimming.
    • Say: 'Nobody told you where they were going, but you worked it out from clues. That's called making an inference. Good readers do this all the time.'

    Students

    • Make a prediction and give a reason based on the objects.
  2. 2

    Explicit teaching: modeling the frame

    10 min

    Teacher

    • Read the passage aloud while students follow.
    • Ask a literal question first: 'What did Dad make for breakfast?' (Pancakes.) Say: 'That's written right there. We don't need to infer it.'
    • Then ask: 'What is Priya getting ready for?' Think aloud using Worked example 1, highlighting each clue.
    • Emphasize: 'An inference needs evidence. If I said Priya was going to the moon, could I point to a clue? No, so that's a guess, not an inference.'

    Students

    • Follow the text and highlight clues as the teacher models.
  3. 3

    Guided practice: Mateo's feelings

    10 min

    Teacher

    • Ask: 'How does Mateo feel, and why?' Have pairs find clues and fill in the chart together.
    • Circulate with prompts: 'Point to the words that tell you. What do you know about people who sit with their chin in their hands?'
    • Share responses and build the class answer (Worked example 2).
    • Ask a harder question: 'Why does Dad frown at the sky?' Accept different well-supported answers (he is worried the game will be canceled, or that Priya will get cold and wet).

    Students

    • In pairs, find clues and complete one row of the chart.
    • Share and justify their inference.
  4. 4

    Independent practice

    13 min

    Teacher

    • Hand out the practice sheet. Students answer the questions using the passage, writing 'It says… I know… So…' for the inference questions.
    • Work with the additional support group, reading the passage together and focusing on one clue at a time.

    Students

    • Complete the practice sheet, using evidence for each inference.
  5. 5

    Reflect and exit ticket

    7 min

    Teacher

    • Ask: 'What's the difference between an inference and a guess?' Take answers. (An inference is backed up by evidence from the text.)
    • Read the short exit ticket text aloud and have students complete it individually. Sort into secure / nearly / not yet.

    Students

    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Modeled inference: What is Priya getting ready for?

Saturday Morning. Priya pulled the blanket over her head when the alarm buzzed. Outside, rain drummed on the roof. From the kitchen came the clatter of pans and the sweet smell of something cooking. Then she remembered what day it was. She threw off the blanket, pulled on her shorts and the shirt with the big number 7 on the back, and grabbed her boots from under the bed. Dried mud from last week was still stuck between the studs. In the kitchen, Dad slid a plate of pancakes towards her. 'Eat up,' he said. 'You'll need the energy.' He glanced out the window at the gray sky and frowned. Priya's little brother, Mateo, sat at the table with his chin in his hands. His swimming bag sat by the back door, still zipped. 'The pool's shut,' he muttered. 'It's always shut when there's a storm.' Priya ate quickly, looking at the clock every few seconds. At quarter past eight, a car horn tooted twice outside. She shoved the last piece of pancake into her mouth, kissed Dad on the cheek and raced out the door, her ponytail bouncing. Mateo sighed and reached for the TV remote.

  1. It says: she put on shorts and 'the shirt with the big number 7 on the back'. I know: team sports players wear numbered shirts.
  2. It says: her boots had 'mud … stuck between the studs'. I know: boots with studs are worn for sports played on grass, like football, soccer, rugby or hockey.
  3. It says: Dad told her 'You'll need the energy'. I know: people need energy for running around in a game.
  4. It says: a car horn tooted at quarter past eight and she raced out. I know: a horn tooting often means someone has come to pick you up.
  5. So: put the clues together. One clue alone could mean many things; several clues pointing the same way make a strong inference.

It says Priya put on a shirt with a number on the back and boots with muddy studs, and Dad said she would need energy. I know players in team sports wear numbered shirts and boots with studs. So I think Priya is going to play a team sport (such as football) on a grass field, and someone has come to pick her up.

Modeled inference: How does Mateo feel, and why?

Use the clues about Mateo in 'Saturday Morning' to infer how he feels and why.

