Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Grade 7 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources

7th Grade Argumentative Text STAAR Reading Review: Claims, Evidence, Counterarguments and Rebuttals

A STAAR-style reading review on argumentative text: students identify the claim, reasons, evidence, counterargument and rebuttal in two original student-written arguments, then judge whether each piece of evidence is relevant and sufficient. Includes multiple-choice items with distractor explanations and a scored short constructed response.

  • 60 minutes
  • Grade 7
  • English Language Arts
  • Argumentative text
  • 🇺🇸 United States

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Identify the claim, reasons, evidence, counterargument and rebuttal in an argumentative text.
  • Evaluate whether evidence is relevant (connected to the reason) and sufficient (enough, and strong enough, to convince).
  • Explain how a counterargument and rebuttal strengthen an argument, and identify the intended audience.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can find the author's claim and restate it in my own words.
  • I can label reasons, evidence, the counterargument and the rebuttal.
  • I can decide whether a piece of evidence is relevant and sufficient, and explain my decision using the text.
  • I can explain why each wrong answer choice is wrong.

Curriculum focus: Reading — Multiple Genres: Argumentative Text · State standards (Texas TEKS first)

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

This is a review lesson written in the style of STAAR reading questions. The passages and questions are original and are not official STAAR material. Released STAAR tests are published by the Texas Education Agency.

More Texas teacher resources (TEKS and STAAR)

Key vocabulary

claim
The author's main position: what the author wants readers to believe or do.
reason
A statement that explains why the claim should be accepted.
evidence
Facts, statistics, examples, expert opinions or experiences that support a reason.
counterargument
An opposing view that the author mentions.
rebuttal
The author's response that shows why the counterargument is weaker or can be solved.
relevant
Directly connected to the reason or claim it is meant to support.
sufficient
Enough evidence, of a strong enough kind, to convince a careful reader.
audience
The people the author is trying to convince.

In the glossary: audience, evidence, persuasive text, rebuttal

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • Passage 1 and Passage 2 (in the Preparation notes), printed with numbered paragraphs — one copy per student
  • Highlighters in five colors (or underline, circle, box, star and wavy line)
  • An 'argument skeleton' anchor chart: Claim → Reasons → Evidence → Counterargument → Rebuttal → Conclusion
  • The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. Print Passage 1 — 'Refill, Don't Landfill' by Tama, student council: (1) Every lunchtime at Westbrook Middle School, the recycling bins by the cafeteria doors overflow with empty plastic water bottles. Our school should install water refill stations in the cafeteria and gym and encourage every student to carry a reusable bottle. (2) The strongest reason is the amount of waste we create. Last spring, the student council counted the plastic bottles thrown away in the cafeteria over five school days. The total was 1,140 bottles, or about 228 a day. Many of these ended up in the trash bins instead of the recycling bins, because the recycling bins were already full. (3) Refill stations would also save families money. A reusable bottle is bought once and can last for years, while bottled water must be bought again and again. (4) Third, refill stations would help students stay healthy. My friend Kai says he drinks much more water when he has his own bottle with him. (5) Our cafeteria also got new tables last year, and students say they are much more comfortable. (6) Some people argue that refill stations cost too much, especially because the school already has drinking fountains. It is true that each station costs money to buy and install. However, the parent association has offered to hold a fundraiser to pay for two stations, and the stations can be used every day for many years. In addition, many students avoid the old fountains because the water pressure is low and it is hard to fill a bottle at them. (7) Small changes in daily habits add up. Installing refill stations is a simple step that would cut waste, save money and make it easier for every student to drink water. Let's refill instead of landfill.
  2. Print Passage 2 — 'Keep the Library Open After School' by Mei, school newspaper: (1) Our school library closes at 3:30, the moment the final bell rings. It should stay open until 5:00 on weekdays so that students have a quiet place to study, read and use computers. (2) Many students have nowhere quiet to work after school. In a survey of 150 students by the school newspaper, 62 said they do not have a quiet space at home to do homework. (3) Some students also need computers and printers for assignments, and the library has twenty computers that sit unused every afternoon. (4) Libraries are also older than most people realize. Some of the first libraries were built thousands of years ago. (5) Critics say the school cannot afford to pay a staff member to stay late. However, the library could use a rotating schedule of teacher volunteers and trained student helpers, the same way the after-school homework club already runs. (6) Opening the library for ninety more minutes a day would give every student a fair chance to succeed.
  3. Draw the argument skeleton anchor chart and add a two-question test underneath: 'RELEVANT? Does it connect to THIS reason? SUFFICIENT? Is there enough, and is it strong (numbers, expert, several examples) or weak (one person's opinion, vague words like "many people say")?'

