Reading comprehension
Fact or Opinion Sort
Students sort 16 original statements about octopuses into fact, opinion or both, using clue words and the test 'Could I check this?'. Includes a tricky false fact and a full answer key with reasons.
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Setup
- Print one statement sheet per pair.
- Draw a three-column table on the board headed Fact, Opinion and Both.
- Write the two tests on the board: Fact: Could I check it in a reliable book or by observing? Opinion: Is it what someone thinks or feels? Could someone reasonably disagree?
- Write these opinion clue words on the board: best, worst, most, should, cute, creepy, fun, interesting, I think.
How to run the activity
- 1Say: 'A fact is something that can be checked and proven. An opinion is what someone thinks or feels, and other people could disagree.'
- 2Model two statements from the sheet. Statement 1: 'An octopus has eight arms. Could I check it? Yes, in any animal book. Fact.' Statement 2: 'Octopuses are the most amazing animals in the ocean. Could someone disagree? Yes, a shark fan might! And I can see the clue word most. Opinion.'
- 3Pairs colour-code statements 3 to 16: one colour for fact, one for opinion, and one for statements that contain both. They must agree before colouring.
- 4Circulate and listen for reasoning. Prompt: 'How could you check that? Which word tells you it is someone's opinion?'
- 5Stop the class at statement 11 ('An octopus has ten arms') if pairs are stuck. Ask: 'Is it true? Can it be checked? So is it a fact-type statement or an opinion?' Draw out that it is a statement of fact that turns out to be false when checked.
- 6Go through the answers, with pairs giving reasons. Write a few in the table on the board.
- 7Finish: each student writes one fact and one opinion of their own about an animal they like, swaps with a partner, and the partner identifies which is which.
Learning outcomes
- Distinguish between statements of fact and opinions.
- Identify language that signals an opinion.
- Understand that a factual statement can be checked, and may turn out to be true or false.
Printable student sheet
Fact or Opinion: Octopuses
Colour each statement: one colour for FACT, one for OPINION, and one for statements that are BOTH. Ask: Could I check it? Could someone reasonably disagree?
- 1An octopus has eight arms.
- 2Octopuses are the most amazing animals in the ocean.
- 3An octopus has three hearts.
- 4An octopus has no bones in its body.
- 5Octopuses look creepy.
- 6Many octopuses can change the colour of their skin in less than a second.
- 7It would be fun to keep an octopus as a class pet.
- 8Many octopuses can squirt a cloud of ink to escape from predators.
- 9Octopus blood is blue.
- 10Watching an octopus is more interesting than watching a dolphin.
- 11An octopus has ten arms.
- 12Octopuses have suckers on their arms.
- 13Everyone should learn about octopuses at school.
- 14The best colour for an octopus is red.
- 15Octopuses have eight arms, and they are the cutest creatures in the sea.
- 16Scientists have seen octopuses unscrew the lids of jars.
Show answers and teacher guidanceHide answers
- Fact. It can be checked in any reliable animal reference book.
- Opinion. 'Most amazing' is a judgement; others might choose a different animal.
- Fact. Scientists have confirmed this: two hearts pump blood through the gills and one pumps it around the body.
- Fact. Octopuses are invertebrates with soft bodies, which lets them squeeze through small gaps.
- Opinion. 'Creepy' is a feeling; many people think octopuses look beautiful.
- Fact. This has been observed and filmed by scientists.
- Opinion. 'Fun' is a judgement, and others could disagree (it would also be very hard to care for one).
- Fact. This can be checked in reference books and has been observed in the wild.
- Fact. Octopus blood uses copper to carry oxygen, which makes it blue.
- Opinion. 'More interesting' depends on the person.
- Statement of fact, but false. It can be checked, and checking shows an octopus has eight arms. Accept 'fact-type statement that is wrong' as the best answer.
- Fact. The suckers help them grip, taste and feel.
- Opinion. The clue word 'should' tells us it is what someone thinks ought to happen.
- Opinion. 'Best' is a judgement; there is no way to prove one colour is best.
- Both. The first part is a fact that can be checked; 'cutest' is an opinion.
- Fact. It describes something that was observed and recorded, so it can be checked.
Variations
- Stand up, sit down: read each statement aloud; students stand for fact and sit for opinion, then justify.
- Cut and sort: pairs cut the statements into strips and sort them into three piles.
- Topic swap: write 10 statements about your current science or history topic for the same routine.
Extension
- Rewrite three opinions as facts, e.g. 'Octopuses look creepy' becomes 'Octopuses have soft bodies with no bones.'
- Write a short persuasive paragraph about octopuses using at least two facts to support one opinion.
Additional support
- Sort only into fact and opinion (leave out 'both' and statement 11).
- Highlight the opinion clue words on the board in the same colour students use for opinion.
Extension challenge
- Students explain why statement 16 is a fact even though it is about what scientists saw, and decide what makes a source of facts reliable.
Teacher notes
- All factual statements have been checked. Octopuses really do have three hearts and blue, copper-based blood, and have been observed unscrewing jar lids in aquariums.
- Statement 11 is deliberately false. It is a good chance to teach that 'fact' means 'can be checked', and checking is how we find out whether a claim is true.
- Some students will argue 'Octopuses are clever' is a fact. That statement is not on the sheet, but it is a good discussion: scientists measure problem-solving, so a precise version can be a fact.
Pair it with
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
Printable worksheets
Interactive games
More reading comprehension
Comprehension Question Dice for Any Text
Small groups roll a die to choose a comprehension job (predict, clarify, question, summarise, connect or evaluate) and discuss a shared text. Works with any picture book, novel chapter or article, with printable prompt cards and model answers.
Detective Questions: Who, What, Where, When, Why, How
Students read an original mystery passage, then act as detectives: they write their own who, what, where, when, why and how questions, swap with a partner and answer with evidence. Includes the passage, model questions and answers.
Hot Seat Character Interview
A student sits in the 'hot seat' in role as a character from a shared text and answers the class's questions in character. Question stems push beyond plot recall into motives, feelings and choices, building inference and empathy before writing.