Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Grade 7 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources

7th Grade STAAR Extended Constructed Response Review: Argumentative Essay Using Evidence from Paired Texts

A STAAR-style argumentative extended constructed response review: students read two original paired texts that take opposite sides on required community service, write an arguable claim, choose and explain evidence from both texts, address a counterclaim with a rebuttal and organize a full essay. Includes an annotated model essay, a classroom scoring guide and a full answer key.

  • 60 minutes
  • Grade 7
  • English Language Arts
  • Extended constructed response: argumentative essay with paired texts
  • 🇺🇸 United States

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Write a clear, arguable claim that answers an argumentative prompt.
  • Select relevant evidence from two paired texts and explain how it supports the claim.
  • Acknowledge a counterclaim and respond with a rebuttal supported by evidence, and organize a complete argumentative essay with transitions.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can identify each author's claim, reasons and evidence.
  • I can write a claim that takes one clear side and previews my reasons.
  • I can use evidence from BOTH texts and explain how each piece supports my claim.
  • I can include a counterclaim and a rebuttal.
  • I can use numbers and facts from the texts accurately, without changing what they say.

Curriculum focus: Writing — Composition: Argumentative Text · State standards (Texas TEKS first)

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

This is a review lesson written in the style of STAAR reading language arts questions. The passages, drafts and questions are original and are not official STAAR material, and the scoring guides are classroom guides, not the official STAAR rubrics. Released STAAR tests and scoring information are published by the Texas Education Agency.

More Texas teacher resources (TEKS and STAAR)

Key vocabulary

claim
The position the writer argues for; it answers the prompt and can be disagreed with.
reason
A statement that explains why the claim should be accepted.
evidence
Facts, numbers, examples or expert statements from the texts that support a reason.
elaboration
The writer's explanation of how the evidence supports the reason and the claim.
counterclaim
An opposing position that the writer acknowledges.
rebuttal
The writer's response that shows why the counterclaim is weaker or can be answered.
paired texts
Two texts on the same topic that are read and used together.

In the glossary: evidence, rebuttal

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • Text 1 and Text 2 (in the Preparation notes), printed side by side with numbered paragraphs — one copy per student
  • The essay prompt, printed at the top of lined paper
  • A two-column evidence organizer: 'Supports requiring service / Supports encouraging service', with a column for the text and paragraph number
  • Highlighters in two colors
  • The classroom scoring guide (in the Preparation notes)