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: which evidence wins?

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Write the claim: 'Our class should get a class pet.' Read three pieces of evidence: (a) 'My cousin's class has a fish and she loves it.' (b) 'Pizza is my favorite food.' (c) 'A survey of our class found 24 of 27 students would help care for a pet, and the teacher next door has offered a spare fish tank.'
    • Ask: 'Which is irrelevant? Which is relevant but weak? Which is strongest, and why?' Draw out: (b) is irrelevant, (a) is relevant but one person's experience, (c) is relevant and more sufficient.
    • Say: 'Today you become argument judges: not just finding the parts, but deciding how strong they are.'

    Students

    • Rank the three pieces of evidence with a partner and justify the ranking.
  2. 2

    Explicit teaching: the parts of an argument

    15 min

    Teacher

    • Read Passage 1 aloud. Model labeling: the claim is the last sentence of paragraph 1 ('Our school should install water refill stations…'). Point out that paragraph 7 restates it.
    • Label the three reasons (paragraphs 2, 3 and 4) and the evidence for each.
    • Model judging evidence: 'Paragraph 2 has a count over five days, 1,140 bottles. That is relevant and fairly strong. Paragraph 4 has one friend's opinion. It is relevant, but is it sufficient? No: one person is not enough to prove students will be healthier.'
    • Ask: 'What does paragraph 5 have to do with refill stations?' Agree it is irrelevant: comfortable tables do not support the claim.
    • Label the counterargument ('Some people argue…') and the rebuttal ('However…'). Explain: 'Admitting the cost and then answering it makes the writer seem fair and makes the argument harder to reject.'
    • Ask: 'Who is the audience?' (Students, families and school decision-makers at Westbrook.) 'How can you tell?' ('Our school', 'Let's', the mention of the parent association.)

    Students

    • Highlight each part of Passage 1 in a different color and add it to the argument skeleton.
  3. 3

    Guided practice: evaluating evidence

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Pairs complete practice questions 1–4 about Passage 1 on whiteboards.
    • For each multiple-choice item, ask one pair to explain why each wrong choice is wrong. Name the common distractor types: true but not relevant; a reason mistaken for the claim; a detail mistaken for evidence; an opinion presented as strong evidence.
    • Model the constructed response routine with Worked example 2.

    Students

    • Answer questions 1–4 and explain each eliminated choice.
  4. 4

    Independent practice: Passage 2

    20 min

    Teacher

    • Students read Passage 2 and complete the remaining practice questions, including the short constructed response.
    • Conference with a small group using the support task: map Passage 2 onto a blank argument skeleton before answering.

    Students

    • Read Passage 2 and answer the practice questions, citing paragraph numbers.
  5. 5

    Exit ticket

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Go over practice question 6 (the irrelevant evidence) together.
    • Students complete the exit ticket on their own.

    Students

    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Mapping an argument

Passage 1: Identify the claim, the reasons, the counterargument and the rebuttal.

  1. Claim (paragraph 1): the school should install water refill stations and encourage reusable bottles.
  2. Reason 1 (paragraph 2): it would reduce waste. Evidence: 1,140 bottles in five days; bottles going into the trash bins.
  3. Reason 2 (paragraph 3): it would save families money. Evidence: a reusable bottle is bought once.
  4. Reason 3 (paragraph 4): it would help students stay healthy. Evidence: one friend's experience.
  5. Counterargument (paragraph 6): refill stations cost too much and fountains already exist.
  6. Rebuttal (paragraph 6): a fundraiser will pay for two stations; they last for years; the fountains are hard to use.

