Grade 8 Science lesson plan · More Science resources
Chemical Reactions: Chemical vs Physical Change, Evidence of a Reaction, and Exothermic vs Endothermic
Students distinguish chemical from physical changes, learn the evidence that a new substance has formed (gas, color change, temperature change, precipitate) and classify reactions as exothermic or endothermic. A safe, flame-free practical measures the temperature drop when citric acid reacts with bicarb soda, alongside teacher demonstrations.
- 60 minutes
- Grade 8
- Science
- Chemical reactions
- 🇺🇸 United States
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Overview
Learning objectives
Students will…
- Distinguish a chemical change (a new substance forms) from a physical change (no new substance forms).
- Identify evidence of a chemical reaction: gas produced, color change, temperature change and a precipitate forming.
- Classify reactions as exothermic or endothermic from temperature data, and describe the direction of energy transfer.
- Carry out a practical safely and record and process temperature data.
Success criteria
Students can say…
- I can explain the difference between a chemical and a physical change with an example of each.
- I can list four pieces of evidence that a chemical reaction may have happened.
- I can use temperature data to decide whether a reaction is exothermic or endothermic.
- I can explain which way thermal energy moves in each type of reaction.
- I followed every safety step in the practical.
Curriculum focus: Physical Science — Chemical reactions · State standards (Texas TEKS first)
Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources
In NGSS states this content sits in middle school physical science, often in Grade 7 or 8.
Key vocabulary
- physical change
- A change in shape, size or state where no new substance forms, such as melting, freezing, dissolving or tearing.
- chemical change
- A change in which one or more new substances form. Also called a chemical reaction.
- reactant
- A substance present at the start of a chemical reaction.
- product
- A new substance formed in a chemical reaction.
- precipitate
- An insoluble solid that forms when two solutions are mixed.
- exothermic
- A reaction that releases thermal energy to the surroundings, so the surroundings get warmer.
- endothermic
- A reaction that absorbs thermal energy from the surroundings, so the surroundings get colder.
- word equation
- A way of writing a reaction using the names of substances: reactants → products.
In the glossary: chemical reaction, combustion, corrosion, heat, physical change, product, temperature
Materials & preparation
You will need
- Safety glasses for every student and the teacher; disposable gloves for the teacher demonstrations
- Per group of 3: a plastic cup or small beaker, 50 mL of tap water at room temperature, a spirit (alcohol) or digital thermometer (no mercury thermometers), a plastic spoon or stirring rod, a measuring cylinder
- Per group: 2 level teaspoons of citric acid and 2 level teaspoons of sodium hydrogen carbonate (bicarb soda), each in a labeled cup
- Teacher demo 1: a small plastic bottle, 50 mL white vinegar, 1 teaspoon bicarb soda, a balloon, a funnel
- Teacher demo 2: a pad of plain steel wool (no soap), 100 mL white vinegar in a beaker, a thermometer, a second empty beaker or jar
- Teacher demo 3: two clear plastic cups, a solution of Epsom salts (magnesium sulfate, about 1 teaspoon in 50 mL water) and a solution of washing soda (sodium carbonate, about 1 teaspoon in 50 mL water), each labeled
- Physical change examples: an ice cube on a saucer, a sheet of paper to tear, a teaspoon of table salt and a cup of water
- Paper towel, a sponge and access to a sink
- Results tables (printable)
Before the lesson
- Trial every demonstration and the student practical before the lesson, and complete your school's risk assessment. Read the safety data sheets for citric acid, sodium hydrogen carbonate, sodium carbonate (washing soda) and magnesium sulfate.
- Make up the Epsom salts and washing soda solutions in advance, wearing gloves and safety glasses. Label both cups clearly.
- Portion citric acid and bicarb soda into labeled cups for each group so students do not handle stock containers.
- Put the balloon over the funnel and add 1 teaspoon of bicarb soda to the balloon, ready to stretch over the bottle neck.
- Leave the tap water out for at least an hour so it reaches room temperature.
- Draw the results table on the board: Reaction | Start temperature (°C) | Final temperature (°C) | Change (°C) | Exothermic or endothermic? | Other evidence.
Safety
- No flames or heating equipment in this lesson: no Bunsen burners, candles, matches, hot plates or kettles.
- Safety glasses on for everyone from the first demonstration until clean-up is finished. Citric acid, vinegar and washing soda sting the eyes: if any splashes in an eye, rinse with running water for at least 15 minutes and tell the teacher straight away.
- The teacher handles washing soda, Epsom salts and steel wool, wearing gloves. Steel wool can splinter and cut skin.
- Use spirit (alcohol) or digital thermometers only, never mercury thermometers. Stir with the spoon or rod, not the thermometer. Report breakages to the teacher; do not pick up broken glass.