Before the lesson

  1. Print Text 1 — 'Service Belongs in Every Student's Schedule' by Jayden (opinion column, Lakeview Middle School newspaper): (1) Last October, forty members of our science club spent two Saturday mornings cleaning up Cedar Creek Park. We filled sixty-two bags with litter, cleared a blocked walking trail and planted a row of shrubs along the creek. When we finished, a man walking his dog stopped to thank us. That moment convinced me: Lakeview Middle School should require every student to complete ten hours of community service each school year. (2) First, service teaches skills that are hard to learn in a classroom. To run the clean-up, club members had to plan a schedule, contact the city parks department, organize supplies and lead groups of volunteers. Ms. Haddad, our science club sponsor, said the students who led groups 'grew more confident in two Saturdays than in a whole semester of class presentations.' (3) Second, service makes our community stronger. The parks department told us that its crew is too small to clean every trail each month. With about 600 students at Lakeview, ten hours each would add up to 6,000 hours of service every year. (4) Finally, service helps students discover what they care about. My friend Priya volunteered at an animal shelter last summer just to earn a badge. She ended up staying all summer, and now she says she wants to become a veterinarian. (5) Some students say they are too busy for a requirement. But ten hours spread across a whole school year is less than half an hour a week. Many projects could also happen during the school day or club time, so students would not have to give up their weekends. (6) A requirement would make sure that every student, not just the ones who already volunteer, gets the chance to help. Ten hours is a small price for a stronger school and a stronger community.
  2. Print Text 2 — 'Encourage Service, Don't Require It' by Sofia (letter to the editor): (1) I agree with Jayden that community service matters. I have helped at our neighborhood's free book swap for two years, and I love it. But Lakeview should encourage service, not require it. (2) A requirement would be unfair to students who have little free time outside school. In a student council survey of 150 Lakeview students, 41 said they look after younger brothers or sisters after school, and 33 said they ride the bus for more than forty minutes each way. For these students, finding ten hours, plus a way to get to a volunteer site, could be a real struggle. A school rule should not punish students for things they cannot control. (3) Required service can also miss the point. When helping becomes one more assignment, some students may choose the quickest task they can find just to finish their hours. Volunteering means the most when people choose to do it. (4) The best evidence that encouragement works is Jayden's own story. The forty students who cleaned up Cedar Creek Park were not required to be there. They came because the science club made the project exciting and easy to join. (5) Instead of a requirement, Lakeview could hold a service fair each fall, where local groups explain how students can help. The school could also run some projects during the school day so that every student, including students with busy afternoons, could take part, and it could recognize volunteers at assemblies. (6) Service should be something students are proud to choose, not a box they have to check.
  3. Print the prompt: 'Should Lakeview Middle School require students to complete community service? Write an argumentative essay that states your position on this question. Use evidence from both texts to support your claim. Remember to: state a clear claim; organize your writing; develop your ideas with evidence and explanation; use correct spelling, capital letters, punctuation and grammar.'
  4. Copy the classroom scoring guide onto chart paper (label it 'Our classroom guide — not the official STAAR rubric'). Ideas and organization — Strong: a clear claim that answers the prompt and is kept throughout; relevant evidence from BOTH texts, used accurately and explained; a counterclaim with a rebuttal; a logical structure with an introduction, body paragraphs, transitions and a conclusion. Developing: a claim that is unclear or shifts; evidence from only one text, or evidence that is listed with little explanation; a weak or missing counterclaim; some organization. Beginning: no clear claim; little relevant evidence; mostly summary of the texts. Conventions — Strong: varied, complete sentences and mostly correct capital letters, punctuation, spelling and grammar. Developing: errors that do not block meaning. Beginning: errors that make the essay hard to follow.

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: claim or not a claim?

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Show three sentences: (a) 'Community service is when people help their community.' (b) 'Many people have opinions about community service.' (c) 'Lakeview should encourage community service instead of requiring it, because a requirement would be unfair to busy students.'
    • Ask: 'Which one could someone disagree with?' Agree that only (c) is a claim: (a) is a definition and (b) is a fact about opinions.
    • Say: 'On the STAAR reading language arts test, an extended constructed response can ask you to argue a position using evidence from the texts you have read. A strong essay needs a claim, evidence from the texts, explanation and a response to the other side. Today you will build one.'

    Students

    • Decide which sentence is a claim and explain why the other two are not.
  2. 2

    Read and map both texts

    15 min

    Teacher

    • Read Text 1 aloud. Students highlight Jayden's claim and number his reasons (skills, community, discovering interests).
    • Ask: 'Where does Jayden respond to the other side?' (Paragraph 5: the 'too busy' counterargument and his rebuttal.)
    • Read Text 2. Students highlight Sofia's claim and number her reasons (fairness, meaning, encouragement already works).
    • Think aloud about a powerful move in Text 2: 'Sofia uses Jayden's own clean-up story as evidence for HER side (paragraph 4). Good arguers look for evidence in the other text, too.'
    • Students sort the evidence into the two-column organizer with text and paragraph numbers.
    • Accuracy check: 'Sofia's survey says 41 students look after siblings and 33 ride the bus a long way. Can we say 74 students are too busy?' Agree: no. Some students may be in both groups, and the survey did not ask whether students were too busy. Use numbers exactly as the text gives them.

    Students

    • Highlight each claim and number each reason.
    • Sort the evidence from both texts into the organizer.
  3. 3

    Plan: choose a side, write a claim

    10 min

    Teacher

    • Say: 'Choose the side you can support best with the texts, not only the side you like. Either side can earn a strong score if it is well argued.'
    • Model a claim for each side: 'Lakeview should encourage community service but not require it, because a requirement would be unfair to busy students and because students already volunteer when projects are well planned.' / 'Lakeview should require ten hours of community service each year, because service builds important skills and strengthens the community.'
    • Students write their claim and plan two reasons, each with evidence from the organizer, and one counterclaim to answer. Check: 'Does your plan use BOTH texts?'

