Grade 5 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources
5th Grade STAAR Revising and Editing Review: Sentence Combining, Transitions, Capital Letters, Punctuation and Subject-Verb Agreement
A STAAR-style revising and editing review: students learn a routine for multiple-choice questions about a student draft, then practice combining sentences, choosing transitions, deleting and adding sentences, and fixing capital letters, commas, apostrophes, run-ons and subject-verb agreement in an original draft. Every answer includes why each wrong choice is wrong.
- 60 minutes
- Grade 5
- English Language Arts
- Revising and editing a draft
- 🇺🇸 United States
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Use a step-by-step routine to answer revising and editing questions about a student draft.
- Revise a draft by combining sentences, choosing transitions, and adding or deleting sentences for clarity and focus.
- Edit a draft for capital letters, commas, apostrophes, run-on sentences and subject-verb agreement, and explain why each wrong choice is wrong.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can tell the difference between a revising question (ideas and sentences) and an editing question (conventions).
- I can combine two short sentences into one clear sentence without changing the meaning.
- I can find the subject of a sentence, even when a phrase comes between the subject and the verb.
- I can recognize when 'No change is needed' is the right answer.
- I can explain why each wrong answer choice is wrong.
Curriculum focus: Writing — Composition: Revising and Editing · State standards (Texas TEKS first)
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
This is a review lesson written in the style of STAAR reading language arts questions. The passages, drafts and questions are original and are not official STAAR material, and the scoring guides are classroom guides, not the official STAAR rubrics. Released STAAR tests and scoring information are published by the Texas Education Agency.
Key vocabulary
- revising
- Improving the ideas, sentences and organization of a draft: combining, adding, deleting or moving sentences, and choosing better transitions.
- editing
- Fixing the conventions of a draft: capital letters, punctuation, grammar and spelling.
- subject-verb agreement
- A singular subject takes a singular verb (the dog barks); a plural subject takes a plural verb (the dogs bark).
- comma splice
- Two complete sentences joined with only a comma. Fix it with a comma and a joining word (and, but, so), or with a period.
- transition
- A word or phrase that shows how ideas connect, such as time order (First, Within a few days), example (For example) or contrast (However).
- proper noun
- The name of a particular person, place, day, month or thing. It begins with a capital letter.
In the glossary: apostrophe, comma, comma splice, editing, proper noun, revising, run-on sentence, subject-verb agreement
Materials & preparation
You will need
- The teaching draft and Liam's draft (in the Preparation notes), printed with numbered sentences — one copy per student
- An anchor chart: 'Revising = ideas and sentences. Editing = conventions.' with the five-step routine
- Mini whiteboards and markers
- The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)
Before the lesson
- Print the teaching draft — 'The Class Garden' by Aroha: (1) Our class planted a garden behind the gym. (2) We grew carrots. (3) We grew lettuce. (4) Every Friday, two students waters the plants. (5) The carrots took a long time to grow, but they were worth the wait.
- Print Liam's draft — 'A Library on a Post': Paragraph 1: (1) Last spring, my neighbor Mrs. Okafor had an idea for our street. (2) She wanted to build a tiny library where anyone could borrow a book for free. (3) The library would be a wooden box on a post. (4) It would have a glass door to keep the books dry. (5) People could take a book, or they could leave one for someone else. Paragraph 2: (6) On saturday, April 12, my dad and I helped her build it. (7) First, we measured and cut the boards. (8) We painted the box bright blue, and Mrs. Okafor added yellow stars. (9) My dad dug a hole for the post, I held the post straight while he filled the hole with gravel. (10) The paint on the sides of the box were still wet when we finished. Paragraph 3: (11) At first, nobody used the little library. (12) Mrs. Okafor and I made a sign and hung it on the post. (13) We also told our friends at school about it. (14) Books started to appear on the shelves. (15) My favorite book is about sharks. (16) Neighbors left everything from picture books to cookbooks. (17) Now the librarys shelves are full almost every day. (18) I am glad I helped build something that the whole street can share.
- Teacher key to the errors planted in Liam's draft (do not print for students): sentences 3 and 4 are choppy; sentence 6 needs a capital letter; sentence 9 is a comma splice; sentence 10 has a subject-verb agreement error; sentence 14 needs a transition; sentence 15 does not belong; sentence 17 needs an apostrophe; a sentence is missing after sentence 11. Sentences 5 and 8 are correct.
