Skip to content
Home: Success TutoringTeachers

Grade 8 English Language Arts lesson plan · More English Language Arts resources

8th Grade STAAR Revising and Editing Review: Clarity, Concision, Sentence Boundaries, Pronoun Agreement and Commas

A STAAR-style revising and editing review: students practice revising an original student draft for clarity and concision, and editing it for fragments, comma splices, pronoun-antecedent agreement, unclear pronouns and comma rules. Each multiple-choice item includes the answer and why every distractor is wrong, plus worked examples and an exit ticket.

  • 60 minutes
  • Grade 8
  • English Language Arts
  • Revising and editing a draft
  • 🇺🇸 United States

By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources

Download PDF

Overview

Learning objectives

Students will…

  • Revise sentences for clarity (unclear pronouns) and concision (wordy or repeated phrases) without changing the writer's meaning.
  • Correct sentence boundary errors: fragments, run-ons and comma splices.
  • Edit for pronoun-antecedent agreement and for comma rules, including nonessential clauses, compound sentences and unnecessary commas, and explain why each distractor is wrong.

Success criteria

Students can say…

  • I can find the antecedent of a pronoun and check that they agree in number.
  • I can spot a pronoun that could refer to two people and fix it.
  • I can cut wordy or repeated phrases while keeping the meaning.
  • I can fix fragments and comma splices in more than one correct way.
  • I can explain why each wrong answer choice is wrong.

Curriculum focus: Writing — Composition: Revising and Editing · State standards (Texas TEKS first)

Specific curriculum codes are added once our team has checked them against the official documents. How we align resources

This is a review lesson written in the style of STAAR reading language arts questions. The passages, drafts and questions are original and are not official STAAR material, and the scoring guides are classroom guides, not the official STAAR rubrics. Released STAAR tests and scoring information are published by the Texas Education Agency.

More Texas teacher resources (TEKS and STAAR)

Key vocabulary

concision
Saying something clearly in as few words as needed, without repeated or empty phrases.
antecedent
The noun a pronoun refers to. In 'The tires were flat, so we patched them', the antecedent of 'them' is 'tires'.
pronoun-antecedent agreement
A pronoun must match its antecedent in number: singular with singular, plural with plural.
unclear pronoun
A pronoun that could refer to more than one noun, so the reader cannot tell who or what it means.
fragment
A group of words punctuated as a sentence that is missing a subject, a verb or a complete thought (for example, a dependent clause on its own).
comma splice
Two independent clauses joined with only a comma.
nonessential clause
A clause that adds extra information but is not needed to identify the noun; it is set off with commas.

In the glossary: clause, comma, comma splice, complex sentence, compound sentence, coordinating conjunction, editing, main clause, pronoun, revising, run-on sentence, semicolon, sentence fragment, subordinate clause

Materials & preparation

You will need

  • Mateo's draft (in the Preparation notes), printed with numbered sentences — one copy per student
  • An anchor chart of the five skills with one example each (see Preparation)
  • Mini whiteboards and markers
  • The practice sheet and exit ticket (printable)

Before the lesson

  1. Print Mateo's draft — 'Fix It, Don't Toss It': Paragraph 1: (1) On the first Saturday of every month, the cafeteria at Pine Hill Middle School turns into a repair café. (2) Neighbors bring in broken lamps and torn backpacks, and volunteers help them fix the items for free. (3) The café was the idea of one of our teachers. (4) Ms. Duarte who teaches science wanted students to see that many broken things can be repaired. Paragraph 2: (5) Before the first event, the volunteers spent weeks preparing. (6) They collected donated tools, they made posters for the library and the grocery store. (7) In my opinion, I think that the posters were the most important part of the preparation because, in fact, they were what brought people to the café in the first place. (8) When the doors opened at nine o'clock on the first Saturday. (9) A line of people was already waiting outside. Paragraph 3: (10) Some repairs were simple. (11) Three bicycles arrived with flat tires, so the volunteers patched it in less than an hour. (12) Other repairs took longer. (13) A neighbor brought a radio that had not worked for years, and a volunteer spent most of the morning testing its wires. (14) When the radio finally crackled to life, the neighbor and the volunteer laughed, and he said it was the best part of his week. Paragraph 4: (15) Repairing things, saves money and keeps useful items out of landfills. (16) It also teaches skills. (17) Students who volunteer learn how to use tools and how to explain their thinking to adults. (18) Thanks to the repair café, many people in our neighborhood now try to fix things before they throw them away.
  2. Teacher key to the issues in Mateo's draft (do not print for students): sentence 4 needs commas around a nonessential clause; sentence 6 is a comma splice; sentence 7 is wordy; sentence 8 is a fragment; sentence 11 has a pronoun-antecedent error; sentence 14 has an unclear pronoun; sentence 15 has an unnecessary comma between the subject and the verb; sentence 13 is correct; the draft needs a concluding sentence after sentence 18.
  3. Make the anchor chart: Clarity: 'Kai told Liam he won.' (Who won?) → 'Kai told Liam, "You won."' Concision: 'due to the fact that' → 'because'. Sentence boundaries: 'Although it rained. We played.' → 'Although it rained, we played.' Agreement: 'The bikes had flat tires, so we fixed it.' → '…fixed them.' Commas: 'My aunt, who lives in Austin, visited.' (extra information: commas) / 'The girl who won the race is my cousin.' (needed to identify the girl: no commas).