    Students

    • Write a claim that previews two reasons.
    • Plan two body paragraphs and a counterclaim paragraph.
  4. 4

    Model: body paragraph and counterclaim

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Write the body paragraph recipe: Reason (topic sentence) → Evidence (with the text named: 'In Text 2, Sofia reports…') → Elaboration (two sentences: what the evidence shows, and why it matters to the claim).
    • Model the second body paragraph of the model essay (Worked example 2), thinking aloud about why the Cedar Creek evidence is persuasive: it comes from the opposing text.
    • Model the counterclaim move: 'Supporters of a requirement argue that… These benefits are real. However…' Say: 'Admit what is true about the other side, then show why your side still wins, with evidence.'

    Students

    • Label the reason, evidence and elaboration in the model paragraph.
  5. 5

    Independent writing

    15 min

    Teacher

    • Students draft their essay: introduction with claim, two body paragraphs, a counterclaim and rebuttal paragraph, and a conclusion.
    • Circulate and ask: 'Which text is this evidence from? Where is your explanation? Where do you answer the other side?'
    • If time is short, students complete the introduction, one body paragraph and the counterclaim paragraph, and finish the essay in the next lesson.

    Students

    • Draft the argumentative essay using evidence from both texts.
  6. 6

    Self-check and exit ticket

    7 min

    Teacher

    • Students check their draft against the Strong column of the classroom guide, highlighting evidence from Text 1 in one color and Text 2 in the other. If only one color appears, they add evidence from the other text.
    • Students complete the exit ticket on their own.

    Students

    • Self-check for evidence from both texts.
    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Writing the introduction and claim

Write an introduction for the prompt 'Should Lakeview Middle School require students to complete community service?'

  1. Open with a sentence that frames the issue fairly: almost everyone agrees service is good; the question is whether to require it.
  2. State the claim: take one side and preview the reasons.
  3. Keep the claim arguable: someone reading Text 1 would disagree with it.

Annotated introduction: [frames the issue] Almost everyone agrees that helping the community is a good thing. The real question is whether Lakeview Middle School should make students do it. [claim + preview of two reasons] Lakeview should encourage community service but not require it, because a requirement would be unfair to busy students and because students already volunteer when projects are well planned.

Writing a body paragraph that uses the opposing text

Write a body paragraph for the reason 'students already volunteer when projects are well planned'.

  1. Reason: start with a transition and the reason.
  2. Evidence: Text 1, paragraph 1 (forty science club members filled sixty-two bags of litter) and Text 2, paragraph 4 (none of them were required to be there).
  3. Elaboration 1: explain what the evidence shows.
  4. Elaboration 2: connect it back to the claim.

Annotated body paragraph: [transition + reason] Second, the evidence shows that students volunteer without being forced. [evidence, Text 1] Jayden describes how forty science club members filled sixty-two bags with litter at Cedar Creek Park. [evidence, Text 2] As Sofia points out, none of those students were required to be there. [elaboration] They came because the project was exciting and well organized. [link to claim] This suggests that Lakeview should put its effort into planning great projects, not into counting hours.

The complete model essay

Read the rest of the model essay and find the counterclaim, the rebuttal and the evidence from each text.

  1. Paragraph 1: the introduction from Worked example 1.
  2. Paragraph 2: 'First, a service requirement would be unfair to students with responsibilities outside school. In Text 2, Sofia reports a student council survey of 150 Lakeview students: 41 look after younger brothers or sisters after school, and 33 ride the bus for more than forty minutes each way. These students are not avoiding service because they do not care; they simply have less free time. A rule that counts against them for something they cannot control would not be fair.'
  3. Paragraph 3: the body paragraph from Worked example 2.
  4. Paragraph 4: 'Supporters of a requirement, like Jayden, argue that service teaches skills such as planning and leadership, and that a rule would make sure every student gets the chance to help. These benefits are real. However, Lakeview can give every student that chance without a rule. As Sofia suggests, the school could run service projects during the school day and hold a service fair each fall. Even Jayden admits that many projects could happen during the school day or club time. That way, students with busy afternoons can take part, and no one is punished for a schedule they cannot change.'
  5. Paragraph 5: 'Community service builds skills and makes Lakeview's neighborhood stronger, but it works best when students choose it. By encouraging service instead of requiring it, Lakeview can get more students involved and keep the experience meaningful.'