- Write the five-step routine on the anchor chart: (1) Read the whole draft once for meaning. (2) Read the question and the numbered sentence, plus the sentences before and after it. (3) Decide: is this revising or editing? (4) Say what is wrong BEFORE you look at the choices. (5) Read each choice back into the draft; the best choice is correct, clear and keeps the writer's meaning. 'No change is needed' is sometimes right.
Lesson sequence
- 1
Hook: error detectives
5 minTeacher
- Write: 'On monday the twins was late for school because their bus broke down.'
- Say: 'There are two errors. Find them in thirty seconds.' (monday → Monday; was → were.)
- Say: 'On the STAAR reading language arts test, you will read drafts written by students and answer questions about how to improve them. Some questions ask you to REVISE, which means improve the ideas and sentences. Some ask you to EDIT, which means fix capital letters, punctuation and grammar. Today you will learn a routine for both.'
Students
- Find the two errors on whiteboards and name the rule for each.
- 2
Explicit teaching: the routine and five skills
15 minTeacher
- Introduce the anchor chart and read the teaching draft aloud.
- Sentence combining. Model Worked example 1 (sentences 2 and 3). Say: 'A good combination keeps every idea, removes repeated words and is still correct. If two ideas share the same subject and verb, I can often join the other words with "and".'
- Subject-verb agreement. Model Worked example 2 (sentence 4). Say: 'I ask: who is doing the action? Two students. That is plural, so the verb is "water", not "waters". Watch out: when a phrase such as "on the sides of the box" comes between the subject and verb, cross it out in your head and find the real subject.'
- Capital letters. Say: 'Days, months, holidays and people's names are proper nouns: capital letters. Words such as "my dad" stay lowercase because "dad" is not used as a name.'
- Commas and run-ons. Point to sentence 5: 'The carrots took a long time to grow, but they were worth the wait.' Say: 'Two complete sentences joined by a comma AND a joining word such as and, but or so: correct. Two complete sentences joined by a comma alone: that is a comma splice.'
- Transitions and focus. Say: 'Transitions show how ideas connect: time (First, Within a few days), example (For example), contrast (However). And every sentence must stay on topic. If a sentence is about something else, the best revision is often to delete it.'
Students
- Label each teaching draft sentence 'needs revising', 'needs editing' or 'correct'.
- Try each skill on whiteboards as it is modeled.
- 3
Guided practice: questions 1–4
12 minTeacher
- Students read Liam's whole draft once for meaning.
- Pairs answer practice questions 1–4 on whiteboards. Before revealing each answer, ask: 'Revising or editing? What is wrong BEFORE you look at the choices?'
- For each question, ask a pair to explain why each wrong choice is wrong. Name the distractor types: 'fixes something that was not broken', 'creates a new error', 'changes the meaning', 'still has the same error'.
Students
- Answer questions 1–4 with a partner and explain every eliminated choice.
- 4
Independent practice: questions 5–9
20 minTeacher
- Students answer questions 5–9 on their own, writing a short reason next to each answer.
- Remind them: 'Read your chosen answer back into the draft. Does it sound right AND follow the rule?'
- Work with the support group: read each numbered sentence aloud together and decide 'revising or editing' before they look at the choices.
Students
- Answer questions 5–9 and write a reason for each answer.
- 5
Review and exit ticket
8 minTeacher
- Go over question 9 together. Say: 'Sentence 8 is already correct. When every change would make a sentence worse, "No change is needed" is the right answer.'
- Students complete the exit ticket on their own.
Students
- Complete the exit ticket.
Worked examples
Combining sentences
Teaching draft: What is the most effective way to combine sentences 2 and 3? (2) We grew carrots. (3) We grew lettuce. A We grew carrots, we grew lettuce. B We grew carrots and lettuce. C We grew carrots, and lettuce. D Carrots we grew, and also lettuce we grew.
- This is a revising question: it asks how to improve sentences.
- Notice the repeated words: 'We grew'. Keep them once and join the two things that were grown with 'and'.
- Test A: two complete sentences joined by only a comma, which is a comma splice.
- Test C: no comma is needed between just two things joined by 'and'.
