Reading comprehension
Detective Questions: Who, What, Where, When, Why, How
Students read an original mystery passage, then act as detectives: they write their own who, what, where, when, why and how questions, swap with a partner and answer with evidence. Includes the passage, model questions and answers.
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Setup
- Print one sheet per student.
- Write the six question words down the side of the board: Who? What? Where? When? Why? How?
- Next to them write the detective rule: A good detective question can be answered using clues in the text.
How to run the activity
- 1Say: 'Detectives solve cases by asking good questions. Today you will read a short mystery, then you will be the one writing the questions.'
- 2Read the passage aloud while students follow on their sheets. Then students reread it silently or with a partner.
- 3Model a who question and a why question. Say: 'Who checked the strawberry patch every morning? I can find the answer in paragraph 1: Priya. That is a right-there question.' Then: 'Why did the friends spread flour on the path? That answer is in paragraph 3, but I have to read carefully.'
- 4Students write one question for each of the six question words in their books (10 minutes). Remind them: 'You must know the answer and be able to point to the sentence that proves it.'
- 5Students highlight the sentence in the passage that answers each of their questions and write the paragraph number next to each question.
- 6Pairs swap books and answer each other's questions. The writer checks each answer against the evidence they highlighted.
- 7Bring the class together. Ask: 'Which question was hardest to answer? Why?' Draw out that 'why' and 'how' questions often need the reader to think, not just find.
- 8Finish with the two detective challenge questions from the sheet as a whole-class discussion, asking students to give evidence for every answer.
Learning outcomes
- Generate literal and inferential questions about a text using question words.
- Locate evidence in a text to support an answer.
- Make inferences by combining clues in the text with what they already know.
Printable student sheet
The Case of the Vanishing Strawberries
Read the mystery. Then write one question for each question word, and highlight the sentence that proves each answer.
- 1Paragraph 1: Every morning before school, Priya checked the strawberry patch in the school garden. On Tuesday, she noticed something strange. Four ripe strawberries had disappeared, and the leaves beside them were torn.
- 2Paragraph 2: At recess, Priya told her friend Tama. 'Someone is eating our strawberries,' she said. Tama thought it might be a student from another class, but Priya was not so sure. The missing strawberries had all been growing low down, close to the ground.
- 3Paragraph 3: That afternoon, the two friends sprinkled a thin layer of flour on the path around the patch, so that anything walking there would leave footprints. They also hung a sign on the garden gate: 'Investigation in progress. Please keep out!'
- 4Paragraph 4: On Wednesday morning, they hurried to the garden. In the flour were dozens of tiny prints, each with four thin toes. The prints wandered around the strawberry plants and then simply stopped in the middle of the path. There were no shoe prints anywhere.
- 5Paragraph 5: 'It wasn't a person at all,' said Priya, staring at the place where the trail ended. 'Our thief can fly!' The friends borrowed a net from the sports shed and draped it over the patch. By Friday, not one more strawberry had gone missing, and Priya picked a bowl of ripe ones to show the class.
- 6Write a Who question and its answer.
- 7Write a What question and its answer.
- 8Write a Where question and its answer.
- 9Write a When question and its answer.
- 10Write a Why question and its answer.
- 11Write a How question and its answer.
- 12Detective challenge 1: Why did Priya decide the thief could fly? Use two clues.
- 13Detective challenge 2: Why do you think Priya was 'not so sure' that a student was eating the strawberries?
Show answers and teacher guidanceHide answers
- Key clues: who (Priya), where (the school garden), when (Tuesday morning), what (four strawberries missing, torn leaves).
- Key clues: Tama suspects a student (a false lead). Priya doubts it. The low strawberries suggest a small visitor.
- Key clues: how they investigated (flour to catch footprints), why (to see who or what walked there), and the sign keeps people away so any prints are not from students.
- Key clues: four thin toes (not a shoe), the trail stops suddenly (the visitor left without walking away), no shoe prints (not a person).
- Key clues: Priya works out the thief can fly, so it was a bird. The net worked, which supports her theory.
- Model: 'Who checked the strawberry patch every morning?' Priya (paragraph 1). Or: 'Who did Tama think was eating the strawberries?' A student from another class (paragraph 2).
- Model: 'What did the friends find in the flour on Wednesday?' Dozens of tiny prints with four thin toes (paragraph 4).
- Model: 'Where did the trail of prints stop?' In the middle of the path (paragraph 4). Or: 'Where did they get the net?' The sports shed (paragraph 5).
- Model: 'When did Priya first notice strawberries were missing?' On Tuesday morning, before school (paragraph 1). Or: 'When did they spread the flour?' Tuesday afternoon (paragraph 3).
- Model: 'Why did the friends sprinkle flour on the path?' So that anything walking there would leave footprints (paragraph 3).
- Model: 'How did the friends protect the strawberries?' They covered the patch with a net from the sports shed (paragraph 5).
- The prints stopped suddenly in the middle of the path, so the visitor left without walking away; and the prints had four thin toes and there were no shoe prints, so it was not a person. A bird fits both clues.
- Accept reasoned answers, e.g. only the low strawberries close to the ground were taken, which suggests a small animal rather than a person, who could reach any of them.
Variations
- Question dice: number the question words 1 to 6 and roll the Dice & Random Number tool to choose which question each student writes next.
- Any text: use the same routine with a class novel chapter or a non-fiction article.
- Quiz the teacher: students ask you their best questions and decide whether your answer has enough evidence.
Extension
- Write a sixth paragraph that explains what the friends did next, then write two new questions about it.
- Sort your six questions into 'right there' (answer is in one sentence) and 'think and search' (answer needs clues from more than one place).
Additional support
- Give question starters: 'Who…?', 'What did… find?', 'Where was…?', 'When did…?', 'Why did… decide to…?', 'How did… solve…?'
- Students write three questions (who, what, where) instead of six, and answer the model questions on the sheet.
Extension challenge
- Each 'why' and 'how' question must need clues from two different paragraphs to answer.
Teacher notes
- The passage is original and written for this activity. The prints with four thin toes and a trail that simply stops are the key inference clues: the visitor was a bird that flew away.
- Students often write 'why' questions whose answers are not in the text. Ask: 'Where is the proof?' If there isn't any, help them turn it into a 'what do you think' discussion question instead.
Pair it with
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
Printable worksheets
More reading comprehension
Comprehension Question Dice for Any Text
Small groups roll a die to choose a comprehension job (predict, clarify, question, summarise, connect or evaluate) and discuss a shared text. Works with any picture book, novel chapter or article, with printable prompt cards and model answers.
Fact or Opinion Sort
Students sort 16 original statements about octopuses into fact, opinion or both, using clue words and the test 'Could I check this?'. Includes a tricky false fact and a full answer key with reasons.
Hot Seat Character Interview
A student sits in the 'hot seat' in role as a character from a shared text and answers the class's questions in character. Question stems push beyond plot recall into motives, feelings and choices, building inference and empathy before writing.