Annotations: the claim is stated in paragraph 1 and never changes; each body paragraph has one reason, evidence with the text named, and elaboration; evidence comes from BOTH texts (Text 2 paragraphs 2, 4 and 5; Text 1 paragraphs 1, 2, 5 and 6); the survey numbers are reported exactly, not added together; paragraph 4 states the counterclaim fairly, concedes ('These benefits are real') and rebuts with evidence, including evidence from the opposing text; transitions ('First', 'Second', 'However') guide the reader; the conclusion restates the claim in new words. On the classroom guide this essay is Strong for both development and organization and conventions. An essay arguing FOR a requirement can be just as strong (see practice question 7).

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Argumentative Extended Constructed Response Review

Use Text 1 and Text 2. Name the text and paragraph number for any evidence you use.

  1. 1Which sentence states Jayden's claim? A 'That moment convinced me: Lakeview Middle School should require every student to complete ten hours of community service each school year.' B 'First, service teaches skills that are hard to learn in a classroom.' C 'Some students say they are too busy for a requirement.' D 'We filled sixty-two bags with litter, cleared a blocked walking trail and planted a row of shrubs along the creek.'
  2. 2State Sofia's claim in your own words and name two of her reasons.
  3. 3Which evidence from Text 2 most directly challenges the idea that a requirement is needed to get students involved? A 41 surveyed students look after younger brothers or sisters after school. B The forty students who cleaned up Cedar Creek Park were not required to be there. C Sofia has helped at a free book swap for two years. D Lakeview could hold a service fair each fall.
  4. 4Is Jayden's evidence about Priya (Text 1, paragraph 4) enough on its own to prove that service helps students discover what they care about? Explain.
  5. 5A student writes: '74 of the 150 students surveyed are too busy to volunteer.' What two mistakes has the student made with Sofia's evidence?
  6. 6Write a claim for the essay that takes a clear position and previews two reasons.
  7. 7Write a body paragraph for the 'require' side, using evidence from Text 1 and explaining it.
  8. 8Write a counterclaim and rebuttal for the 'require' side that answers Sofia's fairness argument.
  9. 9Extended constructed response: Should Lakeview Middle School require students to complete community service? Write an argumentative essay that states your position. Use evidence from both texts to support your claim.
Show answers
  1. A. It states the position the whole column argues for (Text 1, paragraph 1). B is the first reason, not the claim. C is the counterargument Jayden answers in paragraph 5. D is part of the opening anecdote, which is evidence, not the claim.
  2. Claim: Lakeview should encourage community service but not make it a requirement (Text 2, paragraph 1). Reasons (any two): a requirement would be unfair to students with little free time (paragraph 2); required service can lose its meaning when it becomes one more assignment (paragraph 3); students already volunteer without a rule, as the Cedar Creek clean-up shows (paragraph 4).
  3. B. It shows students volunteering in large numbers without a rule (Text 2, paragraph 4). A supports Sofia's fairness reason, not whether a rule is needed for involvement. C is one person's experience and shows Sofia values service, not that rules are unnecessary. D is a proposed solution, not evidence that encouragement already works.
  4. It is relevant, because Priya found a career interest through volunteering, but it is not sufficient on its own: it is a single example, it is reported second-hand ('she says'), and Priya was not required to volunteer by a school rule. A survey of many students or several examples would make the reason stronger.
  5. (1) The student added 41 and 33, but some students may both look after siblings AND ride the bus a long way, so the groups may overlap and cannot simply be added. (2) The survey did not say these students are 'too busy to volunteer'; it said they look after siblings or have long bus rides. Accurate version: 'In a survey of 150 students, 41 said they look after younger siblings after school and 33 said they ride the bus for more than forty minutes each way' (Text 2, paragraph 2).
  6. Sample (encourage): 'Lakeview should encourage community service instead of requiring it, because a rule would be unfair to students with busy afternoons and because students already volunteer for well-planned projects.' Sample (require): 'Lakeview should require ten hours of community service each year, because service teaches skills students cannot learn in class and gives thousands of hours of help to the community.' Accept any claim that takes one side, answers the prompt and gives reasons that the texts can support.
  7. Sample: 'First, a service requirement would teach students skills that are hard to learn in a classroom. In Text 1, Jayden explains that to run the Cedar Creek clean-up, students had to plan a schedule, contact the parks department, organize supplies and lead volunteers. Their sponsor, Ms. Haddad, said the student leaders "grew more confident in two Saturdays than in a whole semester of class presentations." If every student had to complete service, every student would practice planning and leadership, not only the students who already join clubs.' Check for: a reason, accurate evidence with the text named, and elaboration that links back to the claim.
  8. Sample: 'Some people, like Sofia, argue that a requirement would be unfair to students who look after siblings or ride the bus for a long time. This is a real concern. However, Jayden points out that many projects could happen during the school day or club time (Text 1, paragraph 5), so those students would not need to find extra time after school. Ten hours across a whole school year is also less than half an hour a week.' Check for: a fair statement of the opposing view, a concession, and a rebuttal supported by evidence.
  9. See the complete model essay in Worked examples 1–3 (encourage side); practice questions 6–8 give the building blocks for the require side. A Strong essay on the classroom guide has: a clear claim kept throughout; at least two reasons with accurate evidence from BOTH texts; elaboration after each piece of evidence; a counterclaim with a rebuttal; an introduction, body paragraphs, transitions and a conclusion; and mostly correct conventions. Either position can be Strong. An essay that only retells the two texts, or uses evidence from only one, is Developing at best.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Give the evidence organizer with the evidence already sorted; students choose which pieces to use.
  • Claim frame: 'Lakeview should ___ because ___ and because ___.'
  • Counterclaim frame: 'Some people argue that ___. This is partly true because ___. However, ___ (Text ___, paragraph ___).'
  • Let students write the introduction, one body paragraph and the counterclaim paragraph.