- Never taste or smell chemicals directly, even food-grade ones. Waft gently towards your nose if asked to smell.
- Use small amounts only, as listed. Do not seal the citric acid and bicarb soda reaction in a closed container: gas pressure can build up.
- Wipe up spills straight away. Rinse solutions down the sink with plenty of water. Put used steel wool in the general waste bin, wrapped in paper towel.
- Wash hands at the end of the practical. Complete your school's risk assessment before the lesson.
Lesson sequence
- 1
Hook: the self-inflating balloon
6 minTeacher
- Put on safety glasses and ask students to put theirs on. Pour 50 mL vinegar into the bottle. Stretch the balloon (containing bicarb soda) over the neck without letting the powder fall in yet.
- Ask: 'What do you predict will happen when I tip the powder in?' Take two or three predictions.
- Lift the balloon so the bicarb soda falls into the vinegar. Students watch the fizzing and the balloon inflating.
- Ask: 'What is filling the balloon? Where did it come from?' Say: 'A gas, carbon dioxide, that wasn't there before. A new substance has formed. That's the sign of a chemical reaction.'
- Ask a student to touch the bottom of the bottle and report: 'Is it warmer, colder or the same?' (Slightly colder.) Say: 'Remember that. We'll come back to it.'
Students
- Predict, observe and describe the evidence they see and feel.
- 2
Explicit teaching: physical vs chemical change
10 minTeacher
- Show the ice cube melting, tear the sheet of paper, and dissolve a teaspoon of salt in water. For each ask: 'Has a new substance formed?' (No: it is still water, still paper, still salt and water; the salt could be recovered by evaporating the water.) Say: 'These are physical changes. The substance changes shape, size or state, but no new substance forms.'
- Say: 'In a chemical change, the particles rearrange to form one or more new substances with different properties.' Write the bicarb soda and vinegar word equation on the board: sodium hydrogen carbonate + acetic acid → sodium acetate + water + carbon dioxide.
- Label the reactants (left of the arrow) and products (right). Say: 'The arrow means "react to form". Carbon dioxide is a new substance: a product.'
- Quick sort on whiteboards: 'Chemical or physical? Toast burning. (Chemical.) Water boiling. (Physical.) Iron rusting. (Chemical.) Sugar dissolving in tea. (Physical.) An egg cooking. (Chemical.) Butter melting. (Physical.)' Discuss any disagreements.
- Say: 'Bubbles in boiling water are water vapor, not a new substance. So bubbles alone don't prove a chemical change. We need to ask: is it a new substance?'
Students
- Observe the physical changes, copy the word equation with labels, and classify examples on whiteboards.
- 3
Evidence of a chemical reaction, and the precipitate demo
8 minTeacher
- Write four headings on the board: Gas produced (bubbles, fizzing, a new smell), Color change, Temperature change, Precipitate forms. Say: 'These are clues that a chemical reaction may have happened. Scientists look for them, then check whether a new substance really formed.'
- Put on gloves. Hold up the two clear solutions. Say: 'Epsom salts solution and washing soda solution. Both are clear and colourless. Watch.' Pour one into the other.
- Ask: 'What do you see?' (It turns cloudy white.) Say: 'That white solid is a precipitate: magnesium carbonate, a new substance that doesn't dissolve in water.' Write: magnesium sulfate + sodium carbonate → magnesium carbonate + sodium sulfate.
- Say: 'One piece of evidence alone isn't proof. Dissolving can change temperature a little, and boiling makes bubbles. The more clues we see together, and the harder the change is to reverse, the stronger our evidence.'
Students
- Record the four types of evidence, and observe and describe the precipitate.
- 4
Explicit teaching: exothermic and endothermic
6 minTeacher
- Say: 'Every chemical reaction involves an energy change. In an exothermic reaction, thermal energy is released to the surroundings, so the surroundings get warmer. Exo means out.'
- Say: 'In an endothermic reaction, thermal energy is absorbed from the surroundings, so the surroundings get colder. Endo means in.'
- Give examples: 'Burning fuel, respiration in our cells and rusting are exothermic. Photosynthesis is endothermic: plants absorb energy from sunlight.'
- Ask: 'The bottle in our balloon demo felt slightly colder. Exothermic or endothermic?' (Endothermic: the reaction absorbed thermal energy from the vinegar and the bottle.)
- Set up teacher demo 2 now so it can run during the practical: wearing gloves, soak the steel wool in vinegar for 1 minute to remove its protective coating, squeeze out the vinegar, wrap it around the thermometer bulb and stand it in the empty beaker. Record the starting temperature on the board.
Students
- Record definitions of exothermic and endothermic in their own words and classify the balloon reaction.
- 5
Practical: citric acid and bicarb soda
18 minTeacher
- Go through the safety steps aloud (see safety) and check every student has safety glasses on.