Lesson sequence

  1. 1

    Hook: how many words can you cut?

    5 min

    Teacher

    • Write: 'In my opinion I think that the reason why the game was canceled is because of the fact that the field was flooded.'
    • Ask: 'Is this sentence wrong, or just weak?' Agree that it is grammatical but wordy. Ask pairs to cut it to the fewest words that keep the meaning. Share the best version: 'The game was canceled because the field was flooded.'
    • Say: 'STAAR reading language arts tests include questions about student drafts. Some ask you to edit errors; others ask you to revise sentences that are correct but unclear or wordy. The best answer is correct, clear, concise and keeps the writer's meaning.'

    Students

    • Cut the wordy sentence down with a partner and count the words saved.
  2. 2

    Explicit teaching: five skills with worked examples

    15 min

    Teacher

    • Teach the routine: 'Read the whole draft for meaning. For each question, read the sentence and its neighbors. Decide what is wrong before you look at the choices. Test each choice in the draft. Eliminate choices that create a new error, change the meaning, or fix something that was not broken.'
    • Sentence boundaries. Model Worked example 1. Say: 'A dependent clause starting with although, because, when or if cannot stand alone. Attach it to an independent clause with a comma when it comes first.' Show three fixes for a comma splice: a period, a comma plus a coordinating conjunction (and, but, so), or a semicolon.
    • Agreement and clarity. Model Worked example 2. Say: 'Draw an arrow from each pronoun to its antecedent. If the arrow lands on a plural noun, the pronoun must be plural. If the arrow could land on two nouns, the pronoun is unclear: replace it with the noun.'
    • Concision. Model Worked example 3. List common wordy phrases: 'in my opinion, I think', 'due to the fact that', 'the reason why … is because', 'in fact', 'in order to'.
    • Commas. Say: 'Use commas around extra information that is not needed to identify the noun: "Ms. Duarte, who teaches science, …" Use a comma before and, but or so when it joins two independent clauses. Never put a single comma between a subject and its verb.'

    Students

    • Try each skill on whiteboards as it is modeled.
    • Draw antecedent arrows on the sample sentences.
  3. 3

    Guided practice: questions 1–4

    12 min

    Teacher

    • Students read Mateo's whole draft once for meaning.
    • Pairs answer practice questions 1–4. For each, ask: 'What is wrong before you look? Which distractor creates a new error? Which changes the meaning?'
    • Highlight that sentence boundary questions often have more than one possible correct fix in real writing, but only one correct choice among the options.

    Students

    • Answer questions 1–4 with a partner, writing the reason each distractor is wrong.
  4. 4

    Independent practice: questions 5–9

    20 min

    Teacher

    • Students answer questions 5–9 on their own.
    • Remind them: 'One sentence in this set is already correct. Do not change what is not broken.'
    • Work with the support group on antecedent arrows for questions 5 and 6.

    Students

    • Answer questions 5–9, with a reason for each answer and each eliminated choice.
  5. 5

    Review and exit ticket

    8 min

    Teacher

    • Go over questions 6 and 8. Say: 'Question 6 had an unclear pronoun; question 8 had nothing wrong. Both test whether you check carefully instead of guessing.'
    • Students complete the exit ticket on their own.

    Students

    • Complete the exit ticket.

Worked examples

Fixing a fragment

Fix the sentence boundary error: 'Although the storm had passed. The power stayed off until evening.'

  1. Test the first group of words: 'Although the storm had passed' starts with 'although', so it is a dependent clause and cannot stand alone. It is a fragment.
  2. Attach it to the independent clause that follows.
  3. When the dependent clause comes first, put a comma after it.

'Although the storm had passed, the power stayed off until evening.'