  1. It says: Mateo 'sat at the table with his chin in his hands'. I know: people often sit like that when they are bored or fed up.
  2. It says: 'His swimming bag sat by the back door, still zipped' and 'The pool's shut… when there's a storm.' I know: pools close in storms for safety, and an unpacked bag means he didn't get to go.
  3. It says: 'Mateo sighed and reached for the TV remote.' I know: people sigh when they are disappointed.
  4. So: combine the feeling clues with the reason clues.

It says Mateo sat with his chin in his hands, sighed and that the pool was shut because of the storm. I know people do these things when they are disappointed. So Mateo feels disappointed and bored because his swimming has been canceled while his sister still gets to go out.

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Making Inferences Practice

Use 'Saturday Morning' to answer. For questions 4–8, use 'It says… I know… So…'.

  1. 1Literal: What was the weather like?
  2. 2Literal: What time did the car horn toot?
  3. 3Is this literal or an inference: 'Priya is excited.'? Explain.
  4. 4How does Priya feel when she remembers what day it is? Give evidence.
  5. 5Why does Priya keep looking at the clock?
  6. 6Has Priya played this sport before? How do you know?
  7. 7Why might Dad frown at the sky?
  8. 8Jayden says, 'Priya is going to a birthday party.' Is this a good inference? Explain using evidence.
Show answers
  1. It was raining (rain drummed on the roof) and the sky was gray.
  2. Quarter past eight.
  3. An inference — the text never says she is excited; we work it out from clues like throwing off the blanket and racing out.
  4. It says she threw off the blanket and grabbed her boots. I know people move quickly like that when they are excited. So she feels excited and keen to go.
  5. It says she ate quickly and looked at the clock every few seconds, then a car horn tooted. I know people watch the clock when they are waiting for someone or don't want to be late. So she is waiting to be picked up and doesn't want to miss her lift.
  6. It says there was dried mud from last week on her boots. I know mud gets on boots when you play on a grass field. So she played last week too — she has played before (probably every week).
  7. It says he looked at the gray sky and frowned. I know people frown when they are worried, and rain can cause games to be canceled or make players cold and wet. So he is worried about the weather affecting Priya's game. (Accept other answers supported by evidence.)
  8. No — there are no clues about a party (no present or party clothes), and the clues (numbered shirt, studded boots, 'You'll need the energy') point to a sport. An inference must be supported by evidence.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Read the passage with the group and focus on one character at a time.
  • Give a partly completed chart with the 'It says' column filled in, so students complete 'I know' and 'So'.
  • Use picture inference first (a photo or drawing of a scene) before the written text.

Core task

  • Complete the practice sheet using the full 'It says… I know… So…' frame for each inference question.

Extension challenge

  • Write a short paragraph about a character, giving clues to their feelings without naming the feeling, then swap with a partner to infer it.
  • Find a clue in the passage that could support two different inferences and explain both.
  • Infer what might happen after the story ends and support the prediction with evidence.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Listen during guided practice: are students pointing to specific words in the text?
  • Check practice questions 4–8 for all three parts of the frame, not just an answer.
  • Sort exit tickets into secure / nearly / not yet.

Exit ticket

  1. Read: 'Tama stood at the edge of the stage, holding his notes so tightly that the paper crinkled. He swallowed hard and wiped his hands on his trousers.' How does Tama feel? Use 'It says… I know… So…'.
  2. What two things do you combine to make an inference?
Show exit ticket answers
  1. It says he held his notes tightly, swallowed hard and wiped his hands. I know people do these things when their hands are sweaty and they are anxious. So Tama feels nervous about speaking or performing on stage.
  2. Clues (evidence) from the text and your own background knowledge.

Common misconceptions

  • Any answer is fine because it's 'my opinion'. Inferences must be backed by evidence from the text. Ask: 'Which words made you think that?'
  • Copying a sentence is an inference. Repeating what the text says is literal recall. An inference adds something the text doesn't say directly.
  • One clue is enough. One clue can point many ways (studs could mean many sports). Encourage students to look for several clues pointing the same way.
  • Background knowledge replaces the text. Students sometimes tell their own story instead of using the text. Keep returning to 'It says…' first.

Extension

  • Inference role-play: students act out a feeling with clues (posture, actions) and the class infers the feeling with evidence.
  • Apply the frame to the class's current novel during shared reading.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.