- Explain the method on the board: 1. Measure 50 mL of room-temperature water into the cup. 2. Add 2 level teaspoons of citric acid and stir until dissolved. 3. Wait 1 minute, then record the temperature: this is the start temperature. 4. Add 2 level teaspoons of bicarb soda and stir gently. 5. Record the lowest temperature reached within 2 minutes. 6. Record other evidence.
- Say: 'Why do we take the start temperature after the citric acid has dissolved?' (Dissolving can change the temperature a little, and we want to measure only the reaction.)
- Circulate and ask each group: 'What evidence of a chemical reaction can you see? What is happening to the temperature? So which way is thermal energy moving?'
- Halfway through, read the steel wool thermometer aloud and record it on the board. Ask: 'What is happening here?' (The temperature is rising slowly: an exothermic reaction, as the iron rusts.)
- Groups clean up: rinse solutions down the sink with plenty of water, rinse cups and thermometers, wipe the bench, wash hands.
Students
- Carry out the practical safely, record start and final temperatures, calculate the change, note other evidence, and clean up.
- 6
Conclusion
7 minTeacher
- Collect each group's temperature change on the board. Expect a drop of several degrees Celsius. Ask: 'Did every group get a temperature drop? Why might the amounts differ?' (Different amounts of powder, starting temperatures, stirring, thermometer reading.)
- Write the word equation together: citric acid + sodium hydrogen carbonate → sodium citrate + water + carbon dioxide.
- Ask: 'What evidence tells us this was a chemical reaction?' (Gas produced, and a temperature change.) 'Exothermic or endothermic?' (Endothermic: the temperature of the solution fell because the reaction absorbed thermal energy from it.)
- Read the final steel wool temperature. Compare: 'Steel wool rusting: temperature rose, exothermic. Citric acid and bicarb: temperature fell, endothermic.'
Students
- Share results, write the conclusion and word equation, and compare the two reactions.
- 7
Exit ticket
5 minTeacher
- Students complete the exit ticket individually. Collect to check understanding of evidence and the direction of energy transfer.
Students
- Complete the exit ticket.
Worked examples
Classifying a reaction from temperature data
Example results: a group's solution started at 22 °C and fell to 13 °C after adding bicarb soda. Calculate the change and classify the reaction.
- Change = final temperature − start temperature = 13 − 22 = −9 °C.
- The temperature fell by 9 °C, so the solution got colder.
- The reaction absorbed thermal energy from its surroundings (the water, cup and thermometer).
A 9 °C decrease: the reaction is endothermic.
Chemical or physical?
Decide whether each is a chemical or physical change and give the evidence: (a) wax melting; (b) a cut apple turning brown; (c) mixing two clear solutions that turn cloudy white.
- (a) Melting changes state from solid to liquid, but it is still wax and it can solidify again. No new substance.
- (b) The brown color is a new substance formed when substances in the apple react with oxygen in the air. Evidence: color change.
- (c) An insoluble solid has formed from two solutions. Evidence: a precipitate.
(a) Physical. (b) Chemical (color change). (c) Chemical (precipitate).
Practice & answers
Printable student sheet
Chemical Reactions Practice
Answer in full sentences. Questions 7 and 8 use these example results. Reaction A: start 21 °C, final 29 °C. Reaction B: start 20 °C, final 12 °C.
- 1Define a chemical change and give one everyday example.
- 2Define a physical change and give one everyday example.
- 3List four pieces of evidence that a chemical reaction may have taken place.
- 4Mei says, 'Boiling water makes bubbles, so boiling is a chemical change.' Explain why she is incorrect.
- 5Identify the reactants and products: citric acid + sodium hydrogen carbonate → sodium citrate + water + carbon dioxide.
- 6What is a precipitate? Describe how one forms in the Epsom salts and washing soda demonstration.
- 7Calculate the temperature change for Reaction A and Reaction B.
- 8Classify Reactions A and B as exothermic or endothermic, and describe the direction of energy transfer in each.
- 9Classify each as exothermic or endothermic: respiration, photosynthesis, burning natural gas, steel wool rusting.
- 10Jayden wants to test whether the amount of bicarb soda affects the temperature drop. Name the independent variable, the dependent variable and two controlled variables.
- 11Why is the start temperature recorded after the citric acid has dissolved, not before?
Show answersHide answers
- A change in which one or more new substances form. Examples: toast burning, iron rusting, an egg cooking, a cake baking, food being digested.
- A change in shape, size or state where no new substance forms. Examples: ice melting, water boiling, paper being cut, sugar dissolving.
- Gas produced (bubbles, fizzing or a new smell), color change, temperature change, a precipitate forming.
- The bubbles are water vapor, which is still water in the gas state. No new substance forms, so boiling is a physical change. Evidence such as bubbles suggests a reaction but does not prove one.