Agreement and clarity

Fix both sentences: (a) 'Every one of the bikes had their chain oiled.' (b) 'When Kai handed the ball to Liam, he dropped it.'

  1. (a) Find the antecedent: 'one' (of the bikes). 'One' is singular and refers to a thing, so the pronoun must be 'its'.
  2. (b) Draw arrows from 'he': it could point to Kai or Liam. The pronoun is unclear.
  3. Decide who dropped the ball (say, Liam) and name him, or restructure the sentence.

(a) 'Every one of the bikes had its chain oiled.' (b) 'When Kai handed the ball to Liam, Liam dropped it.' or 'Liam dropped the ball when Kai handed it to him.'

Making a sentence concise

Revise for concision: 'The reason why the game was canceled is because of the fact that the field was flooded.'

  1. Find the empty phrases: 'The reason why … is because of the fact that'.
  2. Keep the two ideas that matter: the game was canceled; the field was flooded.
  3. Join them with one clear word that shows cause: 'because'.

'The game was canceled because the field was flooded.'

Practice & answers

Printable student sheet

Revising and Editing Review: 'Fix It, Don't Toss It'

Read Mateo's draft, then answer each question. Choose the best answer and write why each wrong choice is wrong.

  1. 1What change should be made in sentence 4? A Insert commas after Duarte and after science. B Insert a comma after Duarte only. C Insert a comma after science only. D No change is needed.
  2. 2What is the best way to revise sentence 6? A They collected donated tools, and they made posters for the library and the grocery store. B They collected donated tools they made posters for the library and the grocery store. C They collected donated tools. And made posters for the library and the grocery store. D They collected donated tools, made posters, for the library and the grocery store.
  3. 3Which revision of sentence 7 is the most concise while keeping Mateo's meaning? A The posters were the most important part of the preparation because they brought people to the café. B In my opinion, I think the posters were important because, in fact, they brought people. C I think that, in my opinion, the posters were, in fact, the most important part. D The posters were important.
  4. 4What is the best way to combine sentences 8 and 9? A When the doors opened at nine o'clock on the first Saturday, a line of people was already waiting outside. B When the doors opened at nine o'clock on the first Saturday a line of people. Was already waiting outside. C When the doors opened at nine o'clock on the first Saturday, and a line of people was already waiting outside. D The doors opened at nine o'clock on the first Saturday, a line of people was already waiting outside.
  5. 5What change should be made in sentence 11? A Change arrived to arrives. B Change it to them. C Change it to they. D No change is needed.
  6. 6Mateo wants to make sentence 14 clearer. Which revision best does this? A When the radio finally crackled to life, the neighbor and the volunteer laughed, and the neighbor said it was the best part of his week. B When the radio finally crackled to life, the neighbor and the volunteer laughed, and they said it was the best part of his week. C When the radio finally crackled to life, the neighbor and the volunteer laughed, and he said it was the best part of his whole entire week. D When the radio finally crackled to life, the neighbor and the volunteer laughed, and someone said it was the best part.
  7. 7What change should be made in sentence 15? A Delete the comma after things. B Change saves to save. C Insert a comma after money. D No change is needed.
  8. 8What change, if any, should be made in sentence 13? A Delete the comma after years. B Change its to it's. C Change its to their. D No change is needed.
  9. 9Mateo wants to add a concluding sentence after sentence 18 that supports the main idea of the draft. Which sentence best does this? A A broken lamp does not have to become trash; with a few tools and a little help, it can shine again. B My favorite repair was a lamp. C Landfills can be found in many parts of the world. D Ms. Duarte teaches science at Pine Hill.
Show answers
  1. A. 'Who teaches science' is a nonessential clause: the name Ms. Duarte already identifies her, so the clause is extra information and needs a comma on both sides: 'Ms. Duarte, who teaches science, wanted…'. B opens the clause with a comma but never closes it. C does not open the clause and puts a single comma between the subject and its verb. D is wrong because the nonessential clause must be set off with commas.
  2. A. A comma and the conjunction 'and' correctly join the two independent clauses. B is a run-on with no punctuation between the clauses. C creates a fragment ('And made posters…' has no subject). D adds a comma that separates 'posters' from 'for the library', which changes the meaning so it sounds as if the tools were for the library too.
  3. A. It removes the repeated and empty phrases ('In my opinion, I think', 'in fact', 'what … in the first place') and keeps both ideas: the posters mattered most, and why. B keeps the repetition ('In my opinion, I think') and weakens 'most important' to 'important'. C keeps the wordiness and drops the reason. D is concise but loses the reason and the idea that the posters were the MOST important part.
  4. A. The dependent clause ('When the doors opened…') is attached to an independent clause with a comma. B still has a fragment and splits the subject from its verb. C adds 'and', which leaves the whole sentence as a dependent clause, so it is still a fragment. D removes 'When' and creates a comma splice.
  5. B. The volunteers patched the 'tires' (plural), so the pronoun must be plural: 'them'. A shifts the tense from past to present and does not fix the agreement error. C is plural but is a subject pronoun; after the verb 'patched', the object pronoun 'them' is needed. D is wrong because the singular 'it' does not agree with its plural antecedent.
  6. A. In the original, 'he' could mean the neighbor or the volunteer. Naming 'the neighbor' removes the confusion. B changes the meaning (now both people speak) and 'his' is still unclear. C keeps the unclear 'he' and adds wordiness ('whole entire'). D replaces the unclear pronoun with the even vaguer 'someone'.
  7. A. 'Repairing things' is the subject of the sentence, and a single comma should never separate a subject from its verb. B is wrong because the gerund subject 'Repairing things' is singular, so 'saves' is correct. C is wrong because 'saves money and keeps useful items' is a compound verb sharing one subject, so no comma is needed before 'and'. D is wrong because the comma is an error.
  8. D. Sentence 13 is correct. A would remove the comma needed before 'and' when it joins two independent clauses. B is wrong because 'it's' means 'it is', and 'testing it is wires' makes no sense; 'its' is the possessive. C is wrong because the antecedent 'radio' is singular, so the singular 'its' is correct.
  9. A. It returns to the central idea that repairing things is better than throwing them away, and it ends with a memorable image. B is a personal detail that does not wrap up the draft. C is general information that is off-topic. D repeats a detail from paragraph 1 and does not conclude the main idea.