Claim: install refill stations. Reasons: less waste, savings for families, better health. Counterargument: cost and existing fountains. Rebuttal: fundraiser, long life, poor fountains.

Judging whether evidence is sufficient

Passage 1: Is the evidence in paragraph 4 sufficient to support the reason that refill stations would help students stay healthy? Explain.

  1. Name the reason: refill stations would help students stay healthy.
  2. Name the evidence: 'My friend Kai says he drinks much more water when he has his own bottle with him.'
  3. Relevant? Yes: it connects having a bottle to drinking more water.
  4. Sufficient? No: it is one person's report, it is an opinion rather than a measured fact, and it does not show that refill stations themselves cause the change.
  5. Suggest what would make it stronger: a survey of many students, or a health expert's statement about drinking water.

The evidence is relevant but not sufficient: it is a single friend's opinion, so it cannot show that refill stations would help most students stay healthy. A survey or an expert statement would make the reason stronger.

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Argumentative Text Review

Use Passages 1 and 2. Cite a paragraph number for every answer.

  1. 1Passage 1: Which sentence states the author's claim? A 'The strongest reason is the amount of waste we create.' B 'Our school should install water refill stations in the cafeteria and gym and encourage every student to carry a reusable bottle.' C 'Some people argue that refill stations cost too much.' D 'Small changes in daily habits add up.'
  2. 2Passage 1: Which evidence best supports the reason that refill stations would reduce waste? A Kai drinks more water when he has his own bottle. B The cafeteria got new tables last year. C The student council counted 1,140 plastic bottles thrown away in five days. D The parent association offered to hold a fundraiser.
  3. 3Passage 1: Why does the author include paragraph 6? A to admit that the plan will not work; B to respond to an opposing view and show that the cost problem can be solved; C to give more evidence that bottles create waste; D to explain how drinking fountains work.
  4. 4Passage 1: Which paragraph contains evidence that is NOT relevant to the claim? Explain.
  5. 5Passage 2: What is the author's claim, and who is the intended audience?
  6. 6Passage 2: Which paragraph includes information that does NOT support the author's claim? A paragraph 2; B paragraph 3; C paragraph 4; D paragraph 5.
  7. 7Passage 2: Is the evidence in paragraph 2 relevant and sufficient? Explain your answer.
  8. 8Passage 2: Which sentence is the rebuttal? A 'Critics say the school cannot afford to pay a staff member to stay late.' B 'However, the library could use a rotating schedule of teacher volunteers and trained student helpers…' C 'Our school library closes at 3:30.' D 'Opening the library for ninety more minutes a day would give every student a fair chance to succeed.'
  9. 9Short constructed response: Which passage supports its claim more effectively, Passage 1 or Passage 2? Use evidence from both passages to support your answer.
Show answers
  1. B. It states the position the whole passage argues for (paragraph 1). A introduces a reason, not the claim. C is the counterargument. D is a general statement in the conclusion that supports the claim but does not state it.
  2. C. It is a measured count that shows how much waste the school produces (paragraph 2). A supports the health reason, not waste. B is irrelevant to the claim. D is part of the rebuttal about cost.
  3. B. The author states the counterargument (cost, existing fountains) and then rebuts it with the fundraiser, the long life of the stations and the problems with the fountains. A is wrong: the author admits a cost but still argues the plan will work. C: paragraph 6 is about cost, not waste. D: fountains are mentioned only to answer the objection.
  4. Paragraph 5. Comfortable new tables have nothing to do with whether refill stations would cut waste, save money or improve health.
  5. Claim: the school library should stay open until 5:00 on weekdays (paragraph 1). Audience: the school community, especially decision-makers such as the principal and staff, and the students who read the school newspaper.
  6. C. The age of the first libraries is true, but it does not explain why this library should stay open later. A gives survey evidence that students need a quiet place. B gives evidence that computers are available and needed. D answers the counterargument about cost.
  7. It is relevant, because it shows that students need a quiet place to work, which is the reason for opening the library. It is fairly strong because it is a survey of 150 students with a specific result (62 have no quiet space). It could be more sufficient if it showed that those students would actually use the library after school.
  8. B. It answers the critics' objection with a practical solution (paragraph 5). A is the counterargument, not the response to it. C is background that sets up the problem. D is the concluding restatement of the claim.
  9. Model answer: 'Passage 1 supports its claim more effectively. Its strongest reason has specific evidence, a count of 1,140 bottles in five days (paragraph 2), and it answers the cost objection with a fundraiser and the long life of the stations (paragraph 6). Passage 2 also has a survey (paragraph 2), but it gives fewer reasons and includes an irrelevant fact about ancient libraries (paragraph 4).' (A well-supported argument for Passage 2 also earns full marks, for example: Passage 2's survey of 150 students is stronger than Passage 1's single friend's opinion in paragraph 4, and Passage 1 also contains irrelevant evidence in paragraph 5.) Scoring guide: 2 points: a clear decision about which argument is more effective, supported by relevant evidence from BOTH passages and an explanation of why that evidence is stronger or weaker. 1 point: a decision supported by evidence from only one passage, OR evidence from both with little explanation. 0 points: no decision, a summary only, or evidence not from the passages.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Give a blank argument skeleton with paragraph numbers already placed beside each part.
  • Read the passages aloud and pause after each paragraph to ask: 'Claim, reason, evidence, counterargument or rebuttal?'
  • Provide a sentence frame: 'This evidence is / is not relevant because ___. It is / is not sufficient because ___.'

