Critical thinking
Would You Rather… and Why?
Students choose between two fun options and must justify their choice using reasoning frames, then respond respectfully to someone who chose differently. Twelve classroom-appropriate prompts with reasons for both sides.
By the Success Tutoring Teachers team · Updated · Educator review in progress · How we make our resources
Setup
- Write these reasoning frames on the board: I would rather… because…, One reason is… Another reason is…, I agree with… but I also think…, I can see why you chose… However…
- If using movement, stick the 'Option A' and 'Option B' signs on opposite walls.
How to run the activity
- 1Read a prompt aloud. Give 20 seconds of silent thinking time: 'Decide, and think of one reason.'
- 2Students show their choice: move to a side of the room, hold up one or two fingers, or point to the sign.
- 3Pair students with someone nearby. Each says their choice using a reasoning frame (30 seconds each).
- 4Take two or three answers from each side. Push for depth: 'Can you give a second reason?' 'What might go wrong with your choice?'
- 5Invite anyone to change sides if they heard a convincing reason, and ask what convinced them.
- 6Repeat for 3–5 prompts. Finish with: 'Whose reason was the most convincing today, even if you disagreed?'
Learning outcomes
- Make a choice and justify it with at least one clear reason.
- Consider advantages and disadvantages of each option.
- Respond respectfully to a different point of view.
Printable student sheet
Would You Rather… and Why?
Choose one option. Write or say your reason using a reasoning frame: 'I would rather… because…'
- 11. Would you rather be able to talk to animals or speak every human language?
- 22. Would you rather have a lesson outdoors every day or have a class pet?
- 33. Would you rather be able to fly or be invisible?
- 44. Would you rather explore the deep ocean or outer space?
- 55. Would you rather read the book first or watch the film first?
- 66. Would you rather be the best player in a losing team or an average player in a winning team?
- 77. Would you rather have a robot that does your chores or a robot that helps with homework?
- 88. Would you rather live where it is always summer or always winter?
- 99. Would you rather invent something that helps the planet or discover a new species?
- 1010. Would you rather solve a puzzle on your own or with a team?
- 1111. Would you rather be able to pause time or rewind time by ten seconds?
- 1212. Would you rather design a new playground or a new school lunch menu?
Show answers and teacher guidanceHide answers
- Possible reasons: animals: learn what pets and wildlife need, help protect them. Languages: talk to anyone in the world, help people communicate.
- Possible reasons: outdoors: fresh air, more space, learning about nature. Class pet: learn responsibility, calming. Challenge: what about rainy days or allergies?
- Possible reasons: fly: travel fast, see the world from above. Invisible: observe without being noticed. Push: which is more useful for helping others?
- Possible reasons: ocean: undiscovered creatures, closer to home. Space: other planets, seeing Earth from afar. Both have extreme conditions to consider.
- Possible reasons: book: imagine characters yourself, more detail. Film: helps you picture the story, then the book adds depth.
- Possible reasons: best player: personal skill, chance to lead. Winning team: shared success, learn from others. Good prompt for discussing teamwork.
- Possible reasons: chores: more free time. Homework: but would you still learn? Push students to consider learning vs convenience.
- Possible reasons: summer: beach, outdoor play, long days. Winter: snow, warm indoor activities. Consider: what about plants, animals and farming?
- Possible reasons: invent: solve a big problem for everyone. Discover: add to scientific knowledge, help protect it. Both involve curiosity and persistence.
- Possible reasons: alone: work at your own pace, quiet. Team: more ideas, share the challenge. Links to how students like to learn.
- Possible reasons: pause: extra thinking time, rest. Rewind: fix mistakes. Push: could either be used unfairly? What rules would you need?
- Possible reasons: playground: more fun and active play for everyone. Menu: healthier or tastier food. Push: how would you find out what other students want?
Variations
- Seated version: use thumbs up (A) or thumbs sideways (B) instead of moving.
- Curriculum link: write prompts from your topic, e.g. 'Would you rather live in the desert or the rainforest?' after a geography unit.
- Written exit ticket: students choose one prompt and write a paragraph with two reasons and a counter-argument.
- Devil's advocate: students must argue for the option they did not choose.
Extension
- Students write their own 'would you rather' prompt where both options are equally tempting, and explain what makes it hard.
- Hold a two-minute mini-debate with three speakers per side.
Additional support
- Offer a bank of reason words: faster, safer, more fun, more useful, kinder, easier.
- Let students draw their choice and tell a partner one reason.
Extension challenge
- Require reasons that consider other people or long-term consequences, not just personal preference.
Teacher notes
- Prompts avoid topics linked to money, family, appearance or home circumstances, so no student feels exposed by their answer.
- There is no right answer: praise the quality of reasoning, not the choice.
- Inclusion: if movement is difficult for any student, use the seated signal version for the whole class.
Pair it with
Free resources from other Success Tutoring sites that match this topic.
More critical thinking
Fact or Opinion Sort
Students sort 16 original statements about octopuses into fact, opinion or both, using clue words and the test 'Could I check this?'. Includes a tricky false fact and a full answer key with reasons.
Four Corners: Take a Stand
Students walk to the Strongly agree, Agree, Disagree or Strongly disagree corner for a statement, discuss their reasons with their corner, then share and respond to other corners. A bank of 18 statements in three age bands builds reasoning and respectful disagreement.
Gallery Walk with Sticky-Note Feedback
Posters, work samples or big questions go up around the room like an art gallery. Small groups rotate on a timer, reading and leaving sticky-note feedback using a clear protocol, then return to respond. Includes three feedback protocols and a printable feedback sheet.