Core task

  • Plan and write the full essay with evidence from both texts and a counterclaim with a rebuttal.

Extension challenge

  • Write a middle-ground claim (for example, a small requirement that can be met during the school day) and support it with evidence from both texts.
  • Identify the strongest and weakest evidence in each text and explain your judgment.
  • Rewrite your conclusion so it ends with a memorable final thought that does not simply repeat your claim word for word.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Highlight evidence from each text in a different color; essays with only one color need a conference about using both texts.
  • Check that numbers and quotations are used accurately and that the text is named for each piece of evidence.
  • Use the classroom guide to sort essays and plan a follow-up lesson on elaboration or on counterclaims, whichever is weaker.

Exit ticket

  1. Which is a strong claim? A 'Community service is a topic many people discuss.' B 'Lakeview should require community service because it builds skills and strengthens the community.' C 'This essay is about community service.'
  2. Why does a strong argumentative essay include a counterclaim and rebuttal?
  3. Write one sentence of elaboration for this evidence: 'The parks department told us that its crew is too small to clean every trail each month' (Text 1, paragraph 3).
Show exit ticket answers
  1. B. It takes a position someone could disagree with and previews reasons. A is a statement of fact, and C announces the topic.
  2. It shows the writer has considered the other side, makes the writer seem fair and well informed, and answers objections before the reader raises them, which makes the argument more convincing.
  3. Sample: 'This shows that student volunteers can do work the city cannot finish on its own, so service hours would make a real difference to the parks.' Accept any sentence that explains how the evidence supports a claim.

Common misconceptions

  • Summarizing both texts is the same as arguing. An argument takes a side and uses the texts as evidence for it.
  • Evidence must come from the text that agrees with me. Evidence from the opposing text can be very persuasive (Sofia uses Jayden's own story).
  • Mentioning the other side weakens my essay. A fair counterclaim followed by a strong rebuttal makes the essay stronger.
  • Numbers from a text can be combined however I like. Report numbers exactly. Groups in a survey may overlap, so they cannot always be added.
  • Quoting is enough. Every piece of evidence needs elaboration that explains how it supports the claim.

Extension

  • Four corners debate: students stand at 'require', 'encourage', 'middle ground' or 'undecided' and argue using text evidence only.
  • Find a short opinion piece in a classroom magazine and write a rebuttal paragraph using evidence from the piece itself.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.