- Test D: it keeps the meaning but is wordy and awkward.
B. 'We grew carrots and lettuce.' It keeps both ideas, removes the repeated words and is correct.
Subject-verb agreement
Teaching draft: What change should be made in sentence 4? (4) Every Friday, two students waters the plants. A Change Friday to friday. B Change students to student's. C Change waters to water. D No change is needed.
- This is an editing question.
- Find the subject: who waters? 'two students', which is plural.
- A plural subject needs a plural verb: 'two students water'.
- Test A: Friday is the name of a day, so it must keep its capital letter.
- Test B: an apostrophe shows ownership; the students do not own anything here.
- Test D: there is an agreement error, so a change is needed.
C. 'Every Friday, two students water the plants.'
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Revising and Editing Review: 'A Library on a Post'
Read Liam's draft, then answer each question. Choose the best answer and write why each wrong choice is wrong.
- 1What is the most effective way to combine sentences 3 and 4? A The library would be a wooden box on a post, it would have a glass door to keep the books dry. B The library would be a wooden box on a post with a glass door to keep the books dry. C The library would be a wooden box, on a post, and with a glass door, to keep the books dry. D The library would be a wooden box on a post and it would be a glass door to keep the books dry.
- 2What change should be made in sentence 6? A Change saturday to Saturday. B Change April to april. C Delete the comma after 12. D Change dad to Dad.
- 3What is the correct way to write sentence 9? A My dad dug a hole for the post I held the post straight while he filled the hole with gravel. B My dad dug a hole for the post, and I held the post straight while he filled the hole with gravel. C My dad dug a hole for the post. While he filled the hole with gravel. I held the post straight. D My dad dug a hole, for the post, I held the post straight while he filled the hole with gravel.
- 4What change should be made in sentence 10? A Change sides to side. B Change were to was. C Change were to are. D No change is needed.
- 5Which transition should be added to the beginning of sentence 14? A For example, B Within a few days, C On the other hand, D In conclusion,
- 6Which sentence should be deleted because it does not belong in the draft? A sentence 12 B sentence 13 C sentence 15 D sentence 16
- 7What change should be made in sentence 17? A Change librarys to library's. B Change librarys to libraries. C Change shelves to shelve's. D No change is needed.
- 8Liam wants to add a sentence after sentence 11 to explain why nobody used the library at first. Which sentence best does this? A Most people on our street did not know it was there. B The box was painted bright blue. C Libraries have been around for a very long time. D Mrs. Okafor has a dog named Pepper.
- 9What change, if any, should be made in sentence 8? A Delete the comma after blue. B Change added to adds. C Change Mrs. Okafor to mrs. okafor. D No change is needed.
Show answersHide answers
- B. It joins the ideas smoothly, keeps the meaning and is correct. A joins two complete sentences with only a comma (a comma splice). C adds commas that are not needed and makes the sentence choppy. D changes the meaning: it now says the box would BE a glass door.
- A. Days of the week are proper nouns and need a capital letter. B is wrong because months are also proper nouns and must keep their capital letter. C is wrong because a comma is needed after the date 'April 12' to separate it from the rest of the sentence. D is wrong because 'dad' follows 'my', so it is not used as a name and stays lowercase.
- B. A comma plus 'and' correctly joins two complete sentences. A is a run-on: two sentences with no punctuation or joining word. C creates a fragment: 'While he filled the hole with gravel.' cannot stand alone. D adds an unnecessary comma after 'hole' and is still a comma splice.
- B. The subject is 'paint' (singular); 'on the sides of the box' is a phrase between the subject and the verb. 'The paint … was still wet.' A does not fix the error, because the verb must agree with 'paint', not 'sides'. C is still a plural verb, and it also changes the tense from past to present. D is wrong because there is an agreement error.
- B. It shows time passing after Liam and Mrs. Okafor made the sign and told friends, which explains how the library started being used: 'Within a few days, books started to appear on the shelves.' A is wrong because sentence 14 is not an example of sentence 13. C signals a contrast, but books appearing is the result the writers hoped for, not an opposite idea. D is wrong because sentence 14 is not the end of the draft.
- C. Liam's favorite book has nothing to do with building and filling the street library. A and B explain what Liam and Mrs. Okafor did to get people using the library. D tells what kinds of books neighbors left, which supports the paragraph.