Core task

  • Complete all practice questions, judging relevance and sufficiency with reasons.

Extension challenge

  • Rewrite paragraph 4 of Passage 1 so the health reason has sufficient evidence, without inventing facts about real groups (for example, describe a survey the student council could run).
  • Write a new counterargument for Passage 2 (for example, about student safety after hours) and a rebuttal the author could use.
  • Write a test-style question about Passage 2 whose distractors include a counterargument, a reason and an irrelevant detail.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Check that students can tell a reason from the claim and a counterargument from a rebuttal.
  • Listen for decisions about sufficiency that mention the type and amount of evidence, not just 'it is good'.
  • Use the constructed response scoring guide to check that students use evidence from both passages.

Exit ticket

  1. Claim: 'Our school should start a walking club at lunchtime.' Evidence: 'Walking is popular in many countries.' Is this evidence relevant and sufficient? Explain.
  2. What is the difference between a counterargument and a rebuttal?
  3. Why might an author include a counterargument in an argumentative text?
Show exit ticket answers
  1. It is weakly relevant at best: it is about walking in general, not about why our school needs a club. It is not sufficient: it gives no specific facts about students at our school. Better evidence would be a survey of students or a teacher willing to supervise.
  2. A counterargument is an opposing view the author mentions. A rebuttal is the author's answer to that view, showing why it is wrong or how the problem can be solved.
  3. To show they have considered other views, to seem fair and well informed, and to answer objections before readers raise them, which makes the argument more convincing.

Common misconceptions

  • Any fact is good evidence. A fact can be true and still be irrelevant, like the age of the first libraries.
  • One example proves a point. A single person's experience is relevant but rarely sufficient.
  • Mentioning the other side weakens an argument. A counterargument followed by a strong rebuttal makes the argument stronger.
  • The claim is always the first sentence. The claim is often the last sentence of the introduction and is usually restated in the conclusion.
  • A reason is the same as evidence. A reason says WHY; evidence PROVES the reason with facts, numbers or examples.

Extension

  • Argument audit: bring in a letter to the editor or advertisement from a classroom magazine and map it onto the argument skeleton.
  • Debate prep: in pairs, take opposite sides of a school issue, write one reason with evidence each, then swap and write a rebuttal.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.