- Reactants: citric acid and sodium hydrogen carbonate. Products: sodium citrate, water and carbon dioxide.
- An insoluble solid formed when two solutions are mixed. When the clear magnesium sulfate and sodium carbonate solutions are mixed, insoluble white magnesium carbonate forms and the mixture turns cloudy.
- Reaction A: 29 − 21 = +8 °C (an increase of 8 °C). Reaction B: 12 − 20 = −8 °C (a decrease of 8 °C).
- A is exothermic: thermal energy is released from the reaction to the surroundings, so the temperature rises. B is endothermic: thermal energy is absorbed from the surroundings into the reaction, so the temperature falls.
- Respiration: exothermic. Photosynthesis: endothermic. Burning natural gas: exothermic. Steel wool rusting: exothermic.
- Independent: the mass or number of teaspoons of bicarb soda. Dependent: the temperature change. Controlled (any two): volume of water, amount of citric acid, starting temperature, type of cup, stirring, time before reading the thermometer.
- Dissolving citric acid can itself change the temperature slightly. Recording after it dissolves means the measured change is caused by the reaction with bicarb soda, not by dissolving.
Differentiation
Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.
Additional support
- Provide a partly completed results table with the formula 'change = final − start' and a sentence frame: 'The temperature went ___, so the reaction is ___ because thermal energy was ___ the surroundings.'
- Give a card sort of everyday changes with picture prompts and the headings Chemical and Physical.
- Pair the word equations with labeled diagrams showing reactants on the left and products on the right.
Core task
- Complete the practical and answer practice questions 1 to 9.
Extension challenge
- Answer questions 10 and 11, then plan the investigation in question 10 in full, including a results table.
- Explain, in terms of particles, why a precipitate is evidence that a new substance has formed.
- Research how instant cold packs and self-heating cans work, and decide which processes are chemical reactions and which are physical changes.
Assessment & exit ticket
Formative assessment
- Observe safe practice during the practical: safety glasses on, correct handling and clean-up.
- Check results tables for correct temperature change calculations and a correct classification.
- Use practice questions 4, 8 and 10 to assess understanding of evidence, energy transfer and variables.
- Sort exit tickets into secure / nearly / not yet to plan the next lesson.
Exit ticket
- Give one chemical change and one physical change, and explain how you can tell them apart.
- A reaction makes the test tube feel warm. Is it exothermic or endothermic? Which way is thermal energy moving?
- Name two pieces of evidence you saw today that a chemical reaction had occurred.
Show exit ticket answersHide answers
- For example, rusting (chemical) and melting ice (physical). In a chemical change a new substance forms; in a physical change no new substance forms.
- Exothermic. Thermal energy is released from the reaction to the surroundings (the test tube and your hand).
- Any two of: gas produced (fizzing, balloon inflating), temperature change (colder in the citric acid practical, warmer with steel wool), precipitate (cloudy white solid).
Common misconceptions
- Endothermic reactions 'produce cold'. Cold is not a substance. The reaction absorbs thermal energy from its surroundings, so the surroundings lose energy and their temperature falls.
- Dissolving is a chemical change. When salt or sugar dissolves, no new substance forms; the solute can be recovered by evaporation. Dissolving is a physical change.
- Any bubbles mean a chemical reaction. Boiling produces bubbles of water vapor, and fizzy drinks release dissolved carbon dioxide. Look for a new substance.
- Mass disappears when a gas is produced. The gas escapes into the air. In a sealed container, the total mass stays the same.
Extension
- Controlled comparison: repeat the practical with bicarb soda in water alone (no citric acid) and compare the temperature change, to separate dissolving from reacting.
- Chemical change in the kitchen: students list five changes that happen when cooking and classify each as chemical or physical with evidence.
Keep the learning going
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
More lesson plans
Living and Non-living Things: a School Grounds Hunt and Picture Card Sort
Students explore the school grounds to find living and non-living things, then sort picture cards and explain their thinking: living things grow, need food and water, and can make new living things like themselves. They finish by naming what plants and animals need to stay alive. Includes outdoor safety steps.
My Five Senses: Seeing, Hearing, Smelling, Tasting and Touching
Students name the five senses and the body parts we use for each, then explore safely at four stations: looking, listening, smelling and touching. They sort pictures by the sense they would use and learn that we often use more than one sense at a time. Tasting is talked about, not done, and clear rules keep everyone safe.
1st Grade Science: What Plants and Animals Need to Live, with a Bean Sprouting Investigation
Students learn the basic needs of animals (air, water, food and shelter) and plants (air, water, light and nutrients), sort picture cards, then set up a safe bean sprouting investigation comparing a seed with water and a seed without water, and record observations in a picture journal over the following week.
Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.