Differentiation

Offer tasks by choice or quietly by invitation — avoid labelling groups by ability in front of the class.

Additional support

  • Tell students which skill each question tests before they answer.
  • Provide an antecedent-arrow version of sentences 11 and 14 with the pronouns already circled.
  • Give a wordy-phrase list to cross out for question 3.
  • Start with questions 2, 4, 5 and 8, then add the rest.

Core task

  • Answer all nine questions and explain why each distractor is wrong.

Extension challenge

  • Rewrite paragraph 2 of Mateo's draft with every error fixed and at least one sentence made more concise.
  • Write a revising question about sentence 16 ('It also teaches skills.') that asks how to make it clearer, with four choices and an explanation for each.
  • Find a sentence in your own recent writing that is wordy, revise it, and count the words you saved.

Assessment & exit ticket

Formative assessment

  • Check that students can explain distractors in terms of the rule ('creates a comma splice', 'changes the meaning'), not just 'it sounds wrong'.
  • Note who chooses a change for sentence 13; reteach the habit of testing whether anything is actually wrong.
  • Use the exit ticket to check transfer to new sentences.

Exit ticket

  1. Choose the correct pronoun: 'The scientists published (its / their) results.'
  2. Fix the comma splice in two different ways: 'The bus was late, we missed the first act.'
  3. Revise for concision: 'Due to the fact that it was raining, we stayed inside.'
Show exit ticket answers
  1. 'their' — the antecedent 'scientists' is plural.
  2. Any two of: 'The bus was late, so we missed the first act.' / 'The bus was late. We missed the first act.' / 'The bus was late; we missed the first act.' / 'Because the bus was late, we missed the first act.'
  3. 'Because it was raining, we stayed inside.'

Common misconceptions

  • A long sentence is a run-on. A run-on is two independent clauses joined incorrectly, not a long sentence. Long sentences can be correct.
  • Adding 'and' fixes every fragment. 'When the doors opened, and a line was waiting' is still a fragment, because 'When' makes the whole thing dependent.
  • A comma goes wherever you would pause. Commas follow rules; a pause after a long subject does not need a comma before the verb.
  • 'It' can refer to a group of things. A plural antecedent needs a plural pronoun ('them', 'they', 'their').
  • The most concise choice is always correct. The best revision is concise AND keeps all of the writer's meaning.
  • Every sentence in a question has an error. 'No change is needed' is sometimes correct.

Extension

  • Concision challenge: give a deliberately wordy paragraph and award points for every word cut without losing meaning.
  • Comma court: students bring one sentence with commas from their reading and argue which rule each comma follows.

Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.

More lesson plans

Need a timer for this lesson? Open the Classroom Timer or make random groups.