- A. The shelves belong to the library, so the singular possessive needs an apostrophe: 'the library's shelves'. B is a plural with no apostrophe, so it does not show ownership, and there is only one library. C is not a word: 'shelves' is a plural and does not own anything. D is wrong because the apostrophe is missing.
- A. It explains the problem in sentence 11, and it connects to sentences 12 and 13, where Liam and Mrs. Okafor make a sign and tell friends so people find out about it. B repeats a detail from paragraph 2 and does not explain why the library was not used. C is off-topic general information. D is unrelated to the library.
- D. Sentence 8 is correct: two complete sentences are joined by a comma and 'and'. A would remove a needed comma before 'and' in a compound sentence. B would shift the tense from past to present, while the rest of the draft is in the past tense. C would remove capital letters from a person's title and name.
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Before each question, tell students whether it is a revising or an editing question.
- Give a subject-verb agreement strip: cover the words between the subject and the verb with a finger, then read 'The paint … were/was still wet.'
- Reduce to questions 1, 2, 4, 6 and 9 first, then add the rest.
Core task
- Answer all nine questions and write why each wrong choice is wrong.
Extension challenge
- Write your own revising question about sentences 1 and 2, with one correct answer and three believable wrong answers.
- Rewrite paragraph 3 of Liam's draft with every error fixed and the new sentence added after sentence 11.
- Find one sentence in the draft that could be combined with another, other than sentences 3 and 4, and write the combined sentence.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Check whether students can explain why distractors are wrong, not just choose the right letter.
- Note which skill causes the most errors (often subject-verb agreement with a phrase in between, or choosing 'No change' when it is correct) and reteach it.
- Use the exit ticket to check that students can apply the skills to new sentences.
Exit ticket
- Fix the error: 'The dogs in the park chases the ball.'
- Combine into one clear sentence: 'Kai has a bike. It is red.'
- Fix the sentence: 'we visited the museum on tuesday, it was full of dinosaur bones.'
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- 'The dogs in the park chase the ball.' The subject is 'dogs' (plural), so the verb is 'chase'.
- 'Kai has a red bike.'
- 'We visited the museum on Tuesday, and it was full of dinosaur bones.' (Use capital letters for 'We' and 'Tuesday', and fix the comma splice with ', and' or by making two sentences: '…on Tuesday. It was full of dinosaur bones.')
Common misconceptions
- The verb agrees with the nearest noun. It agrees with the subject. In 'The paint on the sides of the box was wet', the subject is 'paint'.
- A comma is a good place to join two sentences. A comma alone creates a comma splice; it needs a joining word such as 'and', 'but' or 'so'.
- Every sentence in a question has an error. 'No change is needed' is sometimes the correct answer.
- Longer combined sentences are always better. The best combination is clear, correct and keeps the meaning, not the longest.
- Words such as 'dad' or 'mom' always need capitals. Only when they are used as a name ('Thanks, Dad'), not after 'my'.
Extension
- Draft doctor: students swap a short piece of their own writing with a partner, mark one revising and one editing suggestion, and explain each.
- Make a class 'sneaky subjects' wall of sentences where a phrase comes between the subject and the verb.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
Interactive games
More lesson plans
Digraphs sh, ch and th: Hearing, Reading and Writing Words Like ship, chop and thin
A teacher-led phonics lesson for beginning readers: two letters, one sound. Students hear sh, ch and th at the start and end of words, learn an action for each sound, read and build short words such as ship, chop, thin and fish, sort words by digraph and write words from dictation. All practice is show-and-say, so it works before students can read independently.
High-Frequency Words: Sounding Out the Regular Parts and Learning the Tricky Parts by Heart
Students learn common high-frequency words, such as the and said, with a heart word routine: say the word, tap its sounds, match each sound to its letters and mark the tricky part with a heart. Regular words are sounded out, never guessed. Quick, active games build fast, accurate reading and spelling of the words.
Phonological Awareness: Hearing Rhyme and Clapping Syllables
A playful listening lesson for beginning readers. Students learn that rhyming words sound the same at the end (cat, hat), judge whether word pairs rhyme, make their own rhymes, then clap, stamp and use the chin-drop trick to count the syllables in names and everyday words. No reading or writing needed.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.